Advocates Call for National Privacy Policy at FTC Open Meeting

October 22, 2021 by Victoria Turner
Advocates Call for National Privacy Policy at FTC Open Meeting

The Federal Trade Commission should work with the U.S. Congress on drafting a comprehensive federal privacy law, instead of using its rulemaking authority to do industry-specific regulation, according to three privacy policy advocates from three separate think tanks on Thursday at the FTC’s open meeting.

“Rather than craft an ISP-specific privacy regulation, Congress should pass a national privacy law that preempts states and sets baseline standards for the whole economy,” said Aurelien Portuese, director of The Schumpeter Project on competition policy at the Information Technology & Innovation Foundation.

Portuese’s comments followed the FTC staff presentation of a report on the privacy practices used by six major internet service providers – AT&T, Verizon Wireless, Charter Communications, Comcast, T-Mobile and Google Fiber –  and three of their advertising affiliates regarding data collection and use practices. The six ISPs combined comprise 98.8% of the U.S. mobile internet market. 

“The expansion of ISPs into vertically integrated entities that not only provide internet, voice and cable services, but also produce the content transmitted across these pipes and sell behavioral advertising, has enabled these firms to consolidate and aggregate a staggering array of data,” said FTC Chair Lina Kahn.

If anything, Kahn said, the report reveals a need to keep an eye on mergers that would lead to the “degradation of user privacy.”

Khan added that the report further unveiled problems with the notice and consent framework for privacy and noted concern for how the “individualized and hyper-granular dossiers” these ISPs have gathered on their users could lead to discriminatory practices. To these means, she sounded support for reasserting the FTC’s authority to oversee ISPs and “put in place nondiscrimination rules, privacy protections and other basic requirements needed to create healthier markets.”

ISPs tend to provide one core service – internet, voice and video – to the consumer, Khan said. They also provide Internet of Things services like home security or connected wearables or content like video or website content, or advertising as an ad platform or providing advertising analytics. The report found that some of the ISPs combine the data they have across products, said Andre Arias, an FTC attorney.

Many ISPs, Arias claimed, “can be at least as privacy intrusive as advertising platforms.” 

Several ISPs in the study “pool and cross-reference” sensitive and detailed data about subscribers and their households, gathering it sometimes through unexpected ways like web browsing history or email contents, that can then be used in harmful ways by property managers, bail bondsmen or bounty hunters. The privacy choices that the ISPs give their customer are also “often illusory…[nudging] consumers towards great sharing of personal data through a variety of dark patterns.” Even when the customer blocks the tracking through device or browser settings, she said the ISPs still use their “supercookie technology to defeat those tools.” 

The current “patchwork process” in data collection and privacy regulation further confuses consumers and reduces their ability to protect their privacy online, said Shane Tews, non-resident senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. 

And there is no need nor benefit for a sector-based solution to privacy laws, Portuese said, warning the chilling effect that unilaterally enforcing sector-specific privacy standards will have on competition. 

“A federal policy framework would avoid the current fragmentation of guidance and encourage more secure digital innovation,” Tews said, applying a “holistic approach to privacy protections and…the same safeguards” to all companies collecting and using data in the space. 

This “fact-finding” study undertaken by the FTC into the industry, which was initiated in 2019, was and will continue being imperative,” said John Verdi, senior vice president of policy at the Future of Privacy Forum, and the FTC could garner more authority to investigate and enforce consumer protections by working with Congress on this bipartisan issue. 

The foundation for this federal privacy law can be found through coupling a 2012 FTC privacy report with an Obama-era Consumer Privacy Bill of Rights, said Nancy Libin, partner at Davis Wright Tremaine. A former chief privacy and civil liberties officer at the Justice Department, Libin said the 2012 bill laid down the framework that distinguishes sensitive and nonsensitive data. The companies, however, would not need to request consumer consent for first-party marketing as it is inferred by the mere nature of the company-consumer relationship, she explained. The 2012 framework directs companies to provide consumers with the option to opt-out absent of this inferred consent and to request an opt-in when the company engages in deliberate data collection and use. 

A+
a-
  • AT&T Verizon
  • Charter Communications
  • Comcast
  • Federal Trade Commission
  • Googles Fiber
  • privacy
  • T-Mobile
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Telecom

    March 21, 2024
    by Dan McCue
    DOJ, 16 States Sue Apple Over Alleged Smartphone Monopoly

    WASHINGTON — The Justice Department and 16 state attorneys general sued Apple on Thursday accusing the Cupertino, California-based tech giant... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Justice Department and 16 state attorneys general sued Apple on Thursday accusing the Cupertino, California-based tech giant of operating an illegal monopoly in the smartphone market. According to the lawsuit, which was filed in federal court in New Jersey, Apple has used the... Read More

    House Passes Bill That Would Lead to TikTok Ban if Chinese Owner Doesn't Sell. Senate Path Unclear

    WASHINGTON (AP) — The House on Wednesday passed a bill that would lead to a nationwide ban of the popular video app... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — The House on Wednesday passed a bill that would lead to a nationwide ban of the popular video app TikTok if its China-based owner doesn't sell, as lawmakers acted on concerns that the company's current ownership structure is a national security threat. The bill, passed by... Read More

    Fake Images Made to Show Trump With Black Supporters Highlight Concerns Around AI and Elections

    WASHINGTON (AP) — At first glance, images circulating online showing former President Donald Trump surrounded by groups of Black people... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — At first glance, images circulating online showing former President Donald Trump surrounded by groups of Black people smiling and laughing seem nothing out of the ordinary, but a look closer is telling. Odd lighting and too-perfect details provide clues to the fact they... Read More

    Americans Reporting Nationwide Cellular Outages From AT&T, Cricket Wireless and Others

    A number of Americans are dealing with cellular outages on AT&T, Cricket Wireless, Verizon, T-Mobile and other service providers, according... Read More

    A number of Americans are dealing with cellular outages on AT&T, Cricket Wireless, Verizon, T-Mobile and other service providers, according to data from Downdetector. AT&T had more than 73,000 outages around 9:30 a.m. ET, in locations including Houston, Atlanta and Chicago. The outages began at approximately... Read More

    Google Ups Stakes in AI Race With Gemini, Technology Trained to Act More Like Humans

    Google took its next leap in artificial intelligence Wednesday with the launch of project Gemini, an AI model trained to behave in... Read More

    Google took its next leap in artificial intelligence Wednesday with the launch of project Gemini, an AI model trained to behave in human-like ways that's likely to intensify the debate about the technology’s potential promise and perils. The rollout will unfold in phases, with less sophisticated versions of... Read More

    Broadcom Planning to Complete Deal for $69B Acquisition of VMWare After Regulators Give OK

    SAN JOSE, California (AP) — Computer chip and software maker Broadcom has announced it has cleared all regulatory hurdles and... Read More

    SAN JOSE, California (AP) — Computer chip and software maker Broadcom has announced it has cleared all regulatory hurdles and plans to complete its $69 billion acquisition of cloud technology company VMware on Wednesday. The company, based in San Jose, California, announced it planned to move... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top