Trump Tries Another Immigration Reset Ahead of 2020

May 17, 2019by Noah Bierman and Molly O’Toole

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump deployed all the trappings of a Rose Garden ceremony to pitch an incomplete and almost certainly doomed immigration plan Thursday, pushing forward even as his efforts to make progress on his other big 2020 campaign issue — trade — faced new obstacles.

A military string band played, and rows of chairs were arranged for White House staff and conservative senators.

“Today we are presenting a clear contrast with Democrats, who are proposing open borders, lower wages and frankly, lawless chaos,” said Trump, who began reading off a teleprompter but predictably veered off script at times during the 25-minute speech. “We are proposing an immigration plan that puts the jobs, wages and safety of American workers first.”

The plan focuses on border infrastructure — additional barriers, checkpoints and other enforcement tools. It also would shift the legal immigration system away from the preference for people who have family in the United States to one based on what the administration defines as “merit” — specific job skills, advanced degrees or the money to start a new company.

Trump has been unable to make a deal on immigration, his top campaign issue, despite sporadic overtures from Democratic lawmakers and, for his two first years, Republican control of Congress. His trade agenda ran into one of its biggest hurdles to date over the past week when negotiations on a pact with China devolved into a trade war that threatens to slow the roaring economy.

Despite those setbacks, Trump has been eager to use the stature of the Rose Garden to convince supporters that he is winning, and keeping his promises, even when those victory parties have been premature. At the beginning of his term, for example, Trump notably invited congressional leaders and a military band to celebrate the House’s vote to repeal President Barack Obama’s health care law, only to see the effort crumble weeks later in the Senate. In February, he dramatically signed an official emergency declaration in an attempt to bypass Congress to fund a wall along the southern border, but no new miles of border fencing have been completed.

Thursday’s event was intended to bolster Trump’s arguments that Congress’ attempts to work with him on immigration have been insincere at best and, at worst, aimed at resisting his efforts to fix a system that he has cast as a threat to national security and economic prosperity.

Democrats and some Republicans have said Trump is the stubborn one, refusing a compromise offer last year that would have allotted $25 billion for the wall because hard-line allies opposed the other part of the deal — a path to citizenship for so-called Dreamers, people who came to the country illegally as children, as well as their extended families.

The president explicitly acknowledged Thursday that his latest plan lacked the Democratic support it would need to get through Congress and was in part a plug for his reelection in 2020.

“If for some reason, possibly political, we can’t get the Democrats to approve this merit-based, high-security plan, then we will get it approved immediately after the election, when we take back the House and keep the Senate, and of course, hold the presidency,” Trump said in closing his speech, opening his arms to a standing ovation.

Trump’s advisers say the new plan crafted by his son-in-law and adviser, Jared Kushner, is meant to rally Republicans around a single message and to reflect Trump’s values.

“The president is a deal maker, and so I’m sure he understands that at this stage he’s putting out some areas he thinks are important, then he and those of us who support those ideas are going to have to go out and get some Democrats to sign on,” Sen. Mitt Romney, R-Utah, an occasional Trump critic and one-time GOP presidential nominee, told reporters Thursday.

Yet even Republican allies have complained in recent days that the new plan falls short of addressing the systematic problems with the existing system.

Trump emphasized what he termed a “Build America” visa, a nod to his “America First” slogan. Yet the plan does not address the Dreamers, or the rest of the estimated 10.7 million people illegally in the United States.

Neither does the plan immediately tackle a recent surge in Central American families and unaccompanied children arriving at the border in near-record numbers. Administration officials said the plan would close loopholes in asylum law that they argue are pulling migrants to the border, but neither the White House nor the president in his announcement offered specifics. Immigration authorities say the spike has brought the immigration system to the “breaking point.”

On Tuesday night, a 2-year-old Guatemalan boy apprehended at the border died in El Paso after weeks in the hospital, the fourth known child death after detention by U.S. authorities since December.

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, the San Francisco Democrat, emphasized the dearth of Democrats who were consulted by Kushner, telling reporters that “we would always welcome” a briefing on the details. She insisted Democrats also want “comprehensive immigration reform” while criticizing Kushner’s use of the term “merit” to describe preferences for people with job offers or educational degrees who would be favored under Trump’s proposed changes.

“It is really a condescending word,” she said. “Is family without merit? Certainly, we want to attract the best to our country and that includes many people from many parts of society.”


Staff writer Jennifer Haberkorn contributed to this report.


©2019 Los Angeles Times

Visit the Los Angeles Times at

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.


New Dems Endorse Proposed Standards For Border Detainees Immigration
New Dems Endorse Proposed Standards For Border Detainees
July 19, 2019
by Elin Johnson

WASHINGTON - The New Democrat Coalition has endorsed a proposal by Representative Raul Ruiz, D-Calif., to establish enhanced standards of care for people detained at the U.S. border by Customs and Border Patrol. Ruiz’s bill, the Humanitarian Standards for Individuals in Customs and Border Protection Custody... Read More

Washington Legal Advocates, Lawmakers Want Immigration Procedures Changed Immigration
Washington Legal Advocates, Lawmakers Want Immigration Procedures Changed
July 16, 2019
by Tom Ramstack

WASHINGTON -- Some of Washington’s prominent legal organizations and lawmakers are scrambling to address the nation’s illegal immigration crisis while courts confront a hopeless backlog of cases. They are proposing new procedures to manage the flood of illegal immigrants being held in detention centers while seeking... Read More

White House Moves to Eliminate Nearly All Asylum Claims at US Southern Border Immigration
White House Moves to Eliminate Nearly All Asylum Claims at US Southern Border

WASHINGTON — The Trump administration moved Monday to in effect end asylum for the vast majority of migrants who arrive at the U.S.-Mexico border, an enormous shift in policy that could block hundreds of thousands of people from seeking protection in the U.S. — and is... Read More

Despite Weeks of Threats, ICE Raids Begin With a Whimper Yet Still Stoke Fears Immigration
Despite Weeks of Threats, ICE Raids Begin With a Whimper Yet Still Stoke Fears

LOS ANGELES — The raids — hyped for weeks by President Donald Trump — were to take place in major U.S. cities including Los Angeles, San Francisco, New York, Chicago, Miami, Denver, Atlanta, Baltimore and Houston. As of Sunday evening, there were no reports of arrests... Read More

Death at the Border: 4 from Guatemala, 3 of Them Children, Succumb to Heat in Texas Immigration
Death at the Border: 4 from Guatemala, 3 of Them Children, Succumb to Heat in Texas

LA BLANCA, Guatemala — Her sister had made the trek last year, following a familiar script: Cross into U.S. territory from Mexico with a minor child, surrender to the Border Patrol, and apply for political asylum — then get released and launch a new life in... Read More

White House Hopefuls Flay Trump On Immigration at LULAC Event 2020 Elections
White House Hopefuls Flay Trump On Immigration at LULAC Event
July 12, 2019
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON - A quartet of Democratic presidential candidates on Thursday vowed to make significant changes to the nation's immigration laws if elected, contrasting their approaches with the hard line policies pursued by President Donald Trump the past two-and-a-half years. The candidates, all of them skewing to... Read More

Straight From The Well
scroll top