Permanent Solutions Needed to Close Digital Divide

February 18, 2021 by Victoria Turner
Permanent Solutions Needed to Close Digital Divide

Substantial federal help is needed to assure affordable broadband access to disadvantaged communities, according to Wednesday’s witnesses before the House Commerce and Energy Committee’s Subcommittee on Communications and Technology.

The virtual hearing, entitled “Connecting America: Broadband Solutions to the Pandemic Problems,” focused on the digital divide that separates communities with high-speed broadband access from those without. The remote work and distance learning demands created by the novel coronavirus have exaggerated this divide, particularly for communities of color, lower-income and rural communities. “The pandemic has laid this inequality bare,” said Subcommittee Chairman Mike Doyle, D-Penn.

The subcommittee members and witnesses discussed two current legislative proposals now on the table to expand broadband access and affordability. The consensus among the witnesses was that, despite assistance to underserved communities and public education, these legislative actions are short-term solutions for an ongoing issue and longer-standing federal solutions need to be implemented.

One program discussed was the $3.2 billion allocated towards the Emergency Broadband Benefit program in the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2021 to expand access to reach these communities. The other legislative solution was one approved by the full committee for budget reconciliation of fiscal year 2021 to create a $7.6 billion Emergency Connectivity Fund that would allow schools and libraries to provide teachers and students with internet service and connected devices, as well as hotspots for at-home internet use to close this homework gap.

The temporary EBB program also provides grants to minority-serving anchor institutions, businesses and nonprofit organizations through the National Telecommunications and Internet Association, additional funding to the Federal Communications Commission’s COVID-19 Telehealth Program, pandemic-related discounts for broadband service and low-cost devices for eligible households on in disadvantaged communities and Tribal lands, and two grant programs under the NTIA to support broadband deployment into Tribal lands and other rural areas lacking connectivity.

Despite these legislative actions being a “much-needed step to help rescue American people,” it is a “band-aid solution to a much bigger access and affordability issue,” said Rep. Yvette Clarke, D-N.Y.

The FCC’s existing E-rate program, which assists schools and libraries in funding technology, first established in 1996, should be expanded to include district funding for reimbursement to eligible households for their at-home studies, according to Dr. Tiffany Anderson, superintendent of Topeka Public Schools in Kansas.

Once the pandemic is over, Anderson said, the need for connectivity will remain and so will the digital divide, unless help is directed to “meet families where they are” and help them “move out of poverty.” The continuance of federal post-pandemic funding in this area is a must, she said, for it is an “equity opportunity gap.”

Jonathan Adelstein, president and CEO of Wireless Infrastructure Association, points out that the nation has seen a 20% increase in mobile online traffic since the onset of the pandemic. 

Despite the wireless industry keeping up with this increased demand due to heavy yearly investment by the industry, there are still about 18 million Americans who are not connected because broadband deployment in urban, suburban, and higher-income communities outpaces that of rural, low-income ones.

Adelstein said that sizable federal funding must be used for operational and infrastructure costs to accelerate the deployment needed in underserved communities without disrupting the connectivity of others. Adelstein also requested additional funds be put towards expanding the workforce, by “up-skilling” and “reskilling” workers through apprenticeships and other employer-sponsored training programs.

 “We need to make sure we get broadband where it needs to be,” he added. 

All witnesses pointed towards the ‘Moving America Forward Act,’ approved by the House but not the Senate last year, as a reference point for the size of federal funding necessary. 

However, the crux of the ongoing cross-aisle debate seems to fall on the level of regulatory oversight the government should have in infrastructure deployment, access and pricing.

Republicans claim that the light regulatory touch of prior Republican administrations has led to private investment in infrastructure that has created robust networks able to satisfy the increased online traffic, which other countries struggled with in the first year of the pandemic. 

They argue that cutting regulatory red-tape, particularly in permits, would allow for expedited deployment. On the other hand, their Democratic counterparts said this lack of oversight is what led to the digital divide in the first place, with internet providers choosing the areas for expansion, increasing prices as they saw fit or putting data caps on their customers. This debate has spanned two decades.

Congress needs to work across the aisle to implement new programs and improve existing ones, said Rep. Tom O’Halleran, D-Ariz., If not, the country will continue coming back to this debate that has left rural America “basically…forgotten for two decades.”

A+
a-
  • broadband
  • Congress
  • digital divide
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Technology

    Amazon to Spend $20B on Data Centers Including One Next to a Nuclear Power Plant

    HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) — Amazon said Monday that it will spend $20 billion on two data center complexes in Pennsylvania,... Read More

    HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) — Amazon said Monday that it will spend $20 billion on two data center complexes in Pennsylvania, including one it is building alongside a nuclear power plant that has drawn federal scrutiny over an arrangement to essentially plug right into the power plant. Kevin Miller,... Read More

    State of the AV Industry in 2025: Progress, Promise and the Path Forward

    The Autonomous Vehicle Industry Association recently released our second annual “State of AV” report. The message is clear: autonomous vehicles are no... Read More

    The Autonomous Vehicle Industry Association recently released our second annual “State of AV” report. The message is clear: autonomous vehicles are no longer just a promise of the future, they are a reality on American roads today. From Phoenix to Pittsburgh and Dallas to Detroit, AVs are safely... Read More

    May 21, 2025
    by Tom Ramstack
    Industry Execs Ask Congress for Uniform AI Rules

    WASHINGTON – Artificial intelligence technologies are evolving at a breakneck speed but the regulations that govern them are not, according... Read More

    WASHINGTON – Artificial intelligence technologies are evolving at a breakneck speed but the regulations that govern them are not, according to industry executives at a congressional hearing Wednesday. The result is a complex web of state and federal regulations that threatens to slow innovation and limit... Read More

    US Cable Giants Charter and Cox, Under Assault by Streaming Services, Pursue $34.5B Merger

    Charter Communications has offered to acquire Cox Communications, a $34.5 billion merger that would combine two of the top three... Read More

    Charter Communications has offered to acquire Cox Communications, a $34.5 billion merger that would combine two of the top three cable companies in the U.S. Cox is the third largest cable television company in the country, with more than 6.5 million digital cable, internet, telephone, and... Read More

    The Road to Innovation and Prosperity

    When was the last time you bought film for a camera? Or drove to a store to rent a movie?... Read More

    When was the last time you bought film for a camera? Or drove to a store to rent a movie? How often do you look to flag down a cab rather than summon a ride using a phone app? All these industries and many more have... Read More

    Beyond American Borders: Why the FTC's Case Against WhatsApp Matters Globally

    As the Federal Trade Commission's landmark antitrust trial against Meta begins, American regulators are focused on a seemingly straightforward question:... Read More

    As the Federal Trade Commission's landmark antitrust trial against Meta begins, American regulators are focused on a seemingly straightforward question: Did Mark Zuckerberg's company illegally suppress competition by acquiring Instagram and WhatsApp? While this case appears centered on U.S. competition policy, the consequences of a potential... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top