AT&T Hauls FCC Into Court Over Trump-Era Wi-Fi Expansion
WASHINGTON – Lawyers for AT&T and a host of utility providers and public safety officials squared off against the FCC in a District of Columbia courtroom on Friday in a battle over a Trump-era regulatory change that expanded the use of Wi-Fi on the 6GHz spectrum band.
At issue in the AT&T led lawsuit is whether the traditional users of the 6GHz band are having their operations affected by new Wi-Fi users entering the spectrum.
They are particularly concerned about the proliferation of Wi-FI 6, the next generation of home wireless service, the appeal of which is its ability to handle large amounts of data.
In April 2020, the Federal Communications commission adopted a set of new rules expanding unlicensed operations in the 6GHz band, ushering in the Wi-Fi 6 era.
Then-FCC Chair Ajit Pai was a particularly gung ho proponent of the move, believing the new spectrum policy would spur the growth of the Internet of Things for connecting appliances, machines, meters, wearables, smart televisions, and industrial sensors for manufacturing.
The following December, after the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit denied a request for a stay on the FCC decision, the commission authorized the first Wi-Fi device for use in the spectrum.
Wireless carriers like AT&T and Verizon use the band for backhaul — basically, to connect a cell site with a core network — while others use it to monitor the electric grid and other critical communications.
They and the Association of Public Safety Communications Officials-International, utilities and others say there aren’t enough protections for incumbents as the band is opened to new unlicensed users.
Though the appellate court denied the request for an emergency stay, it has continued to hear arguments challenging the FCC’s decision.
In its most recent filing in the case, AT&T argues Wi-Fi users in the 6GHz band are “very likely to result in harmful interference at unpredictable places and times.”
Tech and campus companies like Comcast, Charter Communications and Facebook support the opening up of the 6GHz band, seeing it as freeing up unused airwaves and improving customer experience for their products.
Speaking shortly after the FCC’s unanimous vote in 2020, Tony Werner, president of TPX, technology, product, Xperience at Comcast Cable, said the decision “would quickly benefit consumers who are using wi-fi now more than ever to work and learn from home, to watch shows and to videoconference and to shop and get their news.
“The order making 1200 megahertz of unlicensed spectrum available in the 6GHz band will dramatically improve Wi-Fi performance and capacity, and will protect existing users of the spectrum. It is a significant step on the path to deploying next generation, gigabit Wi-Fi services to complement our world class gigabit broadband networks,” Werner said.
Also noteworthy is the fact that lawyers for the Biden administration and acting FCC chair, Jessica Rosenworcel, have defended that Trump-era FCC order.
“The FCC’s reasoned decision in this case, based on ample evidence in the record, provides more than enough justification for its actions,” the agency argued in a recent court filing.
In fact, the FCC is scheduled to vote on new rules later this month that would implement an automated frequency coordination system in the 6GHz band. The AFC system is specifically intended to prevent interference to incumbent operations.
The D.C. Circuit judges are David Tatel, a Clinton appointee, Patricia Millett, an Obama appointee, and Justin Walker, a Trump appointee.
In The News
WASHINGTON -- The Federal Communications Commission is poised to consider an application from Boeing to launch and run an array... Read More
WASHINGTON -- The Federal Communications Commission is poised to consider an application from Boeing to launch and run an array of broadband satellites. Acting FCC chair Jessica Rosenworcel circulated a proposal for voting on Boeing’s application last week. Industry watchers have said the fact Rosenworcel went... Read More
WASHINGTON -- Both sides of the U.S. Congress are viewing high-speed broadband as essential. Now, the industry players will have... Read More
WASHINGTON -- Both sides of the U.S. Congress are viewing high-speed broadband as essential. Now, the industry players will have the challenge of reconfiguring a private business model to fit that of a utility, said Rhod Shaw, chairman of the Alpine Group, Wednesday. The growing attention... Read More
WASHINGTON -- Disputes in Congress on how much tax money should be invested in infrastructure continued during a hearing Wednesday... Read More
WASHINGTON -- Disputes in Congress on how much tax money should be invested in infrastructure continued during a hearing Wednesday on expanding broadband telecommunications access. Broadband refers to data transmission over a wide range of frequencies through optical fiber, wireless radio and satellite signals. It is... Read More
Amazon Web Services’ quantum computing service, Amazon Braket, is partnering with next-generation digital services consulting firm Infosys to develop quantum... Read More
Amazon Web Services’ quantum computing service, Amazon Braket, is partnering with next-generation digital services consulting firm Infosys to develop quantum computing capabilities for its Infosys Cobalt cloud offerings. Amazon Braket provides the technology and research for scientists and developers to build quantum algorithms, test them on... Read More
The deployment of artificial intelligence is of top priority for Communication Service Providers to monitor their networks and drive down... Read More
The deployment of artificial intelligence is of top priority for Communication Service Providers to monitor their networks and drive down operational costs, according to an independent study released by Anodot Thursday. The global study, commissioned by the business monitoring company, found as much as 67% of... Read More
As the wireless industry works to get 5G deployed across the nation, the U.S. Department of Commerce has been working... Read More
As the wireless industry works to get 5G deployed across the nation, the U.S. Department of Commerce has been working hand-in-hand with the Federal Communications Commission to make sure there is enough spectrum to do it, said Secretary of Commerce Gina Raimondo Tuesday. There are still... Read More