Justices Side With Two Doctors Snared in Opioid ‘Pill Mill’ Case 

June 27, 2022 by Dan McCue
Justices Side With Two Doctors Snared in Opioid ‘Pill Mill’ Case 
The U.S. Supreme Court building. (Photo by Dan McCue)

WASHINGTON — In a unanimous ruling the Supreme Court said on Monday that prosecutors must prove doctors knowingly misprescribed drugs to secure convictions against them for the unlawful distribution of controlled medicines, like opioids.

The decision came down in a case brought by two doctors, Xiulu Ruan and Shakeel Kahn, who were sentenced to decades in prison for unlawfully prescribing opioids to patients at their medical clinics in Alabama and Arizona.

Both men were convicted under the Controlled Substances Act, which makes it a crime for any person to “knowingly or intentionally” dispense a controlled substance.

Under the law, there is an exception for a licensed health care professional who is allowed to dispense some of the drugs with a prescription, but the prescription must be issued for a legitimate medical purpose.

Between January 2011 and May 2015, Ruan’s clinic, Physicians Pain Specialists, issued nearly 300,000 controlled substance prescriptions netting the practice more than $3 million. 

According to federal prosecutors, more than half of the drugs prescribed were so-called Schedule II drugs — among the most dangerous drugs on the market. 

They include opioids such as fentanyl, hydrocodone, morphine and oxycodone, all of which can be used to treat pain, but are also known to be highly addictive. 

The clinic was raided by the FBI and Ruan was charged with running a “pill mill” that prescribed controlled substances for no legitimate medical purpose. 

Kahn’s arrest came after a three-year investigation by the Board of Pharmacy, where he ran another clinic, after questions were raised about the large amount of painkillers he was prescribing.

State and federal law enforcement eventually took over the investigation, and Kahn and his brother Nabeel were charged with distributing millions of opioids and laundering the proceeds.

Ruan and Kahn’s cases were consolidated for the Supreme Court. 

Ruan was sentenced to 21 years in prison in 2017 after being found guilty of running what the Justice Department called a pill mill, while Shakeel Kahn of Wyoming was sentenced to 25 years in prison in 2019 for crimes including drug distribution resulting in death. 

“Dr. Kahn testified that he would not have issued prescriptions to individuals that he knew to be selling their medication,” his lawyer told the justices during oral arguments on March 1. 

A lawyer for Ruan, meanwhile, argued that the doctors can’t be convicted under the law without regard to whether they “reasonably believed” the prescriptions fell within the usual course of professional practice.

But the U.S. Supreme Court was having none of this argument.

Deputy Solicitor General Eric Feigin told the justices that lawyers for the doctors were “really asking this court to transform their [federal] registrations, which are premised on the idea that they’re actually practicing medicine, into licenses to, at their own subjective views, violate the general rule that drug pushing is illegal.”

“They want to be free of any obligation even to undertake any minimal effort to act like doctors when they prescribe dangerous, highly addictive and, in one case, lethal doses of drugs to trusting and vulnerable patients,” Feigin said.

In essence, the justices were asked to decide what threshold doctors had to cross in handing out prescriptions to go from providing care to drug trafficking.

Ultimately, the justices concluded intent matters for the doling out of prescriptions to be considered criminal.

The court found that in these cases, intent matters for prescribing to be considered criminal. 

“In each of these two consolidated cases, a doctor was convicted under §841 for dispensing controlled substances not ‘as authorized,’” said Justice Stephen Breyer, writing for the court. “The question before us concerns the state of mind that the government must prove to convict these doctors of violating the statute. 

“We hold that the statute’s ‘knowingly or intentionally’ mens rea applies to authorization. After a defendant produces evidence that he or she was authorized to dispense controlled substances, the government must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant knew that he or she was acting in an unauthorized manner, or intended to do so,” he said.

Despite coming to that conclusion, the justices did not throw out the convictions of the two physicians.

Instead, it told appeals courts to review the jury instructions from the original criminal cases to see if they comported with the new ruling and to determine whether any instructional error that was made was harmless.

Dan can be reached at [email protected] and @DanMcCue

A+
a-
  • Controlled Substances Act
  • drug trafficking
  • Opioids
  • Supreme Court
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Supreme Court

    Five Takeaways From the Abortion Pill Case Before US Supreme Court

    WASHINGTON (AP) — U.S. Supreme Court justices on Tuesday did not appear ready to limit access to the abortion pill mifepristone,... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — U.S. Supreme Court justices on Tuesday did not appear ready to limit access to the abortion pill mifepristone, in a case that could have far-reaching implications for millions of American women and for scores of drugs regulated by the Food and Drug Administration. It's... Read More

    March 26, 2024
    by Tom Ramstack
    Supreme Court Skeptical of Ban on Abortion Pill Mifepristone

    WASHINGTON — A hearing Tuesday before the Supreme Court indicated a majority of the justices want to maintain women’s access... Read More

    WASHINGTON — A hearing Tuesday before the Supreme Court indicated a majority of the justices want to maintain women’s access to the abortion pill mifepristone despite objections from anti-abortion activists. The doctors and organizations who sued argued the Food and Drug Administration was wrong in granting... Read More

    March 19, 2024
    by Dan McCue
    Supreme Court Gives Texas Green Light to Deport Illegal Immigrants

    WASHINGTON — A divided Supreme Court on Tuesday allowed Texas to begin enforcing a state law that effectively allows officials... Read More

    WASHINGTON — A divided Supreme Court on Tuesday allowed Texas to begin enforcing a state law that effectively allows officials to deport undocumented immigrants, despite objections from the Biden administration, which argued only the federal government has authority over immigration issues. In an unsigned order, the... Read More

    A Supreme Court Ruling in a Social Media Case Could Set Standards for Free Speech in the Digital Age

    WASHINGTON (AP) — In a busy term that could set standards for free speech in the digital age, the Supreme... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — In a busy term that could set standards for free speech in the digital age, the Supreme Court on Monday is taking up a dispute between Republican-led states and the Biden administration over how far the federal government can go to combat controversial social... Read More

    March 4, 2024
    by Dan McCue
    Justices Rule Trump Can Stay on Colorado Ballot

    WASHINGTON — In a unanimous decision, the Supreme Court ruled Monday that former President Donald Trump may remain on Colorado’s... Read More

    WASHINGTON — In a unanimous decision, the Supreme Court ruled Monday that former President Donald Trump may remain on Colorado’s primary ballot, rejecting a challenge to his eligibility based on a section of the 14th Amendment that bars those who have “engaged in insurrection” from holding... Read More

    About as Many Abortions Happening in US Monthly as Before Roe Was Overturned, Report Finds

    The number of abortions performed each month is about the same as before the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade and... Read More

    The number of abortions performed each month is about the same as before the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade and the nationwide right to abortion more than a year and a half ago, a new report finds. The latest edition of the #WeCount report conducted for... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top