Michigan Court of Appeals Denies Appeal, Says Open Carry at Polls Is Legal
LANSING, Mich. — The open carry of firearms will be permitted at the polls on Election Day, under an order issued Thursday by the Michigan Court of Appeals.
A three-member panel of the court rejected Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson’s appeal of a ruling that struck down her directive banning the open carry of guns at or around polling places on Election Day.
In declining to hear the appeal, the panel said that although concerns about voter intimidation involving firearms are valid, the state already has laws to handle that.
“Voter intimidation is — and remains — illegal under current Michigan law,” the panel said.
Also, “brandishing a firearm in public is — and remains — illegal under current Michigan law.” Therefore, “anyone who intimidates a voter in Michigan by brandishing a firearm … is committing a felony under existing law, and that law is — and remains _enforceable by our executive branch as well as local law enforcement.”
Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel filed an emergency appeal with the Michigan Supreme Court Thursday night.
“Just today, a poll released by the Detroit News and WDIV-TV indicated that 73% of Michigan voters say openly carried guns should be banned near polling places,” Nessel spokesman Ryanend nu Jarvi said. “The merits of this issue — which impacts all Michiganders — deserves full and expedited consideration by our state’s highest court.”
Although Benson’s directive remains without force under the Thursday order, existing state law could still prohibit some Michiganders from openly carrying firearms at some polling places. Schools are often used as polling places and guns are generally prohibited on school grounds, though concealed pistol license holders are allowed to open carry on school property.
There is no Michigan law that expressly permits the open carry of firearms. Rather, it is presumed to be legal anywhere it is not expressly prohibited. Those places include courthouses, hospitals, casinos and large sports arenas.
Benson’s directive, issued Oct. 16, banned the open carry of guns on Election Day not just at or near polling places, but around municipal clerks’ offices and places where ballots are counted.
On Thursday, Michigan Court of Claims Judge Christopher Murray issued a preliminary injunction against the directive, saying it amounted to an administrative rule and Benson did not take the proper steps to implement it, through the Administrative Procedures Act.
Activist Robert Davis and several gun rights groups had sued over the directive.
Davis called Thursday’s ruling a victory for the rule of law.
“I hope that the Secretary of State and attorney general learn their lesson and begin to follow the law rather than trying to change the law unilaterally,” Davis said.
The three judges on the panel — Patrick Meter, Michael Gadola, and Brock Swartzle — were all appointed to the court by Republican governors.
Staff writer Dave Boucher contributed to this report.
(c)2020 Detroit Free Press
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC
In The News
WASHINGTON — Texas Sen. John Cornyn, a senior Republican and adviser to the majority leader, said flatly Thursday that President Donald Trump has no realistic path to overturning the election. After weeks of court defeats, he noted, Trump's legal team has yet to show evidence of fraud and ballot tampering despite claims... Read More
WASHINGTON - As part of the 10th Annual NewDEAL Leaders Conference held this week, the NewDEAL Forum, a Washington, D.C.-based non-profit organization, released a new education report detailing policy solutions for providing high quality college and career pathways for students of all education levels. The NewDEAL... Read More
To those who felt their lives were just a little bit emptier after a canvassing board in Iowa certified the results in that state's 2nd Congressional District, declaring a winner in a race in which the candidates were separated by only six votes: we introduce you... Read More
ATLANTA — Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger on Wednesday called on President Donald Trump to drop unproven allegations of voting fraud in the state. At a news conference at the Georgia Capitol, Raffensperger decried Trump's continued insistence that voter fraud cost him the election in Georgia and elsewhere. The secretary cited this week's comments... Read More
WHEATLAND, Iowa - Democrat Rita Hart is challenging the vote totals in Iowa's 2nd Congressional District, two days after a state board certified Republican Mariannette Miller-Meeks the winner in a contest that came down to just six votes. The race is the closest federal election in... Read More
In the end, it came down to a razor thin margin of six votes out of 394,441 cast, but that was margin enough for the Iowa state canvassing board Monday to declare Republican Mariannette Miller-Meeks winner of the state's hotly contested 2nd Congressional District race. On... Read More