Golfers Sue Under Antitrust Laws to Compete in Saudi Arabia

August 4, 2022 by Tom Ramstack
Golfers Sue Under Antitrust Laws to Compete in Saudi Arabia
Henrik Stenson, of Sweden, holds the trophy after winning the LIV Golf Invitational at Trump National in Bedminster, N.J., Sunday, July 31, 2022. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig)

WASHINGTON — Eleven pro golfers led by six-time major champion Phil Mickelson on Wednesday challenged their suspension from competing in the United States after they participated in the Saudi-financed LIV Golf series.

Their antitrust lawsuit filed in San Francisco, California, carries potential broad implications for the authority of the Professional Golfers’ Association and other sports leagues to enforce restrictions on players, all of whom claim status as independent contractors.

The lawsuit says “the [PGA] Tour has evolved into an entrenched monopolist with a vi[s]e grip on professional golf.”

“As the tour’s monopoly power has grown, it has employed its dominance to craft an arsenal of anticompetitive restraints to protect its long-standing monopoly,” says the complaint filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California.

The allegations explain why the Justice Department started an investigation last month of the PGA Tour. The sports league suspended Mickelson and 16 other golfers for participating in the LIV Golf series.

In a June 9 memo to other golfers, the PGA explained its reasons by saying, “These players have made their choice for their own financial-based reasons. But they can’t demand the same PGA TOUR membership benefits, considerations, opportunities and platform as you. That expectation disrespects you, our fans and our partners.”

LIV Golf offers record prize money to players through the financial support of Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund. Mickelson’s contract is reportedly worth about $200 million.

One reason players who accept the deals are enduring criticism in the media is their association with the Saudi government and its history of human rights abuses, including the murder of Washington Post columnist Jamal Khashoggi.

Their lawsuit did not address the Saudi human rights record, only the competition the LIV Golf series presents for the PGA.

“It is no secret that the PGA Tour is targeting players in order to defeat the threat of competitive entry,” the lawsuit says. “The PGA Tour has been clear since the threat of competitive entry emerged that its most powerful weapon to defeat competition is to target its members — who comprise virtually all of the elite professional golfers in the world — to prevent them from playing on a competing tour.”

PGA Tour Commissioner Jay Monahan invoked the league’s “Conflicting Events Regulation” as part of his justification for the suspension. The regulation prohibits PGA Tour members from participating “in any other golf tournament or event” if a PGA Tour-sanctioned event is scheduled in the same week.

The PGA Tour has sanctioned events scheduled nearly every week of the year.

The rule grants exceptions for international events at the discretion of the commissioner but Monahan is not granting them for LIV Golf.

The lawsuit seeks an injunction against the suspensions, saying that banning the golfers from PGA Tour events would hurt their incomes and cause them “irreparable harm.”

The timing of the lawsuit carries special importance for three of the 11 golfers who are suing.

Talor Gooch, Matt Jones and Hudson Swafford qualified for the PGA Tour’s FedEx Cup Playoffs that started this week. They want a temporary restraining order to lift their suspensions so they can play in the tournament.

The legal terms being invoked in their lawsuit and by their professional golf supporters indicate the consequences stretch deep into other sports leagues.

Earlier this year, LIV Golf Investments chief executive and retired professional golfer Greg Norman wrote a memo to PGA Tour agents and players saying they lacked a right to ban golfers who also participate in a competing league.

“Simply put, your players enjoy the freedom under law to choose how they make a living,” Norman wrote. “In our view and in the eyes of the law, the PGA Tour’s threats are utterly impermissible under competition and other laws.”

The U.S. Supreme Court reached a similar conclusion in its 1957 ruling of Radovich v. NFL. The ruling said antitrust laws allowed National Football League players to join competing leagues without risk of punishment by league officials.

Other federal courts also have ruled that professional sports leagues are subject to the Sherman Act, which outlaws “every contract, combination, or conspiracy in restraint of trade,” and any “monopolization, attempted monopolization, or conspiracy or combination to monopolize.”

