Federal, State Laws Should Bolster Social Media Accountability, Carr says

July 12, 2021 by Victoria Turner
Federal, State Laws Should Bolster Social Media Accountability, Carr says

Reforming Section 230 of the 1996 Communications Decency Act is not enough to curb the power of social media platforms, and should be bolstered by federal and state laws to enforce transparency, accountability and anti-discrimination, FCC Commissioner Brendan Carr said. 

Despite the “tremendous benefits” the tech industry has provided society, Carr told attendees at a Federal Communications Bar Association event last week he has never seen such a wide gap between corporate power and accountability.

Social media platforms are treated as “interactive computer services” under Section 230 of the CDA, a designation that shields them from liability for third-party content published through their services. 

The same designation gives them a free hand to moderate any content they deem violates their standards under their rights as private companies. 

Carr said there are a number of laws that already apply to the cable and telecom industry that are examples of how to impose “affirmative” anti-discrimination requirements on the big technology and social media platforms.

For example, he said, the cable television industry has “must-carry” obligations that require operators to carry the content of local broadcast stations on their networks.

These obligations were put in place to protect commercial and noncommercial broadcasters  in local markets, who compete against stations owned and affiliated with the national cable operators.

Similarly, Carr said, mobile service providers are required to carry data from other entities when their wireless customers “roam” outside their given networks.

Carr’s comments came a day after former President Donald Trump filed lawsuits against Facebook, Twitter and YouTube over their decisions to remove him from their platforms. 

The former president said he was wrongfully censored, along with others, and asked the court to find Section 230 unconstitutional and that the platforms are not private companies but “state actors.” 

They also came just days after U.S. District Judge Robert Hinkle blocked a Florida law signed by Gov. Ron DeSantis that would have prohibited social media platforms from banning politicians.

Trump’s lawsuit and the Florida law share the fact they are both predicated on First Amendment claims, but Carr said ultimately, the outcome of the debate may be much closer to the action that led to the must carry and roaming obligations imposed on other tech and telecom companies.

Social media platforms are a “unique medium with unique features,” he said. “These platforms are speaking for themselves, but they are also conduits of other people’s speech, [and] they are also content moderating.”

Despite bipartisan interest in keeping the technology industry in check, Carr said, lawmakers on Capitol Hill appear to be “pulling on opposite threads.” 

This is why he said he promotes focusing on state law efforts, which have a better chance of “surviving judicial review” than their federal cases. 

“We had these blind spots in the left and the right in the U.S. that led to this outsized power concentrating in Silicon Valley,” Carr said , pointing out it was time for both sides to work together in closing the “gap” and find a reasonable approach to accountability for the nation’s biggest tech firms.

A+
a-
  • Brendan Carr
  • Donald Trump
  • Federal Communications Bar Association
  • Federal Communications Commission
  • lawsuits
  • Social Media
  • Technology
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Technology

    Americans Reporting Nationwide Cellular Outages From AT&T, Cricket Wireless and Others

    A number of Americans are dealing with cellular outages on AT&T, Cricket Wireless, Verizon, T-Mobile and other service providers, according... Read More

    A number of Americans are dealing with cellular outages on AT&T, Cricket Wireless, Verizon, T-Mobile and other service providers, according to data from Downdetector. AT&T had more than 73,000 outages around 9:30 a.m. ET, in locations including Houston, Atlanta and Chicago. The outages began at approximately... Read More

    February 9, 2024
    by Tom Ramstack
    FCC Bans Robocalls Using Voices Generated by Artificial Intelligence

    WASHINGTON — The Federal Communications Commission released a decision Thursday to ban robocalls with voices generated by artificial intelligence. The... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Federal Communications Commission released a decision Thursday to ban robocalls with voices generated by artificial intelligence. The FCC said the robocalls play key roles in rising rates of sophisticated scams, such as calls before the New Hampshire primary last month using the voice... Read More

    Biden Administration Announces $5B Commitment for Research and Development of Computer Chips

    WASHINGTON (AP) — The Biden administration on Friday announced the investment of $5 billion in a newly established public-private consortium... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — The Biden administration on Friday announced the investment of $5 billion in a newly established public-private consortium aimed at supporting research and development in advanced computer chips. The National Semiconductor Technology Center is being funded through the CHIPS and Science Act. That 2022 law... Read More

    AI Is the Buzz, the Big Opportunity and the Risk to Watch Among the Davos Glitterati

    DAVOS, Switzerland (AP) — Artificial intelligence is easily the biggest buzzword for world leaders and corporate bosses diving into big... Read More

    DAVOS, Switzerland (AP) — Artificial intelligence is easily the biggest buzzword for world leaders and corporate bosses diving into big ideas at the World Economic Forum’s glitzy annual meeting in Davos. Breathtaking advances in generative AI stunned the world last year, and the elite crowd is... Read More

    Biden Administration Announces $162M to Expand Computer Chip Factories in Colorado and Oregon

    WASHINGTON (AP) — The Biden administration is providing $162 million to Microchip Technology to support the domestic production of computer chips —... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — The Biden administration is providing $162 million to Microchip Technology to support the domestic production of computer chips — the second funding announcement tied to a 2022 law designed to revive U.S. semiconductor manufacturing. The incentives announced Thursday include $90 million to improve a plant in Colorado... Read More

    December 29, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    MidAmerican Tests New Lighting System at Three Iowa Wind Farms

    DES MOINES, Iowa — MidAmerican Energy has begun testing on a new radar-activated aircraft detection lighting system that the company... Read More

    DES MOINES, Iowa — MidAmerican Energy has begun testing on a new radar-activated aircraft detection lighting system that the company hopes will dramatically reduce the visual impact of flashing lights on turbines during the overnight hours. If the system works as envisioned, the technology will eliminate... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top