Cities Have a Green Infrastructure Blind Spot
Carbon footprint standards exist for buildings, but not for the landscaping that surrounds them

June 22, 2021 by Anthropocene
Cities Have a Green Infrastructure Blind Spot

This article is by Sara DeWeerdt and was originally published by Anthropocene magazine.

Green infrastructure has a lot of benefits: nature can improve people’s mental and physical health; vegetation helps reduce building energy use by providing insulation and cooling; and plants and soils store carbon.

The problem is there’s no way of evaluating whether green infrastructure projects really live up to their promises. How much carbon does a street tree actually sequester? And what’s the greenhouse gas impact of growing seedlings in nurseries, assembling the raw materials for potting soil, and transporting mulch to where it needs to go?

The solution, according to a group of researchers in Finland: develop carbon footprint standards (known as Environmental Product Declarations or EPDs) for plants, soils, and mulches similar to those that already exist for building materials. This would provide an objective check of cities’ and developers’ claims about the environmental benefits of green infrastructure projects, and help landscape designers plan, construct, and maintain green spaces in the most climate-friendly way.

“Landscape designers will need to know how much carbon typical plants and growing media can sequester. This should be seen as basic product information that enables us to mitigate climate change,” says study team member Matti Kuittinen, adjunct professor of architecture at the University of Aalto in Finland.

But that basic information isn’t so simple to assemble. As a first step to developing such standards, Kuittinen and his colleagues analyzed how carbon flows through plants, soils, and mulches in different phases of their life cycle. Based on this analysis, it’s clear that standard methods for assessing the carbon footprint of building materials will need to be tweaked when applied to components of green infrastructure, the researchers report in the International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment.

One challenge: plants are alive. So the amount of carbon stored when, for example, young shrubs are planted in a park may not correspond to the amount stored years later after they’ve grown to maturity. The upshot is that applying conventional life cycle analysis approaches to green infrastructure could actually be misleading and suggest that plants are a climate burden.

On the plus side, there are already widely used methods for modeling the carbon stock of trees and carbon storage in urban forests. “Bushes, herbaceous plants and their carbon dynamics with soil are clearly more challenging,” says Kuittinen.

One source of complexity is that neither soils nor mulches have a clearly defined “end of life” stage: soil might be removed from a site and deposited elsewhere, but it’s still soil; mulch decomposes over time, yet there’s no clear demarcation of when it ceases to be mulch and becomes something else. The researchers couldn’t find any established methods for modeling the environmental impact of mulches.

But one step at a time, says Kuittinen: “Next steps in translating our findings into EPDs will be compilation of data on the carbon uptake potential of bushes. We will start to gather samples and measure their carbon contents,” he reports.


Anthropocene magazine, published by Future Earth,  gathers the worlds’ best minds to explore how we might create a Human Age that we actually want to live in. 

Sarah DeWeerdt is a Seattle-based freelance science journalist specializing in biology, medicine, and the environment. In addition to Anthropocene, her work has appeared in Nature, Newsweek, Nautilus, Spectrum, and many other publications. Find her on Twitter at @DeWeerdt_Sarah.


Source: Kuittinen M. et al. “Environmental Product Declarations for plants and soils: how to quantify carbon uptake in landscape design and construction?” The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment 2021.

A+
a-

In The News

Health

Voting

Infrastructure

White House Is Distributing $5.8B From Infrastructure Law for Water Projects

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Biden administration announced Tuesday that it is distributing another $5.8 billion for water infrastructure projects around the... Read More

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Biden administration announced Tuesday that it is distributing another $5.8 billion for water infrastructure projects around the country, paid for by one of its key legislative victories. The new allocations will go to projects in all 50 states, bringing the total awarded to states... Read More

States and Congress Wrestle With Cybersecurity at Water Utilities Amid Renewed Federal Warnings

HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) — The tiny Aliquippa water authority in western Pennsylvania was perhaps the least-suspecting victim of an international... Read More

HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) — The tiny Aliquippa water authority in western Pennsylvania was perhaps the least-suspecting victim of an international cyberattack. It had never had outside help in protecting its systems from a cyberattack, either at its existing plant that dates to the 1930s or the... Read More

December 1, 2023
by Tom Ramstack
Inspector General Investigates Reports of Bias in New FBI Headquarters Choice

WASHINGTON — A federal inspector general’s investigation is checking out reports that conflicts of interest might have influenced the choice... Read More

WASHINGTON — A federal inspector general’s investigation is checking out reports that conflicts of interest might have influenced the choice last month of Greenbelt, Maryland, for the new FBI headquarters. Until the General Services Administration announced the 61-acre Greenbelt site on Nov. 8, a second site... Read More

Biden to Convene New Supply Chain Council, Announce 30 Steps to Strengthen US Logistics

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden on Monday will convene the first meeting of his supply chain resilience council, using the event... Read More

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden on Monday will convene the first meeting of his supply chain resilience council, using the event to announce 30 actions to improve access to medicine and needed economic data and other programs tied to the production and shipment of goods. “We’re determined... Read More

Top US Accident Investigator Says Close Calls Between Planes Show Aviation Is Under Stress

The nation’s top accident investigator said Thursday that a surge in close calls between planes at U.S. airports this year... Read More

The nation’s top accident investigator said Thursday that a surge in close calls between planes at U.S. airports this year is a "clear warning sign” that the aviation system is under stress. “While these events are incredibly rare, our safety system is showing clear signs of... Read More

'Amtrak Joe' Biden Is Off to Delaware to Give Out $16B for Passenger Rail Projects

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden — perhaps the nation's biggest Amtrak fan — is set to promote new federal investments for... Read More

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden — perhaps the nation's biggest Amtrak fan — is set to promote new federal investments for trains on the heavily trafficked Northeast Corridor. The Democratic president is headed to Bear, Delaware, on Monday to announce more than $16 billion in new funding that... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top