US-UK Free Trade Agreement Stalled Over Ag Disputes

June 22, 2020 by Sara Wilkerson
The opening of the latest round of U.S.-U.K. trade talks.

Trade agreement talks between the United States and the United Kingdom have been tabled for the foreseeable future over a disagreement concerning agricultural practices.

U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer revealed the impasse during testimony before the House Ways and Means Committee last week.

Lighthizer, who spent more than 8 hours on Capitol Hill last Monday said the United States will not compromise its position on agricultural practices as it negotiates a post-Brexit free trade deal with the United Kingdom.

“We either have fair access for agriculture or we won’t have a deal with either one of them [the United Kingdom or the European Union],” he said.

The “fair access” Lighthizer is seeking is the ability of American farmers being able to sell food to United Kingdom farmers without tariffs. 

Johnson’s ‘Dual-Tariff’ Proposal 

In recent months, U.K. Prime Minister Boris Johnson has floated a “dual-tariff” system he hoped would allay concerns on both sides of the bargaining table.

Under the system, products that do not comply with U.K. animal welfare standards would be subject to high import tariffs.

By the same token, a lower tariff regime could be applied to imports that do meet the U.K. standards, such as organically reared, free-range meat.

The National Chicken Council of the United States took issue with Johnson’s plan, insisting that “any free trade deal be just that – free and fair – unfettered by any tariff or non-tariff barriers.” 

Lighthizer also expressed dissatisfaction with the plan, telling the House Ways and Means Committee that UK standards should not be applied at the expense of American farmers. 

“One thing is for sure, we’re not going to be in a position where our farmers aren’t treated fairly,” he said.

Lighthizer went on to explain the U.S.-U.K. trade negotiations had reached an impasse due to the United Kingdom’s claim that food from America is “unsafe”, which he believes to be “thinly veiled protectionism.” 

Lighthizer refuted the United Kingdom’s stance on American food by stating, “I would say the United States has the best agriculture in the world. It has the safest, highest standards. And I think we shouldn’t confuse science with consumer preference.” 

What the United Kingdom appears to most object to is the U.S. meat processing practice of washing chicken in chlorine and other disinfectants to remove harmful bacteria.

The practice was banned by the European Union in 1997 over food safety concerns. It has stopped virtually all imports of US chicken meat which is generally treated by this process.

But Minette Batters, president of the U.K.’s National Farmers Union, said recently the discomfort is “not just about chlorinated chicken.”

“This is about a wider principle,” Batters said. “We must not tie the hands of British farmers to the highest rung of the standards ladder while waving through food imports which may not even reach the bottom rung.” 

She added, “To sign up to a trade deal which results in opening our ports, shelves and fridges to food which would be illegal to produce here would not only be morally bankrupt, it would be the work of the insane.” 

Trade Potential, the Space Sector and Beyond 

Discussion of a post-Brexit free trade agreement began in March. It was then that the U.K.’s Department of International Trade released a 184-page document detailing how it intended to approach negotiations with the United States, its objectives for the trade deal, public response on a U.S.-U.K. agreement, and a preliminary assessment of the U.S.-U.K. trade agreement before it’s put into effect.

According to the document, a free trade agreement between the two nations would boost the total trade value between them “by £15.3 billion [just over $19 billion ] in the long run [15 years from the agreement] … and increase U.K. workers’ wages by £1.8 billion [about $2.2 billion].”

In addition, the agreement would seek to be geared toward the benefit of exchanging professional services such as those of accounting, architecture and legal services, as well as “maximising the United Kingdom’s reach in emerging fields like global data flows and artificial intelligence.” 

In terms of global data flows and AI, the United States and United Kingdom have already brokered progress in this area.  

On June 16, the U.S.-U.K. Technology Safeguards Agreement was signed between the two countries, allowing U.S. companies to participate in United Kingdom space launches. American space companies will greatly benefit from the United Kingdom space sector’s success of having 42,000 people employed in the sector, with incomes generating £14.8 billion, or $18.2 billion, [$18.4 billion to $22.7 billion] every year. 

The United Kingdom Science Minister Amanda Solloway highlighted the enormity of the space agreement by stating, “This deal with the U.S. takes us one step closer to seeing the first ever launch into space from British soil. 

“This is a key moment for our commercial space industry, and I look forward to seeing companies from Scotland to Newquay benefiting, and the creation of highly skilled jobs on both sides of the Atlantic.” 

The U.K.’s ambassador to the U.S., Karen Pierce, remarked on the space technology agreement stating, “This agreement marks an exciting new area for U.K.-U.S. space collaboration and represents a significant step towards U.S. companies launching from United Kingdom spaceports.” 

Pierce continued, saying “The commercial space sector already represents hundreds of millions of dollars in trade between our two countries each year, as well as thousands of jobs on both sides of the Atlantic. This new agreement will generate further growth and prosperity for both our countries.” 

The U.S.-U.K. Technology Safeguards Agreement highlights the cooperation and economic potential between the two allied countries, not just in the space sector but also in the trading arena. The United States is the United Kingdom’s second biggest trading partner, with the European Union being its biggest trading partner. 

Trade

New Trade Accord Between US, Canada and Mexico Goes Into Effect
Trade
New Trade Accord Between US, Canada and Mexico Goes Into Effect
July 1, 2020
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON - It's NAFTA no more. As of 12:01 this morning, the U.S. - Mexico - Canada trade agreement, better known as the USMCA, is in full effect, formally replacing the 26-year-old North American Free Trade Agreement "Today marks the beginning of a new and better... Read More

The Pandemic is Exacerbating America’s Systemic Food Inequality
Food
The Pandemic is Exacerbating America’s Systemic Food Inequality

Access to food has been unequal in America long before the onset of the coronavirus. But the pandemic has deepened the problem, with images of snaking lines at food banks bringing the harsh reality to light. Even in the U.S., one of the most food-secure nations... Read More

US-UK Free Trade Agreement Stalled Over Ag Disputes
Trade
US-UK Free Trade Agreement Stalled Over Ag Disputes
June 22, 2020
by Sara Wilkerson

Trade agreement talks between the United States and the United Kingdom have been tabled for the foreseeable future over a disagreement concerning agricultural practices. U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer revealed the impasse during testimony before the House Ways and Means Committee last week. Lighthizer, who spent... Read More

Maritime Industry Asks Congress for Bailout During Coronavirus
Trade
Maritime Industry Asks Congress for Bailout During Coronavirus
June 1, 2020
by Tom Ramstack

WASHINGTON - Representatives of the U.S. maritime industry asked Congress for an emergency bailout Friday as they described how coronavirus is hurting ports and shippers. They are expecting their revenue to drop by as much as one-quarter below normal levels by mid-2020. Rep. Peter DeFazio, an... Read More

Pompeo Says US No Longer Considers Hong Kong Autonomous from China
Geopolitics
Pompeo Says US No Longer Considers Hong Kong Autonomous from China
May 27, 2020
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON - Secretary of State Mike Pompeo announced Wednesday that he's informed Congress the State Department no longer considers Hong Kong to have significant autonomy under Chinese rule, a move seen as foreshadowing the end of some or all of the U.S. government's special trade and... Read More

Department of Transportation Relaxes Rest Stop Rules For Truck Drivers
Transportation
Department of Transportation Relaxes Rest Stop Rules For Truck Drivers
May 18, 2020
by Gaspard Le Dem

WASHINGTON - The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration announced on Thursday that it had finalized new rules to give truckers more flexibility on their driving hours. The announcement comes after two years of intense public debate over how to give truckers more leeway on required rest... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top