Senators Express Frustration with FDA for Slow Response to Vaping Hazards

November 15, 2019 by Tom Ramstack
A selection of the popular Juul brand vaping supplies on display in the window of a vaping store in New York on Saturday, March 24, 2018. A state judge has granted a preliminary injunction to halt Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer's flavored vaping ban. (Richard B. Levine/Sipa USA/TNS)

WASHINGTON — A Food and Drug Administration official told a U.S. Senate committee this week that new regulations to control vaping are likely coming soon, but couldn’t say when.

His testimony drew rebukes and words of frustration from members of the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee.

“There is no final answer as of now,” said Mitch Zeller, director of the FDA’s Center for Tobacco Products.

Trump administration officials said in September that it would clamp down soon on the flavored e-cigarettes that are blamed for killing at least 40 people and sickening thousands with a respiratory illness.

Electronic cigarettes, also known as e-cigarettes, are handheld battery-powered vaporizers that simulate smoking but without burning tobacco. Using an e-cigarette is known as “vaping.” 

The White House announcement said “the FDA intends to finalize a compliance policy in the coming weeks … clearing the market of non-authorized e-cigarette products …”

Some senators during a hearing Wednesday questioned whether the FDA was wavering under pressure from the e-cigarette industry.

“I think any questions about the current state of policy really needs to be directed to the White House,” Zeller said in response. “We are in a deliberative process. The White House made an announcement in September and we are working to advance a policy consistent with taking steps to do everything that we can to protect kids from these products.”

Sen. Tim Kaine, D-Va., accused Zeller of either hiding or not knowing how the Trump administration plans to eliminate hazards of e-cigarettes.

Zeller replied, “There is no final answer on the policy question, that’s why we continue to have these discussions internally.”

Kaine suggested that further delays are dangerous.

“We should get an answer to this question about whether the administration is going to honor the policy that they announced or not,” Kaine said.

Sen. Maggie Hassan, D-N.H., told the FDA official, “You’ve had plenty of time already, and kids, people, Americans all over this country are being hurt.”

Anne Schuchat, a deputy director for the Atlanta-based Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), described how health officials are responding to health problems from e-cigarettes.

“As of November 5, 2019, there are 2051 confirmed and probable cases of [e-cigarette lung injuries] reported” in the United States,” Schuchat said.

“Most patients reported a gradual onset of difficulty breathing, shortness of breath or chest pain before hospitalization,” she said. “Some patients reported mild to moderate gastrointestinal illness. This lung condition is serious.”

The CDC activated its Emergency Operations Center in September. About 300 of its staff members are either investigating the lung illnesses or disseminating information about them to state health officials.

The CDC reported last week that vitamin E acetate is the most likely culprit in causing vaping-related illnesses and deaths. Most of the victims were teenage boys and young men.

The report was based on samples of lung fluid from 29 patients affected by the mysterious e-cigarette lung illness. Two of them died.

Vitamin E acetate was found in all samples. The substance is most commonly found in skin creams, where it is harmless.

U.S. Senate

View From the Gallery: Senators Pack Up Desks as Impeachment Trial Nears Its End
Impeachment
View From the Gallery: Senators Pack Up Desks as Impeachment Trial Nears Its End

WASHINGTON — Senate Minority Leader Charles E. Schumer tightly hugged Rep. Adam B. Schiff just after the closing argument in President Donald Trump’s impeachment trial, then spoke directly into the House lead manager’s ear for about 10 seconds. Before the New York senator let go, he... Read More

What Happens If Senators Are Tied 50-50 on Whether to Call Impeachment Witnesses?
Impeachment
What Happens If Senators Are Tied 50-50 on Whether to Call Impeachment Witnesses?

WASHINGTON — With increasing prospects of a 50-50 tie on the Friday vote to subpoena witnesses in President Trump’s impeachment trial, Democrats are considering how they might be able to nudge Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. to weigh in on the issue and break the... Read More

Impeachment Cellphone Ban Gives Senate Pages a Workout
Impeachment
Impeachment Cellphone Ban Gives Senate Pages a Workout

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump’s impeachment trial may be requiring senators to stay seated hour after agonizing hour, but there’s one group getting more exercise than they’ve seen in years: Senate pages. The blue-jacket-clad teens have been running all over the Senate floor, relaying messages between... Read More

Senate Democrats Push House Gun Provisions in Violence Against Women Act
Guns
Senate Democrats Push House Gun Provisions in Violence Against Women Act

WASHINGTON — Senate Democrats on Wednesday introduced the same Violence Against Women Act reauthorization bill passed by the House, days after they say talks with Republicans about a compromise broke down over controversial gun provisions. The entire Democratic caucus has backed the bill, which has provisions... Read More

Border Wall, Other Disputes Sidetrack Senate Spending Work
Federal Budget
Border Wall, Other Disputes Sidetrack Senate Spending Work

WASHINGTON — The Senate’s appropriations process fell into disarray Tuesday after a scheduled markup was abruptly postponed in a dispute over policy riders, and a fight over the border wall threatened to hold up defense spending. Democrats were also resisting the GOP majority’s proposed subcommittee allocations... Read More

Congress Returns to Gun Control Fight and a Government Shutdown Deadline
Congress
Congress Returns to Gun Control Fight and a Government Shutdown Deadline

WASHINGTON — Congress returns to Washington this week amid mounting pressure from Democrats and the public to enact new gun restrictions, but lawmakers from both parties say meaningful action hangs solely on President Donald Trump. Since lawmakers were last in session Aug. 2, three mass shootings... Read More

Straight From The Well
scroll top