Police Cannot Search Homes in Name of ‘Community Caretaking,’ Supreme Court Rules

May 19, 2021 by Reece Nations
The U.S. Supreme Court. (Photo by Dan McCue)

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court unanimously ruled Monday that a longstanding exception to the Fourth Amendment does not permit police to search private homes without a warrant.

The “community caretaking” exception originates from the 1973 case Cady v. Dombrowski, in which a police officer seized a gun from an impounded car without a warrant. At the time, the Supreme Court ruled that the officer’s actions were appropriate “community caretaking functions.” 

The court ruled this week, however, that the exception does not permit police to execute search and seizures without a warrant in private living spaces. In the court’s opinion on Caniglia v. Strom, written by Justice Clarence Thomas, the court determined police in Rhode Island overstepped their authority by confiscating a firearm that belonged to a man who agreed to undergo a mental health evaluation.

“To be sure, the Fourth Amendment does not prohibit all unwelcome intrusions ‘on private property,’ only ‘unreasonable’ ones,” Thomas wrote in the opinion. “We have thus recognized a few permissible invasions of the home and its curtilage.” 

Thomas continued, “The First Circuit’s ‘community caretaking’ rule, however, goes beyond anything this Court has recognized. The decision below assumed that respondents lacked a warrant or consent, and it expressly disclaimed the possibility that they were reacting to a crime. The court also declined to consider whether any recognized exigent circumstances were present because respondents had forfeited the point.”

Further, in Cady, the court made the distinction that the police’s authority to search vehicles without a warrant but not homes amount to a “constitutional difference.” Therefore, the court ruled, the protections of the Fourth Amendment mandate protection against “unreasonable searches and seizures” within a citizen’s private residence. 

While the court’s ruling in Cady amounted to a broadening of police authority, the ruling in Caniglia represents the inverse. The court’s decision comes more than a year after Breonna Taylor was shot and killed by Louisville police officers executing a no-knock search warrant on her apartment. 

“The Court holds — and I entirely agree — that there is no special Fourth Amendment rule for a broad category of cases involving ‘community caretaking,’” Justice Samuel Alito wrote in the concurring opinion. “As I understand the term, it describes the many police tasks that go beyond criminal law enforcement. These tasks vary widely, and there is no clear limit on how far they might extend in the future.” 

Alito continued, “The category potentially includes any non-law-enforcement work that a community chooses to assign, and because of the breadth of activities that may be described as community caretaking, we should not assume that the Fourth Amendment’s command of reasonableness applies in the same way to everything that might be viewed as falling into this broad category.” 

In The News

Health

Voting

Law Enforcement

Hundreds Jailed in Global Sting Operation
Law Enforcement
Hundreds Jailed in Global Sting Operation
June 22, 2021
by Reece Nations

Criminal groups in 16 countries were tracked for years by law enforcement agencies under the guise of a secure smartphone-based messaging application known as “ANOM,” leading to over 800 arrests. ANOM was developed by an individual cooperating with the San Diego branch of the FBI who... Read More

Judge Tosses Most Claims Over Clearing Protesters in DC Park
Law
Judge Tosses Most Claims Over Clearing Protesters in DC Park

WASHINGTON (AP) — A federal judge dismissed most claims filed by activists and civil liberties groups who accused the Trump administration of violating the civil rights of protesters who were forcefully removed by police before then-President Donald Trump walked to a church near the White House... Read More

Stretch of Mass Shootings Occur Nationwide Over Weekend
Crime
Stretch of Mass Shootings Occur Nationwide Over Weekend
June 14, 2021
by Reece Nations

A violent string of mass shootings killed at least 10 people and left another 50 injured in nine separate incidents across six states between Friday and Sunday this past weekend. Mass shootings are typically defined as incidents in which four or more individuals are shot with... Read More

Trump DOJ Seized Data from House Democrats in Leaks Probe
Justice
Trump DOJ Seized Data from House Democrats in Leaks Probe

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Justice Department under former President Donald Trump seized data from the accounts of at least two members of the House Intelligence Committee in 2018 as part of an aggressive crackdown on leaks related to the Russia investigation and other national security matters,... Read More

Mexican Drug Kingpin’s Wife Pleads Guilty in D.C. Court
Crime
Mexican Drug Kingpin’s Wife Pleads Guilty in D.C. Court
June 11, 2021
by Tom Ramstack

WASHINGTON -- The wife of Mexican drug kingpin Joaquin "El Chapo" Guzman is scheduled to be sentenced Sept. 15 after pleading guilty Thursday in U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C., to drug trafficking and money laundering charges. Emma Coronel Aispuro, 31, pleaded guilty after assisting her... Read More

Sting: FBI-run Messaging App Tricks Organized Crime
Law Enforcement
Sting: FBI-run Messaging App Tricks Organized Crime

THE HAGUE, Netherlands (AP) — Criminal gangs divulged plans for moving drug shipments and carrying out killings on a messaging app secretly run by the FBI, law enforcement agencies said Tuesday, as they unveiled a global sting operation they said dealt an "unprecedented blow" to organized... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top