AT&T Hauls FCC Into Court Over Trump-Era Wi-Fi Expansion
WASHINGTON – Lawyers for AT&T and a host of utility providers and public safety officials squared off against the FCC in a District of Columbia courtroom on Friday in a battle over a Trump-era regulatory change that expanded the use of Wi-Fi on the 6GHz spectrum band.
At issue in the AT&T led lawsuit is whether the traditional users of the 6GHz band are having their operations affected by new Wi-Fi users entering the spectrum.
They are particularly concerned about the proliferation of Wi-FI 6, the next generation of home wireless service, the appeal of which is its ability to handle large amounts of data.
In April 2020, the Federal Communications commission adopted a set of new rules expanding unlicensed operations in the 6GHz band, ushering in the Wi-Fi 6 era.
Then-FCC Chair Ajit Pai was a particularly gung ho proponent of the move, believing the new spectrum policy would spur the growth of the Internet of Things for connecting appliances, machines, meters, wearables, smart televisions, and industrial sensors for manufacturing.
The following December, after the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit denied a request for a stay on the FCC decision, the commission authorized the first Wi-Fi device for use in the spectrum.
Wireless carriers like AT&T and Verizon use the band for backhaul — basically, to connect a cell site with a core network — while others use it to monitor the electric grid and other critical communications.
They and the Association of Public Safety Communications Officials-International, utilities and others say there aren’t enough protections for incumbents as the band is opened to new unlicensed users.
Though the appellate court denied the request for an emergency stay, it has continued to hear arguments challenging the FCC’s decision.
In its most recent filing in the case, AT&T argues Wi-Fi users in the 6GHz band are “very likely to result in harmful interference at unpredictable places and times.”
Tech and campus companies like Comcast, Charter Communications and Facebook support the opening up of the 6GHz band, seeing it as freeing up unused airwaves and improving customer experience for their products.
Speaking shortly after the FCC’s unanimous vote in 2020, Tony Werner, president of TPX, technology, product, Xperience at Comcast Cable, said the decision “would quickly benefit consumers who are using wi-fi now more than ever to work and learn from home, to watch shows and to videoconference and to shop and get their news.
“The order making 1200 megahertz of unlicensed spectrum available in the 6GHz band will dramatically improve Wi-Fi performance and capacity, and will protect existing users of the spectrum. It is a significant step on the path to deploying next generation, gigabit Wi-Fi services to complement our world class gigabit broadband networks,” Werner said.
Also noteworthy is the fact that lawyers for the Biden administration and acting FCC chair, Jessica Rosenworcel, have defended that Trump-era FCC order.
“The FCC’s reasoned decision in this case, based on ample evidence in the record, provides more than enough justification for its actions,” the agency argued in a recent court filing.
In fact, the FCC is scheduled to vote on new rules later this month that would implement an automated frequency coordination system in the 6GHz band. The AFC system is specifically intended to prevent interference to incumbent operations.
The D.C. Circuit judges are David Tatel, a Clinton appointee, Patricia Millett, an Obama appointee, and Justin Walker, a Trump appointee.
In The News
BOSTON (AP) — The U.S. wireless carrier T-Mobile said Thursday that an unidentified malicious intruder breached its network in late... Read More
BOSTON (AP) — The U.S. wireless carrier T-Mobile said Thursday that an unidentified malicious intruder breached its network in late November and stole data on 37 million customers, including addresses, phone numbers and dates of birth. T-Mobile said in a filing with the U.S. Securities and... Read More
A couple of years into the pandemic, Shirley Neville had finally had enough of her shoddy internet service. “It was... Read More
A couple of years into the pandemic, Shirley Neville had finally had enough of her shoddy internet service. “It was just a headache,” said Neville, who lives in a middle-class neighborhood in New Orleans whose residents are almost all Black or Latino. “When I was getting... Read More
WASHINGTON — Seven voice service providers face removal from a key database managed by the Federal Trade Commission if they... Read More
WASHINGTON — Seven voice service providers face removal from a key database managed by the Federal Trade Commission if they fail to demonstrate they’re taking concrete steps to comply with the agency’s anti-robocall rules. The first-of-their-kind FCC Enforcement Bureau orders give the companies until Oct. 18... Read More
BUCHAREST, Romania — An American was chosen to be the first woman to lead the United Nations’ telecommunications agency, the... Read More
BUCHAREST, Romania — An American was chosen to be the first woman to lead the United Nations’ telecommunications agency, the International Telecommunication Union, in its 157-year history after an overwhelming vote Thursday in Romania. Doreen Bogdan-Martin, the new secretary general of the agency, received 139 votes... Read More
WASHINGTON — The Federal Communications Commission is looking at ways to help deaf incarcerated people connect better with their families... Read More
WASHINGTON — The Federal Communications Commission is looking at ways to help deaf incarcerated people connect better with their families through improved telecommunications services, including video chatting, in prisons and jails throughout the country. “Incarcerated people face considerable barriers to stay in touch with their loved... Read More
WASHINGTON — The Federal Communications Commission formally added Pacific Networks Corp. and its wholly owned subsidiary ComNet and China Unicom... Read More
WASHINGTON — The Federal Communications Commission formally added Pacific Networks Corp. and its wholly owned subsidiary ComNet and China Unicom (Americas) Operations Limited to its list of companies whose telecom equipment and service pose a national security threat. The commission along with national security agencies created... Read More