Environmentalists Fire Back Against Oil Industry in Lawsuit over Greenhouse Gas Regulation

January 20, 2023 by Tom Ramstack
Environmentalists Fire Back Against Oil Industry in Lawsuit over Greenhouse Gas Regulation
(Photo by Jplenio via Pixabay)

WASHINGTON — Environmentalists tried this week to strike down efforts by oil industry supporters who are challenging U.S. government warnings about greenhouse gasses.

They filed a brief that urged a federal appeals court in Washington, D.C., to dismiss a lawsuit by the pro-fossil fuel groups against the Environmental Protection Agency.

The EPA issued the warnings about health and welfare consequences in 2009 prior to a regulatory crackdown on greenhouse gas emissions.

The lawsuit by Concerned Household Electricity Consumers Council and others says the EPA is unrealistic in its fossil fuel restrictions while endangering the economy. They also claim the EPA warnings are not well established by science.

The environmentalists’ brief filed this week says the plaintiffs have no legal basis for a right to sue the EPA.

They failed to explain how the EPA warnings hurt them or anyone else, which is a prerequisite to any right to sue, the brief says.

The U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia has ruled in previous cases that the EPA findings of danger from greenhouse gasses are well supported. Other evidence comes from the United Nations and scientific groups.

“The Clean Air Act and this court’s precedents do not lightly allow for relitigation of agency determinations that have been subject to a comprehensive public rulemaking process and judicial review,” the environmentalists’ brief says. “Petitioners’ briefs fail to grapple with the robust body of law and the great weight of evidence supporting EPA’s 2009 finding and its subsequent reaffirmations.”

In 2009, the EPA declared that carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide, hydrofluorocarbons, perfluorocarbons and sulfur hexafluoride create a health hazard with current atmospheric concentrations. 

The D.C. Circuit upheld the EPA’s endangerment warning in its 2012 ruling in Coalition for Responsible Regulation et al. v. EPA et al. The U.S. Supreme Court let the ruling stand on appeal.

The EPA issued the endangerment warning before beginning a new round of tougher emission regulations on power plants.

The agency gained greater legal support last year when Congress approved the Inflation Reduction Act. The legislation aims to curb inflation by reducing the deficit, lowering prescription drug prices and by promoting domestic clean energy.

The Inflation Reduction Act identifies the six greenhouse gasses listed by the EPA’s 2009 endangerment warning as pollutants subject to Clean Air Act regulation.

“These provisions express Congress’s own judgment that each of these compounds falls within the definition of ‘air pollutant,’ which applies throughout the act,” the environmentalists’ brief says. “Furthermore, the Inflation Reduction Act requires that EPA use existing Clean Air Act regulatory authorities to reduce emissions of greenhouse gasses. Because those Clean Air Act provisions authorize EPA to regulate emissions of ‘air pollutants,’ they further confirm that greenhouse gasses are indeed such pollutants.”

The brief responds to statements made in the lawsuit by the Concerned Household Electricity Consumers Council, which was joined in suing by the FAIR Energy Foundation, the Competitive Enterprise Institute and Texas Public Policy Foundation.

They petitioned the EPA beginning in 2017 to overturn its endangerment findings but the agency refused. They then sued in federal court to override the EPA.

The oil industry supporters said the EPA’s endangerment finding has set the nation on “a technically and economically impossible crusade to decarbonize the U.S. economy.”

The lawsuit revives some of the issues in last June’s Supreme Court ruling in West Virginia v. EPA, which angered environmentalists.

The case focused on the EPA’s Clean Power Plan, which required power plants to implement clean energy technology, such as solar panels and wind generators. The EPA drew authority from the Clean Air Act.

Several states and coal companies sued to block the plan.

The Supreme Court ruled that Congress never gave the EPA authority to require power plants to use specific technologies to comply with the Clean Air Act. The agency could regulate emissions from existing power plants but not interfere with their choice of how they generate electricity.

Similarly, Concerned Household Electricity Consumers Council is once again arguing the EPA exceeds its authority with its warning about the greenhouse gasses.

Tom can be reached on Twitter at [email protected].


A+
a-
  • Environmentalists
  • greenhouse gases
  • Litigation
  • OIl industry
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Litigation

    September 18, 2023
    by Tom Ramstack
    Hunter Biden Says IRS Invaded His Privacy After Agents Disclosed His Tax Records

    WASHINGTON — Presidential son Hunter Biden sued the Internal Revenue Service on Monday for what he calls an invasion of... Read More

    WASHINGTON — Presidential son Hunter Biden sued the Internal Revenue Service on Monday for what he calls an invasion of his privacy even as he faces unrelated felony gun charges. Biden’s lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia accuses IRS agents of... Read More

    September 18, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    California Sues Oil and Gas Giants Over Climate Change Claims

    OAKLAND, Calif. — California is suing five of the largest oil and gas companies in the world for allegedly engaging... Read More

    OAKLAND, Calif. — California is suing five of the largest oil and gas companies in the world for allegedly engaging in a decadeslong campaign of deception related to climate change and doing nothing as the state endured the growing problems related to a warming planet. The... Read More

    September 14, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    Minnesota Voters Sue to Keep Trump Off Presidential Ballot

    SAINT PAUL, Minn. — Eight Minnesota voters, including a former Minnesota secretary of state, are suing the current occupant of... Read More

    SAINT PAUL, Minn. — Eight Minnesota voters, including a former Minnesota secretary of state, are suing the current occupant of that office in a bid to keep former President Donald Trump from appearing on the state’s ballot in 2024. The lawsuit, which was filed on their... Read More

    September 8, 2023
    by Tom Ramstack
    Appeals Court Revives Psychologists’ Lawsuit After They Were Accused of Helping in Torture

    WASHINGTON — The Washington, D.C., Court of Appeals on Thursday revived a defamation lawsuit by retired military psychologists who claimed... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Washington, D.C., Court of Appeals on Thursday revived a defamation lawsuit by retired military psychologists who claimed they were inaccurately accused of encouraging torture during the U.S. war on terrorism. The ruling also represents a setback for local laws found nationwide intended to... Read More

    August 30, 2023
    by Tom Ramstack
    Giuliani Loses by Default Judgment in Election Workers’ Defamation Lawsuit

    WASHINGTON — Rudy Giuliani was found liable by a federal court in Washington, D.C., Wednesday for defaming two Georgia election... Read More

    WASHINGTON — Rudy Giuliani was found liable by a federal court in Washington, D.C., Wednesday for defaming two Georgia election workers he accused of falsifying ballots to make Donald Trump lose the 2020 presidential election. The ruling from U.S. District Judge Beryl Howell represented a default... Read More

    August 30, 2023
    by Tom Ramstack
    Consumer Group Sues Hyatt Hotels for Undisclosed ‘Resort Fees’

    WASHINGTON — A consumer advocacy group is suing Hyatt Hotels over what the lawsuit filed in Washington, D.C., describes as... Read More

    WASHINGTON — A consumer advocacy group is suing Hyatt Hotels over what the lawsuit filed in Washington, D.C., describes as deceptive fees. The lawsuit invokes the District of Columbia Consumer Protection Procedures Act, which requires honest dealings, such as businesses selling products and services for their... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top