FEC Rules Campaigns Can Get Discounts on Cybersecurity
WASHINGTON – The Federal Election Commission ruled Thursday that federal candidates and political committees can accept low-cost cybersecurity services from a Silicon Valley security company so long as the firm continues to offer the same rates to its non-political clients.
The firm, Area 1 Security, Inc., first approached the commission in June, requesting permission to offer low-to-no-cost services to political candidates during the 2020 election cycle.
The company was founded in 2013 by a group of former National Security Agency hackers, and it specializes in crawling the web for signs of phishing.
In December, it successfully uncovered a phishing attack on the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in Cyprus that compromised the entire EU’s diplomatic communication network.
In approaching the FEC, the company cited a 2018 ruling by the agency that allowed Microsoft to offer free account security to political candidates.
In Microsoft’s case, it stood the risk of long-term damage to its reputation if its clients were hacked.
But at a hearing on Area 1’s request in June, lawyers for the commission said the company’s request should be rejected on the grounds that it would be violating campaign finance laws that prohibit corporations from offering free or discounted services to federal candidates.
The same law also prevents political parties from offering candidates cybersecurity assistance because it is considered an “in-kind donation.”
The attorneys dropped their opposition after learning Area 1 would simply be offering the same low-cost services to candidates as it does to its regular clients.
In its ruling, technically an “advisory opinion,” the commission stated that Area 1 could charge candidates a fixed fee of $1,337 for its phishing services, “because doing so would be in the ordinary course of Area 1’s business and on terms and conditions that apply to similarly situated non-political clients.”
As a result, wrote commission chair Ellen Weintraub, “the commission concludes that the proposal would not result in prohibited in-kind contributions and thus is permissible.”
She did note, however, that any change in the material facts on which the opinion was based, would effectively render it null and void.
She also said the conclusions in the advisory opinion could be affected by subsequent developments in the law including, but not limited to, statutes, regulations, advisory opinions, and case law.
In June, House Democrats passed sweeping legislation that would require voting systems to use backup paper ballots in federal contests, while also banning voting machines from being connected to the internet and being produced in foreign countries.
In addition the Securing America’s Federal Elections Act, introduced by Representative Zoe Lofgren, D-Calif., authorized $600 million for the Election Assistance Commission, which would be allocated to states to enhance their security ahead of 2020, and $175 million that would be provided biannually for “sustainment” funds intended to maintain election infrastructure.
The House voted 225-184 in favor of the bill, with only one Republican, Florida Representative Brian Mast, voting for the measure.
To date, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell has declined to bring it — or any other election security bill to the Senate floor.
In The News
WASHINGTON -- A congressional hearing Friday showed that foreign computer hackers are facing a growing likelihood of counterattack from the United States as a result of the SolarWinds software breach. Lawmakers and computer industry officials agreed the hackers must face consequences to deter them in the... Read More
WASHINGTON (AP) — Jolted by a sweeping hack that may have revealed government and corporate secrets to Russia, U.S. officials are scrambling to reinforce the nation's cyber defenses and recognizing that an agency created two years ago to protect America's networks and infrastructure lacks the money,... Read More
WASHINGTON -- Cybersecurity experts suggested to a congressional committee Wednesday that lawmakers act quickly to address growing threats from hackers. They mentioned the SolarWinds computer infiltration by the Russians last year and a hacker’s attempt to poison a Florida municipal water supply last week as examples.... Read More
ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. (AP) — A hacker's botched attempt to poison the water supply of a small Florida city is raising alarms about just how vulnerable the nation's water systems may be to attacks by more sophisticated intruders. Treatment plants are typically cash-strapped, and lack the... Read More
WASHINGTON — Dramatic changes in the workforce and service delivery have posed unique security challenges over the last year. Evolving technologies are accommodating training and remote work, but new cybersecurity threats continue to emerge. In the last few years, directives have required federal agencies to take... Read More
Recent cyberattacks on U.S. federal systems point to the need to make the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Agency the "centralizing authority system" for the nation, said Rep. John Katko, R-N.Y., during a fireside chat at the State of Net Conference. That said, Katko went on to say... Read More