Broadband Deployment Needs Better Data, Flexible Approach

June 3, 2021 by Victoria Turner
Broadband Deployment Needs Better Data, Flexible Approach
Giant rolls holding fiber optic cable are stored at a Lake Connections construction yard, waiting to be installed as a part of a broadband project in northern Minnesota, July 31, 2012. By the time the communications project is done in 2014 around 2000 miles of fiber optic cable will be strung, connecting customers with broadband internet, video and telephone service. (Bruce Bisping/Minneapolis Star Tribune/MCT)

The Federal Communications Commission must be more “forward-looking” as the agency thinks of spending billions on high-speed broadband deployment, said Austin Bonner, wireline legal advisor for FCC Commissioner Geoffrey Starks, at a Federal Communications Bar Association lunch-and-learn event Wednesday.

In President Joe Biden’s American Jobs Plan, the infrastructure funding plan would allocate $100 billion to broadband, an amount that Republicans want to decrease to $65 billion, which the White House indicated on May 21 it would be willing to accept “in the spirit of finding common ground.” 

On Wednesday, Biden met with Sen. Shelley Moore Capito, R-W. Va., who represents a group of Republicans looking to come to a compromise on Biden’s overall infrastructure plan, including the high-speed internet objectives. 

Before the deal is sealed, however, Bonner said the FCC must gather the data from the pandemic, such as the lessons from having parents and children trying to jump onto online meetings and classes at the same time, to ensure the proper investment of funds that leave “folks with something that’s going to stand the test of time.” 


Moreover, the data currently used for the broadband policy decisions is pre-pandemic, warned Scott Wallsten, president of Technology Policy Institute, during yesterday’s separate Brookings Institution event discussing whether Biden’s broadband plan would actually close the digital divide between communities having high-speed internet access and those that do not. 

It is “nice to see [broadband] has become a mainstream” issue, Wallsten said, but he was surprised the U.S. will be “[spending] $100 billion on two paragraphs” – to be fair, there are four paragraphs under Biden’s “Revitalize America’s digital infrastructure” section

Wallsten’s fellow panelist, Brookings Institutions’ Senior Fellow Dr. Nicol Turner-Lee, noted it will require “a multi-stakeholder approach” that is “technology-agnostic” and “flexible.“


“We need to be thinking of the plethora of technology,” she urged, and what is right for the specific underserved community – for example, what type of technology actually “works best” for the area being reached. 

Critics of the administration’s broadband policy proposals, such as the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation, have called for a revision of the plan’s objectives of upgrading existing networks to have symmetrical high speeds – as opposed to the current requirements of high download speeds and low upload speeds – to reach 100% coverage and prioritizing government-owned and non-profit networks. 

“It does not seem like good policy to provide [symmetrical speeds] to some regions that may already have connectivity when there are…areas of the country that still lack any internet,” said Danielle Thumann, wireline legal advisor to FCC Commissioner Brandon Carr, adding that those disconnected areas should be targeted first.

In a report last month, the ITIF suggested that broadband policy should target subsidies to high-cost areas that are not built out, to avoid duplicative efforts and keep moderate speed requirements as opposed to the symmetrical, and hold procurement auctions, instead of prioritizing municipal networks. The latter, the report stated, have proven to “help network deployment in high-cost areas much more cost effectively than other models.” 

This is where a “hybrid” approach – be it a combination of broadband, wireless, or satellite – could benefit the residents, Turner-Lee explained, as competition would address resident’s affordability and connectivity issues, helping these individuals to “boost their economic recovery.” 


In areas lacking providers, she said, it was reasonable for municipal networks to “step in,” but the approach has to “stop trying to be so constrained.” 

The FCC has been trying to map out the served versus underserved broadband areas for about 10 to 15 years and has yet to finalize them. This needs to happen to ensure accurate deployment, Turner-Lee urged, to avoid underbuilding or overbuilding broadband networks across the U.S. 

A+
a-

In The News

Health

Voting

Telecom

August 16, 2022
by Madeline Hughes
FCC Asks Congress for Universal Service Fund Reform

WASHINGTON — The Federal Communications Commission is asking Congress to help reform how it collects money to expand and provide... Read More

WASHINGTON — The Federal Communications Commission is asking Congress to help reform how it collects money to expand and provide telecom services to every American. The reason? The Universal Service Fund is stuck in a “death spiral,” according to FCC Commissioner Brendan Carr. He and the... Read More

August 12, 2022
by Madeline Hughes
DC Circuit Court Upholds FCC Spectrum Reallocation

WASHINGTON — The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals on Friday solidified the Federal Communications Commission’s ability to reallocate spectrum that... Read More

WASHINGTON — The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals on Friday solidified the Federal Communications Commission’s ability to reallocate spectrum that went largely unused. "I am pleased with the court's decision, which upholds the FCC's broad authority to manage the nation's airwaves in the public interest,” said... Read More

July 29, 2022
by Madeline Hughes
FCC Opens Spectrum Auction

WASHINGTON — Friday morning the Federal Communications Commission kicked off a spectrum auction, allowing telecommunications companies to possibly buy more... Read More

WASHINGTON — Friday morning the Federal Communications Commission kicked off a spectrum auction, allowing telecommunications companies to possibly buy more than 8,000 licenses in the 2.5 GHz band. The licenses are mostly available in rural parts of the country, according to the commission. “We all know... Read More

July 29, 2022
by Madeline Hughes
Democrats Revive Fight for Net Neutrality

WASHINGTON — Two senators and a member of the House of Representatives are working to ensure internet providers deliver equitable... Read More

WASHINGTON — Two senators and a member of the House of Representatives are working to ensure internet providers deliver equitable service to customers, banning the practice of throttling service and blocking access to certain content. Sens. Ed Markey, D-Mass., and Ron Wyden, D-Ore., and Rep. Doris... Read More

July 21, 2022
by Madeline Hughes
FCC Asks Cell Carriers About Use and Retention of Geolocation Data

WASHINGTON — Federal Communications Commission Chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel is asking the country’s top cellphone carriers for information on how each... Read More

WASHINGTON — Federal Communications Commission Chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel is asking the country’s top cellphone carriers for information on how each company uses and retains customer geolocation data. It’s important because “mobile internet service providers are uniquely situated to capture a trove of data about their own... Read More

July 20, 2022
by Madeline Hughes
Former FCC Chairs: Commissioner Needs to Be Confirmed

WASHINGTON — Throughout the various iterations of the Federal Communications Commission, its members have essentially had to answer one question:... Read More

WASHINGTON — Throughout the various iterations of the Federal Communications Commission, its members have essentially had to answer one question: “How do you make sure technology as it develops and evolves can be enjoyed by everyone in the country?” said former Chair William Kennard at the... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top