Justices Uphold California Ban on Sale of Pork From Confined Sows

May 11, 2023 by Dan McCue
Justices Uphold California Ban on Sale of Pork From Confined Sows
(Photo by pixelmixer via Pixabay)

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Thursday upheld a California ballot initiative that barred the sale of pork produced in other states unless the sow was housed in humane conditions allowing for free movement.

The decision of the court was 5-4, with Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Samuel Alito, Brett Kavanaugh and Ketanji Brown Jackson dissenting.

At issue in the case was a California law known as Proposition 12, which bans the in-state sale of whole pork meat that comes from breeding pigs (or their immediate offspring) that are “confined in a cruel manner.”

The law further defines “cruel” to mean in ways that prevent a pig from lying down, standing up, fully extending its limbs or freely turning around.

Prior to the vote, animal rights activists argued the law would benefit both animal welfare and consumer health.

After Proposition 12’s adoption two industry organizations, the National Pork Producers Council and the American Farm Bureau Federation, sued on behalf of their members, maintaining Proposition 12 violated the Constitution by impermissibly burdening interstate commerce.

The organizations went on to argue that the cost of compliance with Proposition 12 would increase production costs and would fall on both California and out-of-state producers.  

They further argued that because California imports almost all the pork it consumes, most of Proposition 12’s compliance costs would be borne by out-of-state firms.  

A federal judge tossed the case, finding that the plaintiffs had failed to state a valid claim as a matter of law. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals later affirmed that decision.

Writing for the Supreme Court majority, Justice Neil Gorsuch observed that “[c]ompanies that choose to sell products in various states must normally comply with the laws of those various states.”  

“Assuredly, under this court’s dormant commerce clause decisions, no state may use its laws to discriminate purposefully against out-of-state economic interests,” he continued. “But the pork producers do not suggest that California’s law offends this principle. Instead, they invite us to fashion two new and more aggressive constitutional restrictions on the ability of states to regulate goods sold within their borders. 

“We decline that invitation. While the Constitution addresses many weighty issues, the type of pork chops California merchants may sell is not on that list,” Gorsuch said.

Dan can be reached at [email protected] and at https://twitter.com/DanMcCue

A+
a-
  • California
  • pigs
  • pork
  • Proposition 12
  • Supreme Court
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Supreme Court

    December 4, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    Justices Appear Divided Over Purdue Pharma Bankruptcy Deal

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court appeared divided on Monday over a bankruptcy deal struck by Purdue Pharma that would immunize... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court appeared divided on Monday over a bankruptcy deal struck by Purdue Pharma that would immunize the Sackler family, its one-time owners, from civil lawsuits for their role in the opioid crisis.  The closely watched case is considered to be among the most... Read More

    November 30, 2023
    by Tom Ramstack
    Supreme Court Leans Toward Reducing Enforcement Authority of Federal Agencies

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court seemed ready Wednesday to cut back on the authority of federal agencies to enforce their... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court seemed ready Wednesday to cut back on the authority of federal agencies to enforce their regulations through fines or seizures of property. Questions from the conservative majority of justices during a hearing focused on whether the agencies were committing unconstitutional procedural... Read More

    November 30, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    Chaos Reigns as Democrats Vote to Subpoena Crow, Leo in SCOTUS Probe

    WASHINGTON — A Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on Thursday became the latest venue for Capitol Hill dysfunction as Democrats on... Read More

    WASHINGTON — A Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on Thursday became the latest venue for Capitol Hill dysfunction as Democrats on the panel approved issuing subpoenas to billionaire Harlan Crow and influential conservative Leonard Leo as part of an ongoing investigation into alleged ethical lapses by Supreme... Read More

    November 28, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    Justices Asked to Parse Accelerated Sentencing Guidelines

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court returned to the bench for its December session on Monday, considering a pair of cases... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court returned to the bench for its December session on Monday, considering a pair of cases whose outcome could have sweeping consequences for the sentencing of recidivist offenders charged with federal crimes. The cases, which were consolidated for the sake of oral... Read More

    November 17, 2023
    by Tom Ramstack
    Supreme Court Blocks Florida Law Banning Kids From Drag Shows

    WASHINGTON — The U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday blocked a Florida law that bans child access to drag shows, saying... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday blocked a Florida law that bans child access to drag shows, saying it violates First Amendment free speech rights. Gov. Ron DeSantis and his supporters enacted the law to protect children from what they consider corrupt influences. The... Read More

    November 17, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    Guns, Social Media and Fair Play for Whistleblowers Stand Out on Early Docket

    WASHINGTON — While “chaos” was the most apt description for certain parts of the federal government in October, the U.S.... Read More

    WASHINGTON — While “chaos” was the most apt description for certain parts of the federal government in October, the U.S. Supreme Court reconvened and got on with the business of unwinding the nation’s thorniest legal questions. By the time Congress finally chose Rep. Mike Johnson, R-La.,... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top