U.S. Foreign Aid Should be Redirected to Risk-Taking Companies

September 4, 2018 by Rachel Marsden
Foreign aid to Pakistan was rescinded ahead of Secretary Pompeo’s meeting with the prime minister, and Rachel Marsden believes that money should be redirected.

PARIS — The Pentagon cancelled $300 million worth of military aid to Pakistan, just as Secretary of State, Mike Pompeo, was preparing to travel to Islamabad to meet with Prime Minister Imran Khan. The move is no doubt a negotiating tactic to get Pakistan to stop diversifying its weapons purchases to from the U.S. in favor of China and Russia, and to help reel in the Taliban in Afghanistan.

The Taliban is to Pakistan what Hezbollah is to Iran. The Trump administration’s move is likely supposed to pressure Pakistan to put these proxies in Afghanistan on a tighter leash. This is well and good for a short-term strategy to pressure the Taliban into a less belligerent role in Afghanistan. However, the concept of foreign aid — military or otherwise — needs to be completely rethought in the interests of long-term stability and economic prosperity.

What kind of return have American taxpayers obtained on foreign aid? How long has America thrown good money after bad with little concern for economic return on investment? The more the country needs aid, the more likely that it’s run by people with their hands in the till. So it shouldn’t come as any surprise that America isn’t getting any bang for its buck. There’s something fundamentally wrong with a funding model that props up corrupt systems, as U.S. foreign aid has long done.

Whether this financial assistance is issued in the interests of civil society building, military support, stabilization or counter-terrorism, the underlying problem remains: an absence of long term economic and political stability. Conventional wisdom has long held that a country has to first be stable before its economy can thrive. This kind of thinking results in endless U.S. funding for military training and advisers, with pitiful results, as we’ve long seen in both the Middle East and Africa.

How many times has America flunked the transition from conflict to stability, or managed to get to the point where such a transition would even be possible? Without stability, there can be no long-term economic prosperity, except maybe for those who profit from military hardware sales.

The free market represents the best hope to ending endless conflict. It’s just a matter of tackling the problem from the correct angle. That angle should be a more directly economic one and less directly military. If you want to loosen the iron grip of fascist power, then you need to reduce people’s reliance on it through local jobs. Instead of going through war and hoping to eventually get around to building companies, how about starting with the companies?

The problem is that foreign companies aren’t going to move into hot spots when there’s an existential risk of getting blown up. If the U.S. and other governments are willing to provide foreign aid funding for NGOs and endless defense activities, which have resulted in very little progress, then why not reserve it for companies bold enough to venture into these areas with the sole purpose of creating local opportunities?

These companies might want to use these funds to protect their assets and interests with private security, develop or protect their supply chain, or tackle any number of risks and prohibitive costs associated with operating in an unstable environment. Without such support, America has been increasingly losing ground to China.

While America funnels its foreign aid into black holes with little return to show for its investments, China is forging into these hot spots with a much different mentality. Do you think that China, unlike the U.S., is giving its money away to NGOs so they can run around showing people in Africa how to make bead necklaces and pottery?

Historically, China doesn’t have a policy of foreign military intervention. They sure do have one of corporate foreign intervention, though. They plunge head-first into these markets and build the infrastructure to support their objectives, notably those involving the extraction of natural resources.

America can — and should — do better than the Chinese model. The idea should be to build up these markets and their citizens — not to pillage and plunder while the locals work for a pittance. When China talks about “win-win,” it usually refers to the oligarchs involved on both sides of the transaction.

U.S. President Donald Trump has recently slapped trade sanctions on China, which has gotten rich as a result of being the developed world’s sweatshop. China, in turn, is now increasingly outsourcing that role to Africa. Earlier this year, Bloomberg reported: “China Is Turning Ethiopia Into a Giant Fast-Fashion Factory.”

Is America really going to let China corner these frontier markets with its perverted form of capitalism? The most effective use of the foreign aid welfare program is in exporting and facilitating the global expansion of capitalism.

© 2018 Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

  • TCA
  • Opinions

    Lawsuit Alleges That Williams CEO Secretly Undermined Billion Dollar Deal
    Opinions
    Lawsuit Alleges That Williams CEO Secretly Undermined Billion Dollar Deal
    March 27, 2020
    by Samantha Hafermann

    An unusual case of corporate intrigue in the energy industry is winding its way through the legal system with potentially far-reaching consequences for policing corporate governance and the bounds of mergers and acquisitions, particularly the rules of the game when a party wants out of a... Read More

    How the Trump Administration Can Keep the Aviation Industry Alive and Save Millions of Jobs
    Opinions
    How the Trump Administration Can Keep the Aviation Industry Alive and Save Millions of Jobs
    March 23, 2020
    by Captain Lee Moak

    As a labor leader with more than two decades of experience in the turbulent airline industry, I urge our government leaders to move with speed to provide immediate grants to keep this vital national industry alive.  The U.S. government has a de facto ban on flying... Read More

    In Light of Coronavirus Outbreak, Veterans Need Assurance That the VA Is Prepared
    Opinions
    In Light of Coronavirus Outbreak, Veterans Need Assurance That the VA Is Prepared
    March 16, 2020
    by Jeremy Butler

    Fear and concern regarding the novel coronavirus continues to grow daily with an alarming number of new patients diagnosed around the world every day. Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America (IAVA) is the leading post-9/11 veterans services organization, and as such, we are particularly concerned about... Read More

    How the Novel Coronavirus Could Drive Policy Solutions in Long-Suffering Venezuela
    Opinions
    How the Novel Coronavirus Could Drive Policy Solutions in Long-Suffering Venezuela
    March 6, 2020
    by Craig Singleton

    As economists work to assess the full-extent of the coronavirus’ effect on both the U.S. economy and global markets, there are already serious indications that the oil and gas sector will be severely impacted for the first half of 2020, if not the entire year. In... Read More

    Why Security Should Be Your Next Social Good Investment
    Opinions
    Why Security Should Be Your Next Social Good Investment
    February 26, 2020
    by Kaylin Trychon

    In his annual letter on corporate governance, BlackRock CEO Larry Fink doubled down on the concept that companies cannot achieve long-term profits without embracing purpose and focusing on sustainability. In the letter, Fink states that brands must have a better understanding of how they are managing sustainability-related issues... Read More

    How Did Air Medical Impact My Life? It Gave Me One
    Opinions
    How Did Air Medical Impact My Life? It Gave Me One

    As a nurse, and someone whose life was saved by emergency air medical transport, I can tell you that having access and continuity of care is critically important to health outcomes. Air ambulances allow you to access specialty care when minutes and seconds count. Without medical... Read More

    Straight From The Well
    scroll top