US Border Authorities See Spike in Unaccompanied Minors From Mexico

January 21, 2020by Wendy Fry, The San Diego Union-Tribune (TNS)
On Thursday January 9, 2020 at YMCA Homes for the Migrant Youth in Tijuana, Mexico, two boys relax on their bunk beds as they look over various social medias sites on their smart phones. The two boys are among the small group of unaccompanied youths staying at the shelter hoping to cross north into the United States.

TIJUANA, Mexico — It’s 10 a.m., but it’s still pretty early for a group of teenage boys who are just waking up inside a migrant shelter for unaccompanied children along a busy highway in Tijuana.

At Casa YMCA de Menores Migrantes, the three Mexican teenage boys — aged 15, 16 and 17 — check their phones as they slowly sit up and stretch their feet out over the edge of their bunk beds.

“About 80% of the kids we receive here are Mexicans, girls and boys and adolescents, between the ages of 12 and 17 who are deported from the United States and they arrive every morning,” said Valeria Ruiz, the new director of Casa YMCA, the only shelter in Tijuana for under-aged migrants.

Like thousands of other children in recent years, they’ve traveled to the border from south Mexico without their parents, and they were caught trying to cross into the United States.

Typically, U.S. immigration authorities process unaccompanied Mexican minors and release them to Mexican authorities. Then, the kids wait in one of the most dangerous cities in the world to be reunited with their families.

It’s a growing trend that has human rights advocates and child welfare workers in Tijuana alarmed.

In the San Diego Sector, across the border from Tijuana, there has been a 40% increase in the number of unaccompanied Mexican children trying to cross the border alone and undetected, during the first quarter of this fiscal year compared to the previous quarter, according to the U.S. Border Patrol.

Unlike unaccompanied minors in the Migrant Protection Protocols program, U.S. border authorities are able to deport these kids back to Mexico because they are not making an asylum claim, according to Supervisory Border Patrol Agent Jeffery Stephenson.

Mexican migrant children who do make an asylum claim often end up detained for many months in U.S. facilities.

Stephenson said border agents routinely work with the Mexican Consulate, Mexican immigration authorities, and the DIF, the Sistema de Desarrollo Integral de la Familia, Mexico’s child welfare agency, to turn unaccompanied children back over to Mexican authorities, who are responsible for reuniting them with their families.

The process has been the same for years, he said.

Some boys at Casa YMCA confirmed last week they were not trying to flee violence or political persecution in their home states of Oaxaca and Guerrero. Most said they were trying to find a job in the United States to support their families back home.

“I tried to cross, but they got me,” said Isaias, referring to Border Patrol. He asked the San Diego Union-Tribune not to use his last name.

At 17, he’s the oldest of the group, and he said he’ll never try to make the journey north again.

“I just came to work. But it was very cold and very hard and actually we saw some very ugly things while trying to cross the border, and for nothing,” he said, shyly. He declined to elaborate.

Ruiz said helping teenagers who have been through traumatic events during their journey north or back home is some of the most challenging work she faces.

“They are teenagers fleeing violence, fleeing poverty, fleeing from a lack of opportunities in their home communities. So, when they arrive at the YMCA, they have often gone through a very long and complicated process, and they’ve often been through human rights violations,” she said.

“It usually is a bit complicated to talk to them at the beginning. They are not afraid; they are uncertain. And they want to be with their families,” said Ruiz. “We have to work with them and support them so they feel this house is a safe space.”

Most of the boys in Casa YMCA have only been in Tijuana for a few days, and soon, they will be reunited with their families in south Mexico — Oaxaca and Guerrero, she said.

But many other adolescents in the border region take great care to avoid detection by U.S. or Mexican authorities, so they won’t be sent back home.

“Unlike adult (migrants), teenagers travel in a very invisible way through the country and the city,” said Ruiz.

“They stay on unusual (migratory) routes and they stay at shelters that are not official. Sometimes, they try to pass themselves off as adults in the different shelters,” she said.

Ruiz said because the minors try to hide throughout the city, there’s really no way to know exactly how many migrant children are roaming the streets of Tijuana alone.

“Unfortunately, the only definite number we have is the number of deported minors, because that is a record kept by both countries,” she said. “We will never know how many there really are in the city.”

Both the United States and Mexico say the numbers of minors trying to cross into the United States and getting deported back into Mexico is steadily increasing, although it has not reached the high numbers seen in 2005, when nearly 5,000 Mexican minors were deported back.

