Maryland Marijuana Case Sets Standard For Police Searches Of Crime Suspects
A ruling last week by Maryland’s highest court is likely to help redefine the criminal law of marijuana possession as states nationwide search for new legal standards.
A unanimous Maryland Court of Appeals ruled that police who smell marijuana can use the odor to justify a search of a vehicle but not a person. A person can be searched only if there is probable cause to believe the suspects were involved in separate crimes, the court said.
“The same facts and circumstances that justify a search of an automobile do not necessarily justify an arrest and search incident thereto. This is based on the heightened expectation of privacy one enjoys in his or her person as compared to the diminished expectation of privacy one has in an automobile,” the court’s opinion says.
Like Maryland, 10 other states allow sales and recreational use of small amounts of marijuana. Another 15 states have decriminalized possession of the drug for personal use.
In 2014, the Maryland legislature downgraded possession of 10 grams or less of marijuana from a crime to a civil offense. It still can result in citations and fines of $100.
The state justices noted evolving popular opinions about marijuana by placing a lyric from a Bob Dylan song, “The Times They Are a-Changin,” in a notation at the top of their order.
The opinion was issued in the case of Michael Pacheco, who was sitting in a parked vehicle outside a laundromat in Wheaton, Md., on May 26, 2016, holding a marijuana cigarette.
Two Montgomery County Police officers nearby testified they smelled “fresh burnt” marijuana and saw a marijuana cigarette in the vehicle’s center console.
The officers searched the car and Pacheco, finding cocaine in his left front pocket. He was arrested, charged with possession of cocaine with intent to distribute and given a citation for marijuana possession.
Pacheco’s attorney moved to suppress evidence of the cocaine, arguing the search of his person was illegal because officers lacked probable cause to believe he possessed 10 grams or more of marijuana.
Prosecutors said the marijuana odor established probable cause to search the vehicle and Pacheco.
The Maryland Court of Appeals agreed with Pacheco. The police search and arrest “was unreasonable because nothing in the record suggests that possession of a joint and the odor of burnt marijuana gave the police probable cause to believe he was in possession of a criminal amount of that substance,” the court’s opinion said.
The court’s previous decisions granted exceptions to citizens’ Fourth Amendment privacy rights when police searched them during an arrest or when illegal items were seen in their automobiles.
In those cases, police did not need a search warrant.
Pacheco’s case was different, the Maryland court said. The smell of marijuana was not enough evidence for an arrest and search now that the drug is legalized in the state.
In an age of decriminalization, courts nationwide “have grappled with the constitutionality of searches and seizures” based on marijuana smell, the ruling said.
Recent court decisions in other states have reached similar conclusions.
In Pennsylvania, a state court judge ruled state troopers lacked probable cause to search a vehicle after smelling marijuana during a traffic stop. The evidence showed the man who was stopped carried a medical marijuana card.
In Florida, some prosecutors support an “odor-plus” standard in which marijuana smell is only one of several factors that proves probable cause to search suspects.
The case is Michael Pacheco v. State of Maryland, Maryland Ct. App., Case No. 17, September Term, 2018.
In The News
Today, Wisconsin Gov. Tony Evers said the state has shipped its one-millionth N95 mask as part of ongoing efforts to ensure frontline workers have access to the critical personal protective equipment (PPE) they need to limit their exposure to COVID-19. The announcement comes after Evers recently... Read More
New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy recently announced that the New Jersey Department of Transportation will be awarding $161.25 million in municipal aid grants to advance road, bridge, safety, and quality-of-life improvements. Over 540 cities and towns throughout the state will benefit from the grant funds. “These... Read More
The disinformation scenario that local election officials feared months ago has come true: President Donald Trump's false claims of voter fraud have been picked up by many state and local Republican officials across the country, and polls now show that more than two-thirds of GOP voters believe the 2020 election... Read More
NEW YORK — A COVID-19 vaccine may be months from reaching millions of Americans. Getting all those shots into arms will be a monumental task. Shreveport, Louisiana, is getting ready now. The city recently completed a test run, one of about a dozen across the state. Health officials... Read More
TRENTON, N.J. - New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy signed an executive order Thursday night, extending the deadline by which counties must certify the results of the 2020 election. The immediate effect of the order relates to two counties, Ocean and Salem, whose boards of elections have... Read More
ATLANTA — U.S. Sen. Kelly Loeffler, R- Ga., is facing a pair of ethics complaints after she solicited campaign contributions for her runoff campaign during an on-camera interview at the U.S. Capitol. The Democratic Party of Georgia and the American Democracy Legal Fund both filed complaints with the Senate ethics committee focused on her Wednesday interview with Fox... Read More