Supreme Court Restores Witness Requirement for South Carolina Absentee Ballots
WASHINGTON – Within hours of the start of its new term on Monday, the Supreme Court revived a South Carolina law that requires absentee ballots to be returned accompanied by a witness’s signature.
Lower courts had set aside the law, holding it interfered with the right to vote during a pandemic.
Though the court as a whole did not explain its rationale for upholding the law, in a concurring opinion Justice Brett Kavanaugh said the conservative majority was correct because state election laws should not be second-guessed by federal judges.
He also noted the Supreme Court has typically refrained from ordering changes to voting procedures so close to an election.
The justices did carve out exceptions to the witness requirements, applying it to ballots cast before they rendered their decision and those received by election officials within two days of the justices’ order.
But Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito Jr. and Neil Gorsuch said they would have reinstated the requirement for all ballots.
The underlying lawsuit was filed by Democratic groups and several South Carolina voters. On the other side were state officials and the South Carolina Republican party, who argued the witness requirement was a not an undue burden and that the practice helped prevent fraud.
U.S. District Judge J. Michelle Childs disagreed, finding the requirement served no useful purpose.
“The fact the witness requirement may provide a lead to investigate absentee fraud is undercut by an utter dearth of absentee fraud,” Childs noted.
A three-judge panel of the 4th U.S. Court of Appeals initially overruled the judge, but the full Appeals court reinstated Childs’ injunction.
State officials then appealed to the Supreme Court.
In The News
Health
Voting
State News
SEATTLE — This spring, as the coronavirus spread across Washington, a team of stalwart volunteers set up signature-gathering drive-thrus outside churches and stores. Their aim: to put a referendum on the November ballot overturning a new law that required public schools to teach comprehensive sexual health education. Thousands... Read More
SACRAMENTO, Calif. — A November ballot initiative to raise property taxes on big-business owners in California is drawing unconventional political support from health care power players and public health leaders. They see Proposition 15 as a potential savior for chronically underfunded local health departments struggling to respond to the... Read More
WASHINGTON — States that claim changes by the U.S. Postal Service will threaten mail-in voting failed again to get an independent monitor appointed to observe the agency's compliance with a court order. U.S. District Judge Gerald Austin McHugh in Philadelphia on Wednesday denied a request from Pennsylvania's attorney general, Josh Shapiro, to assign a former USPS... Read More
WASHINGTON - The Supreme Court put the brakes on a lower court order that would have allowed curbside voting in Alabama in November. The underlying lawsuit was filed by the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, the Southern Poverty Law Center and the Alabama Disabilities Advocacy... Read More
PHILADELPHIA — Former President Barack Obama delivered a punishing rebuke of his successor Donald Trump's tenure and a clarion call to supporters for his old running mate Joe Biden at a drive-in rally outside Citizens Bank Park as the sun set Wednesday night. Trump's tone and the misinformation he spreads have poisoned American political discourse,... Read More
AUSTIN, Texas — Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden has drawn even in Texas with President Donald Trump, and Democrat MJ Hegar is closing in on U.S. Sen. John Cornyn in the Quinnipiac University poll of likely Texas voters released Wednesday afternoon. "Biden and Trump find themselves in a Texas standoff, setting the stage for a bare-knuckle battle for 38 electoral votes," said... Read More