According to Mexico Consul General Carlos González Gutiérrez, a total of 1,573 unaccompanied Mexican minors were returned to Mexico or “repatriated to the national territory” in 2019, through Baja California ports of entry. He said the figure represents a 19% increase compared to 2018 and an 84% increase compared with 2017.

In 2019, Border Patrol agents in the San Diego area caught 993 unaccompanied Mexican minors trying to cross the border in this specific region.

Human rights advocates in Tijuana said more kids are trying to cross the border undetected because of a policy change in Mexico that prevents them from seeking asylum.

In the past, unaccompanied minors were allowed to ask for asylum at U.S. ports of entry, like any other adult, but child advocates say this is no longer the case.

“As part of the agreement that Mexico made with the United States, one of the main changes is that minors cannot apply for asylum as an adult would directly at the border,” said Ruiz. “In the case of adolescents, children who travel alone and show up at the border alone, they are not allowed to make an asylum request,” she said.

She said the children are no longer permitted, and they are often blocked by Mexican immigration authorities, from putting their name on the infamous “list” in Tijuana where migrants wait for their turn to ask for asylum under a U.S. policy known as “metering.” The policy allows for only a certain number of asylum seekers to be processed each day.

“They are first stopped by the Mexican authorities … and they are detained and brought here or sent home,” said Ruiz.

She said Mexican authorities explain the policy change as an effort aimed at protecting minors and keeping them from being victims of human trafficking.

Nicole Ramos, is the project director for the Border Rights Project at Al Otro Lado, a binational legal services organization for migrants.

Ramos said preventing unaccompanied kids from seeking asylum is illegal.

“Under the Trafficking Victim Protection Act and the Convention on the Rights of the Child, an unaccompanied minor has the right to present themselves directly to U.S. immigration authorities,” Ramos said. “The idea that Mexican and U.S. officials are collaborating to prevent human trafficking is not credible in the slightest. If that were actually true, U.S. immigration officials would not turn unaccompanied minors away from the port of entry in violation of U.S. and international law and back to the streets of Tijuana, one of the most dangerous cities in the world, and the site for epic levels of human trafficking, particularly the sexual exploitation of children.”


©2020 The San Diego Union-Tribune

Visit The San Diego Union-Tribune at

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.


Appeals Court Says White House Can Withhold Funds for Immigrant-Friendly Policies
Political News
Appeals Court Says White House Can Withhold Funds for Immigrant-Friendly Policies

NEW YORK — The Trump administration can withhold millions in crime-fighting grants from states to force cooperation with immigration enforcement, the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Tuesday. The decision reversed a lower court decision on the money named for New York police officer Edward Byrne,... Read More

How a Nonprofit Lender Is Helping to Make Immigration More Affordable
How a Nonprofit Lender Is Helping to Make Immigration More Affordable

MIAMI — For Vantanna Tarver — a 37-year-old Tampa resident — the cost of reuniting with her Jamaican boyfriend after he was taken into Immigration and Customs Enforcement custody was high. $4,000. That’s the bond amount Tarver had to come up with to get her boyfriend... Read More

Green Card Gridlock: When Will Congress Agree on a Solution?
Green Card Gridlock: When Will Congress Agree on a Solution?

WASHINGTON — On Dec. 18, immigration reform stalwart Richard J. Durbin’s announcement on the Senate floor about a rare bipartisan breakthrough flew largely under the radar, overshadowed in the chaotic flurry of impeachment. Durbin, an Illinois Democrat, and Republican Sen. Mike Lee of Utah had dueled... Read More

Trump Expands ‘Travel Ban’ to Six More Countries, But True Impact Unclear
In The News
Trump Expands ‘Travel Ban’ to Six More Countries, But True Impact Unclear

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump marked the roughly third-year anniversary of his controversial “travel ban” on Friday by adding six African, Central and East Asian countries to the list of those whose nationals face restrictions on travel to the United States. The Homeland Security and State... Read More

How a Single Policy Transformed the US Asylum System
How a Single Policy Transformed the US Asylum System

SAN DIEGO — Over the last year, the Trump administration has dramatically changed the way the U.S. asylum system processes many of the people coming to the southwest border to seek protection. The administration has heralded those changes as a victory for border security, touting reduced... Read More

Divided Supreme Court Allows White House to Enforce Green Card Rule
Divided Supreme Court Allows White House to Enforce Green Card Rule
January 27, 2020
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON - The Supreme Court split along ideological lines Monday in a decision allowing the White House to proceed with a rule making it harder for immigrants who rely on public assistance to gain legal status. The unsigned order lifts a nationwide injunction imposed by the... Read More

Straight From The Well
scroll top