Loading...

Brooking Institution Explores Connections Between Race, Social Capital, and Vanishing Economic Mobility

January 14, 2021 by Daniel Mollenkamp January 14, 2021by Daniel Mollenkamp
Brooking Institution Explores Connections Between Race, Social Capital, and Vanishing Economic Mobility
Monument Square in Racine, Wisconsin, which the Brookings Institution says is the U.S. city with the least economic mobility.

The Brooking Institution’s How We Rise project last week presented the results from its study on the role of social networks and geography in economic mobility, offering data on this important factor for those attempting to understand or improve opportunities for social advancement in the US. 

Research, such as this 2015 Pew report, has shown that upward mobility in the US is declining. Often cited projects like Opportunity Insights show a steep fall in the number of children who earn more household income than their parents over the past half century, particularly for the middle class. 

According to the authors of the recent Brookings paper, a critical factor to upward mobility is the “access to support, information, power, and resources” inherent to interpersonal relationships found in family, friends, and colleagues. It is the access to these opportunities which is so often connected to the concept of the American dream, a dream in which circumstances of birth don’t define economic outcomes.

Brooking’s How We Rise project is a part of its Race, Prosperity, and Inclusion Initiative, which seeks to offer policy solutions that “combat systemic racism and build a more equitable society.” Camille Busette, a former executive from the World Bank, directs the program.

The paper intended to compare social networking tendencies across a few American cities in order to create a bed of data on which future policy platforms can rest. 

It inspected three American cities with different rates of economic mobility based on surveys with 254 participants between May and July of last year: Racine, Wis., Washington, DC, and San Francisco, Calif.

Racine, the smallest city on the list, represented the profile with the least amount of economic mobility of the three cities (and the smallest population of Blacks). In contrast, San Francisco represented relatively high economic mobility and Washington, DC, represented moderate mobility. The researchers built and analyzed profiles of the respondents as well as who they had reached out to for help in education, housing, or jobs. 

The full report can be read here

The paper suggests a consistent difference in access to interpersonal networks across race, a sort of loose segregation of “social capital”, which may help to pinpoint some of the differences in upward mobility across the country which have been noted over the last few years. 

Among the specific conclusions of the paper were:

  • Race was the most consistent and important factor that distinguished networks. 
  • In Racine and Washington, the low and moderate economic mobility cities, race and gender were the two most important factors for categorizing economic mobility. 
  • In San Francisco, it was race and individual income (above or below $50,000 annual salary) that most accounted for differences.
  • Black males tended to have smaller networks.
  • Relative to the areas of interest for this study– education, jobs, and housing– Whites in all three cities had the most racially homogeneous networks. 
  • In DC, particularly, White male networks were remarkably segregated, resting at about 97% racially homogenous.

Racine was the city with the least economic mobility. Economic opportunities for Black males in Racine drag considerably behind other cities in the US, according to factors such as household income as tracked by the Opportunity Index. The city was named as the second worst city for African Americans to live in a 2019 24/7 Wall St. report, which made its determination based on analysis of racial disparity. 

Maurice Horton, who is the alderman for District 7 on the northwest side of Racine, emphasized a lack of trust and knowledge, particularly among the Black males in that community as an important factor, during a phone interview. 

“I think it’s just awareness of the opportunities that are going on, and then there’s the issue of trust in the African American community and other [marginalized] races,” Alderman Horton said.

Racine itself is a small city, with a population of about 80,000, which means that people tend to know each other and where government officials are reachable, Horton said. But even still, it can be hard for people to become connected to the resources and opportunities in the town, he added.

He drew attention to the fact that the Brookings paper showed that social networking is particularly low among African American males in Racine. In contrast, social networking among White men was comparatively high, and this is visible at the networking events, he said.

“At a big event, you might have no more than five to six African American men there that are working in the areas where their counterparts are working.”

The Brookings report recommends a trio of legislative commitments that it claims would improve mobility across all three disparate mobility profiles: honest engagement with racial dynamics, collaborative efforts across racial lines with an identified accountability for equity goals, and, finally, a focus on areas with the greatest potential for equity gains in the next three to five years. 

In The News

Health

Voting

Think Tanks

June 23, 2022
by Madeline Hughes
Reigniting Democracy Using the Internet

WASHINGTON — Laughter rang out at the Brookings Institution when an audience question came to two White House staffers: “Was... Read More

WASHINGTON — Laughter rang out at the Brookings Institution when an audience question came to two White House staffers: “Was the internet a mistake?” The question came about a half hour into a discussion about how the U.S. is inspiring a global effort to reignite the... Read More

June 13, 2022
by Eden Metzger
Study Suggests America’s Primary Election System Ripe for Reform

WASHINGTON — Political primaries are not mentioned in the Constitution of the United States, but it’s highly likely the founding... Read More

WASHINGTON — Political primaries are not mentioned in the Constitution of the United States, but it’s highly likely the founding fathers would have rejected them outright had anyone thought to suggest them at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia in 1787. Primaries came into being as a... Read More

May 25, 2022
by Alexa Hornbeck
USDA Steps Up Efforts to Restock Baby Formula for WIC Beneficiaries

WASHINGTON — Many Americans desperately seeking baby formula have experienced empty shelves over the last few months. Now the U.S.... Read More

WASHINGTON — Many Americans desperately seeking baby formula have experienced empty shelves over the last few months. Now the U.S. Department of Agriculture is increasing efforts to restock those shelves, especially for low-income families where the impact of the shortage has been most severe. “It goes... Read More

May 16, 2022
by Kate Michael
Countries Negotiating First Legally Binding Global Agreement to End Plastic Pollution

WASHINGTON — Countries have been negotiating limits on plastic use for years, but China’s 2018 announcement that it would stop... Read More

WASHINGTON — Countries have been negotiating limits on plastic use for years, but China’s 2018 announcement that it would stop accepting 24 kinds of plastic scrap import waste from foreign countries was undoubtedly a spark that ignited 175 countries of the United Nations to pass a... Read More

May 13, 2022
by Kate Michael
Consensus, Sabotage Spoiling WTO According to Former Director

WASHINGTON — As the World Trade Organization plans to convene in Geneva next month for its 12th ministerial conference, top... Read More

WASHINGTON — As the World Trade Organization plans to convene in Geneva next month for its 12th ministerial conference, top officials — including the WTO’s last director — wonder if this conference will be a “make or break" moment for the only global international organization that... Read More

May 8, 2022
by Reece Nations
Ukraine Invasion Could Influence Biden’s National Security Strategy

WASHINGTON — Foreign policy and defense experts think Russia’s invasion of Ukraine could complicate the Biden administration’s national security plans.... Read More

WASHINGTON — Foreign policy and defense experts think Russia’s invasion of Ukraine could complicate the Biden administration’s national security plans. Classified versions of President Biden’s National Security Strategy, Nuclear Posture Review and National Defense Strategy were transmitted to Congress in late March, but the official release... Read More

News From The Well