ABA Recommends Random Case Assignments to Avoid Judge Shopping for Political Advantage

August 10, 2023 by Tom Ramstack
ABA Recommends Random Case Assignments to Avoid Judge Shopping for Political Advantage
Gavel and scales

DENVER — The American Bar Association is trying to stop the “judge shopping” that allows political advocacy organizations to file lawsuits in courts most likely to rule in their favor.

Commonly, state attorneys general and activists will sue in federal courts with one judge whose record of judgments favors the plaintiffs’ political orientation.

At least 55 of the nation’s 94 federal district courts are subdivided into geographic “divisions.” Thirty-five of the divisions have only one or two judges assigned to them.

The ABA’s House of Delegates approved a resolution this week during its annual meeting in Denver encouraging the judiciary to avoid case assignment methods that allow litigants to choose their preferred judges in cases that seek “to enjoin or mandate the enforcement of a state or federal law or regulation.”

The ABA’s Resolution 521 is essentially the same as legislation introduced in May by congressional Democrats that would require that any one judge has no more than a 25% chance of being assigned to a specific case in federal district courts.

In addition, Democratic senators last month called on the Judicial Conference to take measures to stop judge shopping. The Judicial Conference is the judiciary’s policymaking arm.

They were motivated partly by a recent high-profile case in Amarillo, Texas, in which a Trump-appointed judge suspended Food and Drug Administration approval of the abortion pills mifepristone at the request of a conservative advocacy group. The federal court in Amarillo is a single-judge division presided over by U.S. District Judge Matthew J. Kacsmaryk.

Before he was appointed as a federal judge, Kacsmaryk was a Christian legal activist who opposed abortion rights. The plaintiffs were the Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine, which claimed residency in Amarillo after incorporating in Texas months before suing.

In another example, patent owners often file infringement cases in Waco, Texas, after learning a local federal judge is favorable to the owners’ claims. The result is that nearly 25% of patent infringement cases with national impact now are filed in Waco.

The ABA recommends case assignment methods that randomly appoint judges throughout their federal district.

“Random assignment serves important functions in preserving and promoting public confidence in the judiciary,” the ABA resolution says.

You can reach us at [email protected] and follow us on Facebook and Twitter

A+
a-
  • American Bar Association
  • judge shopping
  • politics
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Law

    May 16, 2025
    by Tom Ramstack
    Former US Attorney for DC Investigated on Ethics Complaint

    WASHINGTON — One of Ed Martin’s last acts as he left his job this week as interim U.S. attorney for... Read More

    WASHINGTON — One of Ed Martin’s last acts as he left his job this week as interim U.S. attorney for the District of Columbia was to acknowledge to his staff that he is under investigation for ethics violations. Martin was appointed by President Donald Trump but... Read More

    May 9, 2025
    by Tom Ramstack
    Trump Nominates TV Host Jeanine Pirro as Interim US Attorney for Washington, DC

    WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump announced the selection Thursday of Fox News host Jeanine Pirro to become the interim U.S.... Read More

    WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump announced the selection Thursday of Fox News host Jeanine Pirro to become the interim U.S. attorney for the District of Columbia after his previous nominee failed to win Senate support. Pirro, 73, is a former prosecutor, judge and longtime popular television... Read More

    May 7, 2025
    by Tom Ramstack
    Ed Martin’s Nomination as US Attorney Loses Favor Among Republicans

    WASHINGTON — The chances are dimming for Trump supporter Ed Martin to win Senate confirmation as the U.S. attorney for... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The chances are dimming for Trump supporter Ed Martin to win Senate confirmation as the U.S. attorney for the District of Columbia. Martin is currently the interim U.S. attorney. His term expires May 20. Republicans who normally endorse President Donald Trump's nominees for various... Read More

    Trump Administration Asks Judge to Toss Suit Restricting Access to Abortion Medication

    WASHINGTON (AP) — The Trump administration has asked a judge to toss out a lawsuit from three Republican-led states seeking... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — The Trump administration has asked a judge to toss out a lawsuit from three Republican-led states seeking to cut off telehealth access to the abortion medication mifepristone. Justice Department attorneys on Monday stayed the legal course charted by the Biden administration, though they didn't... Read More

    May 5, 2025
    by Tom Ramstack
    Judge Overrules Trump’s Order Punishing a Major Law Firm

    WASHINGTON — A federal judge in Washington, D.C., on Friday struck down an executive order by President Donald Trump that... Read More

    WASHINGTON — A federal judge in Washington, D.C., on Friday struck down an executive order by President Donald Trump that sanctioned a law firm for its previous representation of Democratic leaders. The judge said Trump’s retaliation against the law firm of Perkins Coie violated First Amendment... Read More

    Former Vice President Pence Defends Constitution After Getting Profile in Courage Award

    BOSTON (AP) — Former Vice President Mike Pence on Sunday repeatedly invoked the Constitution and said it is what “binds us all... Read More

    BOSTON (AP) — Former Vice President Mike Pence on Sunday repeatedly invoked the Constitution and said it is what “binds us all together” after receiving the John F. Kennedy Profile in Courage Award. Pence received the award for his refusal to go along with President Donald Trump’s efforts to remain... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top