Supreme Court Rules in Favor of Florida Medicaid in Settlement Dispute

June 6, 2022 by Dan McCue
Supreme Court Rules in Favor of Florida Medicaid in Settlement Dispute
The U.S. Supreme Court. (Photo by Dan McCue)

WASHINGTON — The U.S. Supreme Court ruled 7-2 on Monday in favor of Florida’s Medicaid program in a dispute over how much money the state can take from an accident victim’s private settlement to recover the costs of their care.

Gianinna Gallardo was just 13 when she was struck by a truck shortly after she stepped off her Florida school bus.

Florida’s Medicaid agency paid $862,688.77 to cover Gallardo’s initial medical expenses, and the agency continues to pay her medical expenses. 

While this was going on, Gallardo, through her parents, sued the truck’s owner and driver, as well as the Lee County School Board.

According to the Supreme Court’s summary of the case, Gallardo sought compensation for past medical expenses, future medical expenses, lost earnings, and other damages. That litigation resulted in a settlement for $800,000, with $35,367.52 expressly designated as compensation for past medical expenses

The settlement did not specifically allocate any amount for future medical expenses.

The Medicaid Act requires participating states to pay for certain needy individuals’ medical costs and then to make reasonable efforts to recoup those costs from liable third parties. 

Under Florida’s Medicaid Third-Party Liability Act, the court said, “a beneficiary like Gallardo who ‘’accept[s] medical assistance’ from Medicaid ‘automatically assigns to the [state] agency any right’ to third-party payments for medical care.” 

Applied to Gallardo’s settlement, Florida’s statutory framework entitled the state to $300,000— 37.5% of $800,000, the percentage the statute sets as presumptively representing the portion of the settlement compensating for future medical expenses. 

On review, the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals held the relevant Medicaid Act provisions do not prevent a state from seeking reimbursement from settlement monies allocated for future medical care. 

Gallardo argued that the Medicaid Act’s anti-lien provision — which prohibits states from recovering medical payments from a beneficiary’s ‘property,’ forecloses recovery from settlement amounts other than those allocated for past medical care paid for by Medicaid. 

But in a ruling written by Justice Clarence Thomas, the court majority held that the provision does not apply to state laws “expressly authorized by the terms of… the Medicaid Act.” 

In a dissent, Justice Sonia Sotomayor said “the court’s atomizing interpretation has little to commend it, particularly when contrasted with the consistent, administrable scheme Congress crafted. 

“The court’s reading also undercuts Congress’ choice to allow Medicaid beneficiaries to place their excess recovery funds in Special Needs Trusts, protecting their ability to pay for important expenses Medicaid will not cover.”

In short, she said, the majority’s holding “is inconsistent with the structure of the Medicaid program and will cause needless unfairness and disruption.”

Dan can be reached at [email protected] and at https://twitter.com/DanMcCue.

A+
a-
  • Medicaid
  • Supreme Court
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Supreme Court

    May 15, 2025
    by Dan McCue
    Justices Appear Divided Over Whether to Curb Nationwide Injunctions

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court appeared to be divided along ideological lines Thursday as it considered whether to remove the... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court appeared to be divided along ideological lines Thursday as it considered whether to remove the ability of lower court judges to issue nationwide injunctions. During a highly unusual oral argument this late in the term, the conservative justices seemed to believe... Read More

    May 15, 2025
    by Tom Ramstack
    Supreme Court Says Context of Police Shooting Determines Whether It’s Justified

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court appears to have made it easier for police officers to be sued for excessive use... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court appears to have made it easier for police officers to be sued for excessive use of force with a ruling Thursday that requires courts to consider the "totality of circumstances." The ruling resulted from the 2016 fatal shooting of a Houston,... Read More

    Former Supreme Court Justice David Souter, a Republican Who Became a Liberal Darling, Has Died

    WASHINGTON (AP) — Retired Supreme Court Justice David H. Souter, the ascetic bachelor and New Hampshire Republican who became a... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — Retired Supreme Court Justice David H. Souter, the ascetic bachelor and New Hampshire Republican who became a darling of liberals during his nearly 20 years on the bench, has died. He was 85. Souter died Thursday at his home in New Hampshire, the court said... Read More

    May 6, 2025
    by Dan McCue
    Supreme Court Allows Transgender Ban in Military to Take Effect

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Tuesday said it will allow a Trump administration ban on transgender individuals serving in... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Tuesday said it will allow a Trump administration ban on transgender individuals serving in the military to take effect while legal proceedings on the matter continue. As is their custom when dealing with emergency applications, the justices gave no explanation... Read More

    May 6, 2025
    by Tom Ramstack
    Justice Dept. Urges Supreme Court to Overturn Hawaii Gun Restrictions

    WASHINGTON — The Justice Department and 25 state attorneys general are asking the Supreme Court to take a Hawaii case... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Justice Department and 25 state attorneys general are asking the Supreme Court to take a Hawaii case that could put further restrictions on the right to legally carry a concealed gun. Hawaii passed a law in 2023 saying legal gun owners could not... Read More

    Americans See More Overreach From the President Than From Judges, an AP-NORC Poll Finds

    WASHINGTON (AP) — As President Donald Trump faces significant pushback from federal judges, a new poll shows U.S. adults are more likely... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — As President Donald Trump faces significant pushback from federal judges, a new poll shows U.S. adults are more likely to believe the president is the one overstepping his power rather than the courts -- although Republicans largely think the opposite. According to a poll from The... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top