Appeals Court Rejects Bid for Stay of ‘Good Neighbor’ Pollution Plan

September 25, 2023 by Dan McCue
Appeals Court Rejects Bid for Stay of ‘Good Neighbor’ Pollution Plan
(Photo by Marak via Pixabay)

WASHINGTON — The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit on Monday rejected an attempt by the state of Utah to block the Environmental Protection Agency from enforcing a plan to protect downwind states from smog that blows from power plants within its borders.

The so-called “Good Neighbor Plan” has been one of many points of contention between the state and the EPA since the agency formally rejected Utah’s plan to reduce emissions implicated in neighboring states’ ozone pollution problems last February.

Environmental regulators in Utah have long maintained that summer surges in ozone pollution along the so-called Wasatch Front, a semi-arid region at the eastern edge of the Great Basin watershed, are not necessarily the result of coal-fired power plants operating in the state.

Instead they argue the pollutants, which can cause severe respiratory issues, are as likely to be drifting in from as near as California or blowing in from as far away as China, leaving them helpless to do anything about it.

Utah regulators have also concluded that the significant cost of installing scrubbers, known as selective catalytic reduction equipment, on Rocky Mountain Power’s Hunter and Huntington power plants would exceed the value of the environmental benefits that would result.

Rocky Mountain Power is Utah’s largest energy provider.

Despite these arguments, Utah submitted proposals to the EPA outlining what it thought it could do about the smokestack pollution, but the agency found the plan wanting in many respects. 

Among other things, federal regulators said, the state implementation plan included no permanent or enforceable emissions controls.

Under President Joe Biden, the EPA’s good neighbor rule was expanded to require Utah and 20 others states to limit emissions within their borders that are causing excessive ozone and other pollution problems in other states.

After finding Utah’s mitigation plan didn’t pass muster, the EPA published an announcement in the Federal Register that it was imposing a plan requiring the installation of the costly emission controls in Utah’s coal-fired plants.

Utah immediately filed a legal challenge, seeking judicial review of the agency’s decision.

In fact, Utah had long expected to have a legal battle on its hands.

In January, before the conflict with the EPA came to a head, Utah House Majority Leader Mike Schultz, a Republican, filed a motion that vowed the state would “push back on the federal regulatory overreach that threatens our ability to provide power to our state, fuel our economy and maintain a high quality of life for the people [of] the state.” 

During Utah’s last legislative session, GOP lawmakers also set aside $2 million to fight the state’s legal battle against the EPA.

The case, State of Utah, et al., v Environmental Protection Agency, et al., is still pending, but environmentalists saw Monday’s decision as a big deal.

“Today’s decision is a win for clean air, public health and the rule of law,” said Noha Haggag, a clean air attorney for the Environmental Defense Fund, which was a party to the case.

“It means we can continue protecting the health of millions of people in downwind states from the dangerous smog being emitted by their neighbors,” she said. “EPA has a long history of protecting downwind states under the good neighbor provisions of the Clean Air Act, and today’s ruling underscores the solid legal foundation of the Good Neighbor Plan.”

Other advocacy groups defending the good neighbor rule include the Clean Air Council, the Clean Air Task Force, Air Alliance Houston and EarthJustice.

Dan can be reached at [email protected] and @DanMcCue

A+
a-
  • Environmental Protection Agency
  • EPA
  • good neighbor plan
  • power plant emissions
  • SCRs
  • selective catalytic reduction equipment
  • Utah
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Environment

    These Surreal Trees Survived for Centuries. Scientists Worry for Their Future

    SOCOTRA, Yemen (AP) — On a windswept plateau high above the Arabian Sea, Sena Keybani cradles a sapling that barely... Read More

    SOCOTRA, Yemen (AP) — On a windswept plateau high above the Arabian Sea, Sena Keybani cradles a sapling that barely reaches her ankle. The young plant, protected by a makeshift fence of wood and wire, is a kind of dragon’s blood tree — a species found... Read More

    May 14, 2025
    by Tom Ramstack
    EPA Revises Rules on ‘Forever Chemicals’ Found in Drinking Water

    WASHINGTON — The Environmental Protection Agency announced Wednesday that it is rolling back limits on the "forever chemicals" that have... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Environmental Protection Agency announced Wednesday that it is rolling back limits on the "forever chemicals" that have been found in the nation's drinking water. The chemicals, known as PFAS, have been linked to cancer and reproductive health problems. They are commonly used in... Read More

    EPA Announces Broad Reorganization That Includes Shuffle of Scientific Research

    The Environmental Protection Agency on Friday announced a broad reorganization as part of the Trump administration's drive to cut costs... Read More

    The Environmental Protection Agency on Friday announced a broad reorganization as part of the Trump administration's drive to cut costs that some activists worry will harm the agency's independent scientific research. Administrator Lee Zeldin announced changes that included creating a new unit within his office “to... Read More

    Justice Department Sues Hawaii, Michigan, Vermont and New York Over State Climate Actions

    DETROIT (AP) — The U.S. Justice Department filed lawsuits against four states this week, claiming their climate actions conflict with... Read More

    DETROIT (AP) — The U.S. Justice Department filed lawsuits against four states this week, claiming their climate actions conflict with federal authority and President Donald Trump'senergy dominance agenda. The DOJ on Wednesday filed lawsuits against Hawaii and Michigan over their plans for legal action against fossil fuel companies for harms caused... Read More

    April 30, 2025
    by Tom Ramstack
    Trump Administration Dismisses Scientists Preparing Climate Change Report

    WASHINGTON — The Trump administration this week dismissed all contributors to a study designed to help the U.S. government prepare... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Trump administration this week dismissed all contributors to a study designed to help the U.S. government prepare for climate change. The study, called the National Climate Assessment, was mandated by Congress under the Global Change Research Act of 1990. It was due for... Read More

    Decision Looming for Trump Administration on First PFAS Drinking Water Limits

    In pain so bad he couldn’t stand, Chris Meek was rushed to the hospital with a life-threatening ruptured gallbladder. When... Read More

    In pain so bad he couldn’t stand, Chris Meek was rushed to the hospital with a life-threatening ruptured gallbladder. When he emerged from surgery, he learned he had kidney cancer that thankfully hadn’t yet spread. Meek, a social studies teacher in Wilmington, North Carolina, was 47... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top