NATO Military Exercises in the Arctic Were Preplanned, Yet Providential

March 17, 2022 by Kate Michael
NATO Military Exercises in the Arctic Were Preplanned, Yet Providential
(Photo by Airman 1st Class Colin Hollowell)

WASHINGTON — While the Arctic is an area of increasing military competition, planned military demonstration exercises off the shores of Norway are happening this week as part of a regular schedule that takes place every other year — and not in response to any specific Russian threat.

Exercise Cold Response 2022, which a Russian delegation was invited to observe but declined, involves some 30,000 troops from 27 nations operating together to demonstrate their ability to compete in one of the harshest environments in the world.

But while the demonstrations are not reactionary, Arctic nations are concerned about how Russia’s actions in Ukraine will affect Arctic cooperation now and into the future and are using these exercises to stoke interest in regional and global security in the Arctic.

“All eight Arctic nations have worked together to advance a region that is stable and committed to the rule of law,” Mike Sfraga, founding director of the Wilson Center’s Polar Institute and chair of the U.S. Arctic Research Commission, recently told an online gathering of the Polar Institute and the Norwegian Institute of International Affairs.

“In the past … days, you and I have witnessed the fabric of Arctic cooperation fraying because of the actions of one Arctic nation, outside of the Arctic region. But the implications of these actions have rippled through every facet of the Arctic.”

Arctic experts at the Wilson Center discussion examined how recent events affect what had previously been a region of low tension and cooperation in the Circumpolar North, including the unprecedented temporary but indefinite pause of the Arctic Council — which Russia currently chairs.

“I think Russia’s standing in the Arctic has … been reduced to junk status,” James P. DeHart, U.S. coordinator for the Arctic Region in the U.S. State Department said, “because the Arctic is a region of strong rules and international law, a commitment to sovereignty, and territorial integrity. And when Russia violates those core principles so egregiously, not so far from the Arctic, how can it be otherwise that they lose standing everywhere?”

“There is no defensible return to any kind of new normal, or even the post-2014 normal we had with Putin and Russia,” Elana Wilson Rowe of the Norwegian Institute of International Affairs said. “The pause, or freeze, was unavoidable with respect for international law, which is a key aspect for the Arctic, so the Arctic Council could not be used as business as usual … for Russia.”

Yet despite current events, many believe that some practical, cross-border maritime operations should continue, not to mention that it could be detrimental to the Earth to wait out a military conflict to continue research on climate change.

Putin’s war is not in the Arctic, but the Arctic does not remain untouched.

“In the Arctic, Russia is quite well served by international law and international order,” Rowe reminded. “So perhaps [Russia] is not likely to challenge it there. But [Arctic nations] can’t be accepting partial engagement with international law.”

So a region that has environmental and commercial connectivity to the entire world is feeling the tension of a shifting geopolitical landscape that is changing due to the actions of its largest member, and NATO member countries and partners just happen to have planned military exercises there, testing their ability to work together on land, in the air and at sea.

“NATO at this moment does not have an Arctic strategy or clear Arctic policy, and its approach to the Arctic has been particularly cautious,” Katarina Kertysova, policy fellow with the European Leadership Network, said.

“Cold Response will likely make waves,” she warned. “Not doing the exercise would have been seen by Putin as a lack of resolve, so it is good for deterrence, but there is always the risk of unintended escalation.”

Kate can be reached at [email protected]


A+
a-
  • Arctic competition
  • military
  • military exercises
  • NATO
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Geopolitics

    US Military May Put Armed Troops on Commercial Ships in Strait of Hormuz to Stop Iran Seizures

    DUBAI, United Arab Emirates (AP) — The U.S. military is considering putting armed personnel on commercial ships traveling through the... Read More

    DUBAI, United Arab Emirates (AP) — The U.S. military is considering putting armed personnel on commercial ships traveling through the Strait of Hormuz, in what would be an unheard of action aimed at stopping Iran from seizing and harassing civilian vessels, five American officials told The... Read More

    New NATO Member Finland Swears In Government Regarded as Country's Most Right-Wing in Decades

    HELSINKI (AP) — Finland, which recently became NATO's 31st member, swore in a new coalition government Tuesday that is considered... Read More

    HELSINKI (AP) — Finland, which recently became NATO's 31st member, swore in a new coalition government Tuesday that is considered the most right-wing one in the Nordic country's modern history. President Sauli Niinistö appointed the 19-member Cabinet of Prime Minister Petteri Orpo, the leader of the... Read More

    Zelenskyy Attends Arab Summit in Saudi Arabia, Where Many Leaders Are Close to Moscow

    EDDAH, Saudi Arabia (AP) — Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy arrived in Saudi Arabia ahead of an Arab summit on Friday,... Read More

    EDDAH, Saudi Arabia (AP) — Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy arrived in Saudi Arabia ahead of an Arab summit on Friday, where he was set to address leaders who have remained largely neutral on Russia's invasion of his country, including many who maintain warm ties with Moscow.... Read More

    Biden Scraps Planned Visit to Australia, Papua New Guinea to Focus on Debt Limit Talks

    WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden said Tuesday he's curtailing his upcoming trip to the Indo-Pacific, scrapping what was to be a historic... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden said Tuesday he's curtailing his upcoming trip to the Indo-Pacific, scrapping what was to be a historic stop in Papua New Guinea as well as a visit to Australia for a gathering with fellow leaders of the so-called Quad partnership so he can focus... Read More

    May 12, 2023
    by Kate Michael
    Experts Consider Future of Foreign Aid in Landscape of Great Power Competition

    WASHINGTON — The U.S. Agency for International Development is an independent agency of the U.S. federal government that has, since... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The U.S. Agency for International Development is an independent agency of the U.S. federal government that has, since 1961, administered civilian aid to help with extreme poverty, health crises, food insecurity and climate change in more than a hundred countries around the world. USAID... Read More

    Russia Arrests Wall Street Journal Reporter on Spying Charge

    Russia's security service arrested an American reporter for The Wall Street Journal on espionage charges, the first time a U.S.... Read More

    Russia's security service arrested an American reporter for The Wall Street Journal on espionage charges, the first time a U.S. correspondent has been detained on spying accusations since the Cold War. The newspaper denied the allegations. Evan Gershkovich was detained in the Ural Mountains city of... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top