Judge Rules Against California’s Bid to Require Cancer Label on Roundup

June 23, 2020 by Dan McCue
Judge Rules Against California’s Bid to Require Cancer Label on Roundup

California can’t require a cancer warning label on Monsanto’s Roundup herbicide, a federal judge ruled Monday, saying the state hadn’t met the legal standard for such a requirement.

California requires warning labels on cancer-causing products under the state’s Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act. Currently the state identifies about 900 chemicals that could trigger such a warning.

Under the law, which was approved by public referendum in 1986, businesses selling potentially cancer-causing  products must provide “clear and reasonable warnings” to the public — unless the anticipated level of exposure would pose no significant cancer risk.

The law defines “no significant risk” as a level of exposure that would cause no more than 1 extra case of cancer in 100,000 people over a 70-year lifetime. 

The state wanted to label products containing glyphosate — the main ingredient in Monsanto’s Roundup — because of a 2015 finding by the International Agency for Research on Cancer, an arm of the World Health Organization, that glyphosate was a probable cause of cancer in humans.

Monsanto sued and in 2018, U.S. District Judge William Shubb temporarily blocked the warning label. 

In issuing a permanent injunction on Monday, Shubb said Supreme Court precedent precludes states from requiring a private company to change its labels unless the statement to be added is “purely factual and non-controversial.”

The judge said the cancer warning California wanted on Roundup would not come close to meeting that standard, because most regulatory bodies — including the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and most of its counterparts in Europe — have found no connection between the herbicide and the disease.

“The great weight of evidence indicates that glyphosate is not known to cause cancer,” the judge wrote.

Shubb rejected proposals by Attorney General Xavier Becerra’s office to reword the label warnings to include both the IARC and EPA findings and a reference to a website for further information. 

The judge said such rewording would mislead the public because it would give them the unwarranted impression that there is equal weight of evidence on both sides of the issue.

Becerra’s office said it is reviewing Monday’s decision.

In the meantime, Monsanto cheered the ruling, saying in a written statement that Shubb’s decision is “a very important ruling for California agriculture and for science.”

Monsanto contends the product is safe but is facing thousands of lawsuits. Cancer victims in Northern California have won nearly $200 million in awards in three lawsuits, including a couple last year who were awarded about $2 billion. That award was later reduced to $87 million. 

All of the verdicts are currently being appealed.

Last year, the Trump administration said it wouldn’t approve warning labels for products that contain glyphosate because its research showed the chemical poses no risks to public health. 

A+
a-
  • California
  • court ruling
  • labeling
  • MOnsanto
  • Pesticide
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    State News

    Great Basin Tribes Want Bahsahwahbee Massacre Site in Nevada Named National Monument

    ELY, Nev. (AP) — White attackers turned a lush, high desert oasis in eastern Nevada, with its bubbling springs and... Read More

    ELY, Nev. (AP) — White attackers turned a lush, high desert oasis in eastern Nevada, with its bubbling springs and a rare stand of Rocky Mountain junipers, into killing fields. They massacred hundreds of Native people there in the 1800s — a horrific history once retold... Read More

    In Milwaukee, Biden Looks to Highlight Progress for Black-Owned Small Businesses

    WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden is aiming to use a visit to the battleground state of Wisconsin on Wednesday... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden is aiming to use a visit to the battleground state of Wisconsin on Wednesday to spotlight a surge in federal government support for Black-owned small businesses during his White House tenure and to highlight his administration's efforts to ramp up... Read More

    Why More Women Live in Major East Coast Counties While Men Outnumber Them in West

    Anyone who has suspected that there are more women than men where they live, or vice versa, will find fodder... Read More

    Anyone who has suspected that there are more women than men where they live, or vice versa, will find fodder for their suspicions in new data from the U.S. Census Bureau. Whether it refutes or confirms their suspicions likely depends on where they live. Women outnumber... Read More

    Ranked Choice Voting Bill Moves to Hearing in Front of Wis. Senate Elections Committee

    MADISON, Wis. (AP) — A bipartisan bill that would dramatically change how Wisconsin residents choose congressional candidates by asking them... Read More

    MADISON, Wis. (AP) — A bipartisan bill that would dramatically change how Wisconsin residents choose congressional candidates by asking them to rank their top choices instead of voting for one of two candidates is headed for its first public hearing. The state Senate's election committee was... Read More

    Democrats Eye Wisconsin High Court's Liberal Majority to Win Abortion, Redistricting Rulings

    MADISON, Wis. (AP) — Wisconsin's Supreme Court will flip from majority conservative to liberal control in August and Democrats have... Read More

    MADISON, Wis. (AP) — Wisconsin's Supreme Court will flip from majority conservative to liberal control in August and Democrats have high hopes the change will lead to the state's abortion ban being overturned and its maps redrawn to weaken GOP control of the Legislature and congressional districts. Democrats... Read More

    States Confront Medical Debt That's Bankrupting Millions

    DENVER (AP) — Cindy Powers was driven into bankruptcy by 19 life-saving abdominal operations. Medical debt started stacking up for... Read More

    DENVER (AP) — Cindy Powers was driven into bankruptcy by 19 life-saving abdominal operations. Medical debt started stacking up for Lindsey Vance after she crashed her skateboard and had to get nine stitches in her chin. And for Misty Castaneda, open heart surgery for a disease... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top