Some of the golfers in the lawsuit filed Wednesday say they could transform the PGA Tour and other sports leagues.

Mickelson explained to journalist Alan Shipnuck in February his motivation for joining the LIV Golf series.

“They’re scary mother [expletive] to get involved with,” Mickelson reportedly said. “We know they killed [Washington Post reporter Jamal] Khashoggi and have a horrible record on human rights. They execute people over there for being gay. Knowing all of this, why would I even consider it? Because this is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to reshape how the PGA Tour operates.”

The case is Phil Mickelson, et al. v. PGA Tour, Inc., case number 3:22-cv-04486, in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California.

Tom can be reached at [email protected] and @TomRamstack

A+
a-
  • golfers
  • lawsuit
  • LIV Golf Series
  • Phil Mickelson
  • Professional Golfers' Association
  • Saudi Arabia
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Sports

    October 18, 2023
    by Jesse Zucker
    Disc Golf Great Way to Stay Fit in the Fall

    WASHINGTON — Are you keeping up with the latest social sports trends here in the district? Disc (or frisbee) golf... Read More

    WASHINGTON — Are you keeping up with the latest social sports trends here in the district? Disc (or frisbee) golf isn’t new. In fact, it dates back to the 1960s but became more popular during the pandemic. It’s a great way to get outside, get moving... Read More

    October 17, 2023
    by Tom Ramstack
    Senators Want Federal Legislation to Reform College Sports Abuses

    WASHINGTON — A Senate committee won agreement Tuesday from some college athletic officials that federal legislation might be needed to... Read More

    WASHINGTON — A Senate committee won agreement Tuesday from some college athletic officials that federal legislation might be needed to halt abuses of student athletes. They contribute to a $16-billion-a-year industry but often receive little compensation for their efforts and sometimes sacrifice the quality of their... Read More

    Adam Wainwright Easing Into Retirement With New Puppy, TV Work and Country Music

    Days after his playing career ended, Adam Wainwright is dealing with a pressing issue. A cute, fluffy one. Louie, a Lagotto... Read More

    Days after his playing career ended, Adam Wainwright is dealing with a pressing issue. A cute, fluffy one. Louie, a Lagotto Romagnolo puppy that was gifted to Wainwright by the St. Louis Cardinals — his only major league team — is at the center of a running family... Read More

    July 20, 2023
    by Carter Schaffer
    Bipartisan Act Would Ensure National College Athlete Protections

    WASHINGTON — The College Athletes Protection and Compensation Act discussion draft released on Thursday would establish national name, image and... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The College Athletes Protection and Compensation Act discussion draft released on Thursday would establish national name, image and likeness standards, cover athletic injury expenses and increase transparency in college athletics. The three U.S. senators behind the act — Richard Blumenthal, D-Conn., Jerry Moran, R-Kan.,... Read More

    July 17, 2023
    by Carter Schaffer
    Major League Soccer’s All-Star Week Coming to Washington

    WASHINGTON — The annual Major League Soccer All-Star game is coming to Audi Field in Southwest D.C. on Wednesday, July... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The annual Major League Soccer All-Star game is coming to Audi Field in Southwest D.C. on Wednesday, July 19, with a team of the league’s best taking on Arsenal F.C. of the English Premier League. As part of the festivities, First Lady Dr. Jill... Read More

    July 12, 2023
    by Carter Schaffer
    PGA-LIV Golf Partnership Questioned in Senate Committee

    WASHINGTON — A congressional subcommittee on Tuesday spent hours scrutinizing a $1 billion proposal to create a new golf competition... Read More

    WASHINGTON — A congressional subcommittee on Tuesday spent hours scrutinizing a $1 billion proposal to create a new golf competition controlled by the PGA Tour, a business plan that inspired controversy due to the involvement of Saudi Arabia's sovereign wealth fund. The Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top