Trump’s Claim of Bias by New York AG Rejected in Foundation Suit
November 24, 2018
NEW YORK — President Donald Trump’s claim that a New York lawsuit against his personal charitable foundation was motivated by political bias of the state attorney general’s office was rejected by a judge.
New York State Supreme Court Justice Saliann Scarpulla on Friday denied a request from Trump and his foundation to dismiss the suit in which the president and his three eldest children are accused of engaging in a decadelong pattern of self-dealing and using the nonprofit’s funds for political purposes.
The lawsuit is one of the most serious legal challenges facing Trump and his family. Unless an appeals court blocks the attorney general, the process of uncovering evidence will allow the state’s lawyers to reach deep into the Trump family’s financial dealings, where some of the president’s critics believe there will be evidence of yearslong improprieties.
Scarpulla said it isn’t the job of the court to determine the motivation of a government agency at this point in the case, and that the lawsuit was filed after Eric Schneiderman, the former attorney general who resigned in an abuse scandal, left office. Trump frequently clashed with Schneiderman, who was a key figure in the resistance to Trump’s agenda.
“There is no basis for finding that animus and bias were the sole motivating factors for initiating the investigation and pursuing this proceeding,” the judge said in the ruling.
Neither the White House nor the foundation’s lawyer, Alan Futerfas, immediately returned calls for comment.
The foundation’s lawyers also argued at a hearing in October that a half-dozen transactions at the center of the lawsuit, including $10,000 the charity spent at an auction to buy a 6-foot oil portrait of Trump, were innocent because the money wound up going to charity anyway.
Attorney General Barbara Underwood claims in the lawsuit that the nonprofit was little more than Trump’s “piggy bank,” and that legitimate donations were overshadowed by rampant violations of state charity law and the use of donated funds for business purposes. She’s seeking to dissolve the charity and to ban the president from serving on a New York not-for-profit for 10 years.
“The Trump Foundation functioned as little more than a checkbook to serve Mr. Trump’s business and political interests,” Underwood said in a statement Friday. “There are rules that govern private foundations — and we intend to enforce them, no matter who runs the foundation. We welcome Justice Scarpulla’s decision, which allows our suit to move forward.”
Among the other violations cited was the foundation’s involvement in a January 2016 Trump campaign fundraiser in Iowa. The attorney general alleges the foundation illegally participated in a political campaign by allowing senior campaign staff to dictate how $2.8 million raised at the event was spent, “all for the purpose of influencing the 2016 presidential election.”
A lawsuit against the family’s for-profit business, the Trump Organization, was also filed in October by individuals who claim the Trumps have been ripping off aspiring business owners for years.
©2018 Bloomberg News
Visit Bloomberg News at www.bloomberg.com
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
In The News
WASHINGTON (AP) — Testing wristbands are in. Mask-wearing is mandatory. Desks are socially distanced. The clearest sign that there's a new boss at the White House is the deference being paid to coronavirus public health guidlines. It’s a striking contrast to Donald Trump’s White House, which... Read More
WASHINGTON (AP) — Three new senators were sworn into office Wednesday after President Joe Biden's inauguration, securing the majority for Democrats in the Senate and across a unified government to tackle the new president's agenda at a time of unprecedented national challenges. In a first vote,... Read More
WASHINGTON - Just hours after the President Joe Biden was sworn into office, White House officials announced the acting agency leadership that will assist the new administration in the next phase of the transition of government. These individuals, nearly all of whom are career civil servants,... Read More
WASHINGTON (AP) — In his first hours as president, Joe Biden will aim to strike at the heart of President Donald Trump’s policy legacy, signing a series of executive actions that will reverse his predecessor’s orders on immigration, climate change and handling of the coronavirus pandemic. Biden on... Read More
WASHINGTON (AP) — A steady stream of Trump administration officials are beating an early path to the exits as a protest against the deadly siege of the U.S. Capitol this week even as others wrestling with the stay-or-go question conclude that they owe it to the... Read More
WASHINGTON - Vice President Mike Pence is opposed invoking the 25th Amendment to remove President Donald, with just days to go before the inauguration of Joe Biden as the next president, according to multiple reports Business Insider was the first publication to report on Pence's opposition... Read More