Pollsters Look to Fix Flaws After 2020 Surprises

March 25, 2021 by Kate Michael
Pollsters Look to Fix Flaws After 2020 Surprises
Voters arrive and depart a polling place on Saturday, Oct. 31, 2020, in Yadkinville, North Carolina. The day was the last day of in-person early voting in North Carolina. (Brian Blanco/Getty Images)

WASHINGTON — The polling industry required an audit after the 2020 election. Poll results overstated Joe Biden’s lead over Donald Trump in the national vote for president by so much that analysts suggested: “the polling industry is a wreck, and should be blown up.” Yet in the same election, polling about specific issues of national concern wasn’t off by the same order of magnitude. 

Public opinion research has been volatile lately, but at a recent discussion on the future of the industry held by the think tank ThirdWay, pollsters argued that the system isn’t broken, it just needs a few thoughtful methodological tweaks. They also said the biggest lesson learned from 2020 is that polls aren’t predictions. 

Polling organizations attempt to collect responses on a number of closed- and open-ended opinion questions from the best representative sample of the American voting public. But while math and computer analytics are used, polling remains as much an art as a science. Subtle trends in voter — and non-voter — opinion may be equally as important as a respondent’s outright claim to support a particular candidate.

And sometimes even the pollsters are surprised. 

“In 2020, we had the highest [voter] turnout since 1900. I was not expecting that, “ said Kate Catherall, executive vice president of Political Strategy at Avalanche Insights. “I was more concerned about voter motivation… which is harder to track.”

Josh Ulibarri, partner at Lake Research Partners, did anticipate an increased participation rate but was stunned that higher turnout didn’t favor Democrats as much as they expected. 

“High turnout did not help us in all of these states, sending an absentee ballot to every voter didn’t help us in all of these states. We’ve been under the observation as progressives — and Democrats many of us — that higher turnout would always benefit us, and that’s not true in some of these states,” he said.

But while some pollsters admitted to a disconnect between polls and final votes, others suggested that it was not polling, but poll interpretation, that was off. 

“I was surprised by very little,” said Angela Kuetler, senior vice president at Global Strategy Group. “We certainly had our misses, like so many [polling firms] did… but we need to do a better job of talking about our data and educating people about how to read our data. Multiple factors… create a disconnect between what the public perceives polling to be and what polling actually is.”

Evaluating 2020 election polling, Third Way’s panel of pollsters agreed that spiking partisanship coupled with declining trust of both societal organizations and polls themselves will be a major concern for polling going forward. 

“Social trust is the big sticky problem we’re trying to deal with,” said Catherall. “I don’t think Trumpism is going away. Social distrust isn’t going away. And I think those things probably are getting worse [based on] the indicators we have.”

Though one fix to address the bias of mistrust may be to focus on the nuances of issue-based polling and ask more open-ended, and less yes-or-no questions. 

Kuetler says the public is not as divided on issues as they are on candidates, so approaching opinion polling from a different perspective and experimenting with more attitudinal questions could be the key to addressing social mistrust.

The industry also needs to take a hard look at how they can best reach out to voters and non-voters to achieve a truly representative sample. 

“Having low social trust doesn’t mean you’re more likely to answer an email, or click a link, than answer the phone, so it’s not something that can be solved with mode,” said Catherall. “There is literally no way to do this that is perfect. There will always be some bias.” Still, she does believe it is critical for the future of polling to reach people where they are.

“Fundamentally, there are people we are just missing in our polls,” said Kuetler. “Multi-modal is the way to go.” She advocated for text-to-web surveys, online panels, phone calls, and even Facebook to reach a wider sweep of opinions. 

“The future is mixed mode… [if we] take all of them, we’re hopefully getting a larger swath of the electorate; hopefully getting the right mix.”


A+
a-
  • flws in polls
  • Political Polls
  • polls
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    In The News

    October 1, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    Senate Votes, President Signs, Shutdown Averted

    WASHINGTON — With just over three hours to spare, the Senate last night passed a bipartisan bill to avert a... Read More

    WASHINGTON — With just over three hours to spare, the Senate last night passed a bipartisan bill to avert a government shutdown, and President Joe Biden signed it just before the midnight deadline. The measure will fund the federal government for 45 days, or until Nov.... Read More

    September 30, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    House Passes Stopgap Funding Bill, Senate Plans Vote Saturday Night

    WASHINGTON — After multiple failed attempts, the House on Saturday approved a “clean” stopgap funding bill in a last-ditch bid... Read More

    WASHINGTON — After multiple failed attempts, the House on Saturday approved a “clean” stopgap funding bill in a last-ditch bid to avert a government shutdown, sending the measure to the Senate with just hours to spare. In the end, after days of wrangling within the House... Read More

    September 29, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    National Zoo Saying Goodbye to Giant Pandas

    WASHINGTON — It is the end of an era at the Smithsonian National Zoo and Conservation Biology Institute. By Dec.... Read More

    WASHINGTON — It is the end of an era at the Smithsonian National Zoo and Conservation Biology Institute. By Dec. 7, Tian Tian and Mei Xiang, the giant pandas who have lived at the conservation park since 2000, and their 3-year-old cub Xiao Qi Ji, will... Read More

    September 29, 2023
    by Jesse Zucker
    Immunity-Boosting Superfoods for Cold and Flu Season

    With the cooler weather rolling in, cold and flu season is upon us. If you’ve ever reached for some vitamin... Read More

    With the cooler weather rolling in, cold and flu season is upon us. If you’ve ever reached for some vitamin C after coughing and sneezing, you may have wished you had thought about boosting your immune system sooner. Here we’ll break down the science around some... Read More

    September 29, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    Disorder in the House; Last Gasp Bid to Avert Shutdown Crushed in Chamber Vote

    WASHINGTON — A last gasp attempt to keep the federal government fully funded beyond this weekend turned into a crushing... Read More

    WASHINGTON — A last gasp attempt to keep the federal government fully funded beyond this weekend turned into a crushing defeat for House Speaker Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif., on Friday as 21 hard-right members of his conference voted against the plan that would have slashed the budgets... Read More

    September 29, 2023
    by Tom Ramstack
    Maryland Law Against Sexual Abuse Threatens Trouble for Catholic Church

    A Maryland law that waives the statute of limitations for child sexual abuse takes effect next week, creating potential legal... Read More

    A Maryland law that waives the statute of limitations for child sexual abuse takes effect next week, creating potential legal liabilities for the Catholic Archdioceses of Washington and Baltimore. For the Washington archdiocese — which includes the Maryland suburbs — the risk results from revelations its... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top