Supreme Court Tosses Michigan Gerrymandering Ruling

October 22, 2019 by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON – The U.S. Supreme Court threw out a lower court ruling on Monday that would have forced Michigan Republicans to redraw congressional and state legislative district maps to be fairer to Democrats.

In a one-sentence statement at the top of their Monday order list, the justices said the case will now be remanded to the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan.

As is their custom, the justices didn’t explain the rationale for their decision, but it was expected in the aftermath of the court’s June 27 ruling that federal courts have no role to play when it comes to cases of partisan gerrymandering.

With that ruling, the justices upheld a Republican-drawn congressional map in North Carolina and a Democrat-drawn map in Maryland.

In April, a three-judge district court panel invalidated Michigan’s GOP-drawn maps, striking down nine congressional and 25 state legislative districts as unconstitutional partisan gerrymanders.

The U.S. Supreme Court put the Michigan case on hold while the justices deliberated over the North Carolina and Maryland cases.

Monday’s order follows a similar decision on Oct. 8, when the justices returned a case to Ohio for further consideration.

In both the Michigan and Ohio cases, it is expected that the challenges will be dismissed on the grounds of lack of jurisdiction following the June Supreme Court ruling.

In 2018, Michigan voters approved the creation of an independent commission to draw the state’s district lines from 2022 onwards. 

Monday’s order does not disturb the outcome of that vote. However, it too is being challenged in a separate lawsuit.

The Michigan case is Chatfield v. League of Women Voters, 19-220.

State News

Cuomo Extends New York ‘On Pause’ Order Through April 29
State News
Cuomo Extends New York ‘On Pause’ Order Through April 29

NEW YORK — Gov. Andrew Cuomo on Monday ordered non-essential businesses and schools across New York to remain closed through the end of the month, as the coronavirus claimed another 599 lives in the Empire State overnight. In his daily briefing from Albany, Cuomo said he’s... Read More

Wisconsin Primary to Proceed Tuesday After Court Blocks Delay
2020 Elections
Wisconsin Primary to Proceed Tuesday After Court Blocks Delay
April 7, 2020
by Dan McCue

Wisconsin’s presidential preference and other primaries will proceed as scheduled Tuesday after the state Supreme Court blocked Gov. Tony Evers’ last-minute attempt to delay in-person voting by executive order. The state’s highest court, voting 4-2, agreed with Republican legislators who had argued the governor lacked the... Read More

Florida Courts Find Stockpiles of Surgical Masks, Prompting Nationwide Search
In The News
Florida Courts Find Stockpiles of Surgical Masks, Prompting Nationwide Search
April 3, 2020
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON - The Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts has directed federal courts across the nation to conduct a search for surplus medical supplies after two Florida courts discovered such stockpiles and donated them to local hospitals. Employees in the Northern District of Florida, a court... Read More

Federal Judge Won't Postpone Wisconsin Primary, But Expands Voting
2020 Elections
Federal Judge Won't Postpone Wisconsin Primary, But Expands Voting
April 3, 2020
by Dan McCue

A federal judge on Thursday refused to push back the date of Wisconsin's April 7 presidential primary despite concerns about the ongoing coronavirus outbreak. U.S. District Judge William Conley's ruling came after listening to arguments Wednesday over whether the primary should be moved while dire warnings... Read More

Next Coronavirus ‘Hot Spots’ Seen as Michigan, Connecticut, Indiana, Georgia, Illinois
State News
Next Coronavirus ‘Hot Spots’ Seen as Michigan, Connecticut, Indiana, Georgia, Illinois

WASHINGTON — The rate of positive coronavirus tests suggests that the next “hot spots” could include Michigan, Connecticut, Indiana, Georgia and Illinois, White House virus task force coordinator Deborah Birx said Thursday. “We do have two states that have 35% positives. And that’s New York and... Read More

States Get Fraction of Requested Supplies From Strategic Stockpile
State News
States Get Fraction of Requested Supplies From Strategic Stockpile

WASHINGTON — Since the novel coronavirus was first detected in the District of Columbia about a month ago, the city has requested more than 1 million N95 masks from the national stockpile. The number of these masks the city has received: 5,520.  States are receiving just a fraction... Read More

Straight From The Well
scroll top