Narrowed Build Back Better Plan Could Come as Manchin Signals Support 

March 7, 2022 by Reece Nations
<strong>Narrowed Build Back Better Plan Could Come as Manchin Signals Support </strong>
Sen. Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., listens as President Joe Biden delivers his first State of the Union address to a joint session of Congress, at the Capitol in Washington, Tuesday, March 1, 2022. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite, Pool)

WASHINGTON — Hopes for the passage of a revamped version of the Build Back Better Act were renewed last week after Sen. Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., indicated he could support a scaled-down version.

Manchin’s objections to the version of the bill passed by the House in November stalled the bill in the Senate. There, Democrats could pass the revised version of the bill and avoid a Republican filibuster under the special budget reconciliation process.

In February, Manchin shot down the prospects of the bill’s passage after talks with the White House fizzled out due to disagreements over its price tag. While Manchin told reporters on Capitol Hill last week he has yet to make any formal counterproposal to the White House, he said he is working on one that could satisfy his Senate Democratic Caucus colleagues while reducing federal deficits. 

“Something is better than nothing for our supporters of the bill and it really looks like we’re down to that,” Matt Grossmann, director of the Institute for Public Policy and Social Research and political science professor at Michigan State University, told The Well News. “So certainly, there’s a lot of people saying that they should give Manchin whatever he is willing [to take] to go for it, especially since it doesn’t appear that he is demanding anything that people don’t want in the bill, it’s just a question of how much is in it. And that’s usually a recipe for compromise.”

Part of Manchin’s reason for dismissing the initial proposal had to do with the process of hammering out details with President Joe Biden, Grossmann said. Controversy ensued when Manchin came forward with a direct proposal to the White House in December, but certain details — such as a lack of funding for the long-term continuation of the Child Tax Credit — were subsequently leaked to the press and led Manchin to signal his disapproval in an interview with Fox News.

In order to keep Manchin on board with the proposal, Grossmann said Democrats not only have to cave on the bill’s substance but also on its process. Manchin’s take-it-or-leave-it approach to negotiating the bill is apparently the only way for him to support it in the narrowly divided Senate.

Some of the proposed concessions would keep major provisions of the bill intact while reducing their costs by shortening the duration of some programs in the bill. Doing so would reduce the overall costs of implementation while still containing the palatable provisions Democrats had hoped for.

“They have already sort of decided, especially on the climate side, that this is mostly going to be an investment approach rather than a cost approach,” Grossmann said. “And that’s … always the easiest thing to pass. It’s very hard to impose costs on anyone, and much easier to just hand out benefits.

“So there’s still kind of an open question as to whether that will work or not,” Grossmann continued. “There’s plenty of people who think that it will, but it’s different than anything like imposing a carbon tax or a carbon price that we’ve been talking about in the past.”

Reece can be reached at [email protected]


A+
a-
  • Build Back Better
  • Joe Manchin
  • White House
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Political News

    October 1, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    Senate Votes, President Signs, Shutdown Averted

    WASHINGTON — With just over three hours to spare, the Senate last night passed a bipartisan bill to avert a... Read More

    WASHINGTON — With just over three hours to spare, the Senate last night passed a bipartisan bill to avert a government shutdown, and President Joe Biden signed it just before the midnight deadline. The measure will fund the federal government for 45 days, or until Nov.... Read More

    September 30, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    House Passes Stopgap Funding Bill, Senate Plans Vote Saturday Night

    WASHINGTON — After multiple failed attempts, the House on Saturday approved a “clean” stopgap funding bill in a last-ditch bid... Read More

    WASHINGTON — After multiple failed attempts, the House on Saturday approved a “clean” stopgap funding bill in a last-ditch bid to avert a government shutdown, sending the measure to the Senate with just hours to spare. In the end, after days of wrangling within the House... Read More

    September 29, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    Disorder in the House; Last Gasp Bid to Avert Shutdown Crushed in Chamber Vote

    WASHINGTON — A last gasp attempt to keep the federal government fully funded beyond this weekend turned into a crushing... Read More

    WASHINGTON — A last gasp attempt to keep the federal government fully funded beyond this weekend turned into a crushing defeat for House Speaker Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif., on Friday as 21 hard-right members of his conference voted against the plan that would have slashed the budgets... Read More

    Biden's Speech and Takeaways From the House Impeachment Hearing

    WASHINGTON (AP) — House Republicans on Thursday are holding the first hearing of their impeachment inquiry into President Joe Biden and their effort to... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — House Republicans on Thursday are holding the first hearing of their impeachment inquiry into President Joe Biden and their effort to tie the him to the business dealings to his son Hunter. It’s a high-stakes opening act for Republicans as they begin a process that can lead to the ultimate... Read More

    September 28, 2023
    by Tom Ramstack
    House Republicans Advised to Tread Carefully as They Mull Biden Impeachment

    WASHINGTON — Constitutional law experts advised a congressional committee Thursday to be careful about overstepping its authority as lawmakers consider... Read More

    WASHINGTON — Constitutional law experts advised a congressional committee Thursday to be careful about overstepping its authority as lawmakers consider impeaching President Joe Biden. Republicans accuse him of using his political leadership to enrich himself and his family through influence peddling with foreign enterprises. If true,... Read More

    September 27, 2023
    by Tom Ramstack
    Congress Looks to Private Sector to Recover Pandemic Loans Lost to Fraud

    WASHINGTON — Shocking new figures on how much of the COVID-19 pandemic relief bailout funds went to fraud prompted a... Read More

    WASHINGTON — Shocking new figures on how much of the COVID-19 pandemic relief bailout funds went to fraud prompted a U.S. House committee on Wednesday to consider private sector strategies to recover more of the money for the government. The Small Business Administration recently estimated that... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top