Telecommute Taxation: States Take Sides Over Out-of-State Income Tax Dispute

January 13, 2021 by Reece Nations
Telecommute Taxation: States Take Sides Over Out-of-State Income Tax Dispute

CONCORD, N.H. — A collection of 14 states have now signed amicus briefs backing New Hampshire in the state’s appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court to determine whether jurisdictions may tax the income of remote workers who cannot commute to their workplaces. 

In October, New Hampshire sued Massachusetts over a dispute regarding a temporary provision that imposes a 5% income tax on employees of Massachusetts companies residing in other states who work remotely. The provision, enacted during the first weeks of the novel coronavirus pandemic, limited the amount of out-of-state income residents can deduct on their income taxes while working remotely for Massachusetts-based entities. 

“Massachusetts cannot balance its budget on the backs of our citizens, punish our workers for making the decision to work from home and keep themselves and their families and those around them safe,” New Hampshire Gov. Chris Sununu said during a press conference. “New Hampshire has no choice but to seek relief in our nation’s highest court.” 

Sununu continued, “We are going to fight this unconstitutional attempt to tax our citizens every step of the way, and we are going to win.” 

The states backing New Hampshire’s lawsuit are listed as follows: Ohio, Arkansas, Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana, Missouri, Nebraska, Oklahoma, Texas, Utah, New Jersey, Connecticut, Hawaii and Iowa. In contrast, Arkansas, Connecticut, Delaware, Nebraska, New York and Pennsylvania had established rules predating the pandemic that taxed workers based on the location of their workplace. 

Massachusetts was the only state to adopt measures that continued taxing wages of workers residing out-of-state amid the pandemic. In October, Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker extended the measure until 90 days after the end of the pandemic period. 

“In the middle of a global pandemic, Massachusetts has taken deliberate aim at the New Hampshire advantage [sic] by purporting to impose Massachusetts income tax on New Hampshire residents for income earned while working within New Hampshire,” the text of New Hampshire’s filed complaint read. “Upending decades of consistent practice, Massachusetts now taxes income earned entirely outside its borders. Through its unprecedented action, Massachusetts has unilaterally imposed an income tax within New Hampshire that New Hampshire, in its sovereign discretion, has deliberately chosen not to impose.” 

States in the past have taken action to avoid “double taxation” by providing credits that offset resident’s tax liability to two locales and by establishing reciprocity agreements that prevent income from being taxed twice. 

In March, Ohio implemented a state law deeming remote work due to COVID-19 protocols to be taking place in the worker’s “principal place of business,” regardless of the city they reside in. However, this was contested in July by the Buckeye Institute in a suit challenging the law’s constitutionality. 

“As attorney general, it is my highest duty to protect the people of New Hampshire and our collective interest as a sovereign state,” New Hampshire Attorney General Gordon MacDonald said in a statement. “That is exactly what we are doing today by commencing an action against the Commonwealth of Massachusetts.” 

MacDonald continued, “Massachusetts has radically redefined what constitutes Massachusetts-sourced income in order to tax earnings for work performed entirely outside its borders. This does not maintain the status quo. It upends it.” 

New Hampshire’s basis for the complaint involves invoking the original jurisdiction of the Supreme Court, meaning lawsuits between two states go immediately to the Court for resolution without having to be litigated in lower courts. In order to do so, the state must demonstrate standing or an injury justifying the lawsuit. 

The complaint alleges Massachusetts’ equalizing of tax burdens regardless of where someone lives unfairly harms New Hampshire communities, state government job recruiting and pandemic response. The Supreme Court has yet to indicate when or if the matter will be brought up for a ruling. 

“While New Hampshire complains that Massachusetts is ‘reaching across its borders’ to tax New Hampshire residents newly telecommuting to their jobs in Massachusetts, Massachusetts has always taxed the Massachusetts-source income of nonresidents who work at Massachusetts businesses, just as other states in turn tax Massachusetts residents’ income from those states,” Massachusetts Attorney General Maura Healy wrote in a brief filed in opposition to the complaint. 

A+
a-
  • Massachisetts
  • New Hampshire
  • state dispute
  • Supreme Court
  • taxation
  • telecomuniting
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    State News

    July 1, 2025
    by Dan McCue
    Allred Launches Senate Bid Aiming for Cornyn Seat

    WASHINGTON — Former Rep. Colin Allred, D-Texas, the former professional football player who ran a spirited but ultimately unsuccessful bid... Read More

    WASHINGTON — Former Rep. Colin Allred, D-Texas, the former professional football player who ran a spirited but ultimately unsuccessful bid to oust Sen. Ted Cruz last year, launched a new Senate campaign Tuesday, hoping to claim the seat currently held by Republican John Cornyn. Allred, who... Read More

    June 10, 2025
    by Katelyn Sims
    Lawmakers Fear ‘Chaos’ Caused by Tariffs Will ‘Decimate’ Retirees’ Savings

    WASHINGTON — Sens. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., and Ron Wyden, D-Ore., have written a letter to Trump administration officials expressing their... Read More

    WASHINGTON — Sens. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., and Ron Wyden, D-Ore., have written a letter to Trump administration officials expressing their fear that the “economic chaos” stemming from the president’s tariff policy will “decimate retirees’ savings.” Compounding their concerns, they wrote, is the administration’s taking a “wrecking... Read More

    April 13, 2025
    by Beth McCue
    Colorado Warms to Geothermal Energy, Awards $14.4M in Project Funding

    DENVER, Colo. — “The heat beneath our feet.” That’s how Colorado Gov. Jared Polis referred to geothermal energy when he... Read More

    DENVER, Colo. — “The heat beneath our feet.” That’s how Colorado Gov. Jared Polis referred to geothermal energy when he made his recent announcement of $14.4 million in funding to support geothermal heating projects in his state. The funding from the Geothermal Energy Grant Program and Geothermal... Read More

    Supreme Court Rejects Republican-led Effort to Halt Climate Change Lawsuits in Democratic-led states

    WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Monday rejected a lawsuit from Republican attorneys general in 19 states aimed at blocking climate change suits... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Monday rejected a lawsuit from Republican attorneys general in 19 states aimed at blocking climate change suits against the oil and gas industry from Democratic-led states. The justices acted on an unusual Republican effort to file suit in the Supreme Court over the... Read More

    Trump's Celebration of American Greatness Puts a Spotlight on a Little-Known Panel of Experts

    Within hours of taking office, President Donald Trump outlined in one of his many executive orders a mission to celebrate... Read More

    Within hours of taking office, President Donald Trump outlined in one of his many executive orders a mission to celebrate American greatness and to recognize those who have made contributions throughout history. He jumpstarted the effort by ordering the name of North America’s tallest peak to be changed... Read More

    Georgia Islanders Rushed to Rescue Survivors After Dock Walkway Collapsed Killing Seven

    SAVANNAH, Ga. (AP) — Orange life jackets bobbed in the water, where bystanders rushed to form a human chain for passing... Read More

    SAVANNAH, Ga. (AP) — Orange life jackets bobbed in the water, where bystanders rushed to form a human chain for passing survivors to safety. Others shouldered the task of wrapping bodies in blankets and carrying them to shore. The frantic scene after an aluminum gangway collapsed Saturday at a... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top