Rising Tide Hasn’t Lifted Trump’s Boat

Presidential Job Approval Rating Charts

October 19, 2018

By Mark Z. Barabak


Charts on economic outlook under President Trump. Los Angeles Times 2018


RENO, Nev. — When the Great Recession hit, it walloped Nevada like no other state, claiming Corry Castaneda among its many victims.

His work remodeling homes practically dried up — “the joke was we were all burning furniture to keep warm” — and there were times he and his wife and two kids were just a paycheck away from desperation.

Things changed dramatically as the economy roared back to life. There’s money in the bank now, Castaneda said, and his career, managing commercial real estate, is thriving as Reno and its neighbors experience a tech-driven boom.

But that’s no thanks, he says, to President Donald Trump, or anyone else in Washington.

Trump boasts of presiding over the greatest economy in the history of America. Even allowing for his habitual exaggeration, the statistics are impressive: the lowest unemployment rate in nearly half a century, a sky-scraping stock market — even after the recent slide — and buoyant levels of business and consumer confidence.

Yet the president’s approval rating is stuck in the dumps, hovering in the low 40 percent range, owing to the near-constant distractions he creates, the uneven benefits of his signature tax cut, and voters like Castaneda who think Trump has very little, if anything, to do with their good fortunes.

The 47-year-old Libertarian credits retiring Republican Gov. Brian Sandoval and local business leaders for making the Reno area a post-recession magnet for Apple, Tesla and other job-producing engines.

“Much of the Washington stuff doesn’t necessarily trickle down or translate to northern Nevada,” Castaneda said, pausing en route to the buffet at a recent Rotary Club lunch.

The disconnect between economic performance and political fallout is not wholly new. Strong growth, which hit a muscular 5.2 percent in the third quarter of 2014, was not enough to stave off electoral disaster for President Barack Obama in that year’s midterm election, when Democrats lost the Senate.

Perhaps because then, as now, not everyone shared equally in the prosperity.

The tax cuts that Trump signed into law have been like rocket fuel for corporate profits and Wall Street investors. But Americans of lesser means have seen considerably more modest benefits, which by some calculations have been largely offset by inflation, increased health care costs and higher gas prices.

Still, the gap between doing well and liking the president appears to be considerably greater than usual. Indeed, repeated surveys show the robust economy is not a key driver this midterm election.

The reason, many suggest, is Trump himself.

“A huge part of this is he’s a big personality, and being a big personality he’s made this a very personal referendum,” said Anita Dunn, a former Obama strategist. “He has, to some extent, separated himself from his policy achievements.”

John Sides, a George Washington University political scientist, was blunter still. “He can’t get out of his own way,” Sides said, citing the self-generated controversies surrounding Trump from the moment he launched his White House bid.

When Sides crunches the data — overlaying presidential popularity and the University of Michigan’s decades-long survey of consumer confidence — he calculates that Trump’s approval rating would be about 20 percent higher than it is today if not for his behavior, temperament and myriad scandals.

The difference is significant. In midterm elections going back to 1946, presidents with job approval ratings below 50 percent in Gallup surveys have seen their party lose an average of 37 House seats, compared with 14 when a president’s approval was above 50 percent. Democrats need to gain 23 seats to win control of the House on Nov. 6.

Like so much else these days, perceptions of the economy are strongly colored by partisanship.

Republicans tend to have a much rosier view than Democrats — the reverse being true when Obama was president — though many who dislike Trump would doubtless do so no matter how low the unemployment rate or how high the stock market.

Democrats, surveys show, are particularly loath to attribute these good times to the president, or to anything he has accomplished.

“I’m not an economist but I know a lot of key metrics were already on the upswing at the end of Obama’s term,” said Tova McGilvray, 35, who works for a title company in Reno after holding down three jobs — court clerk, bartender and casino dancer — when Nevada’s economy began cratering in 2008.

“For Trump to swoop in and take credit is as ludicrous as saying Obama caused the recession when you’re talking about financial manipulations that happened under (George W.) Bush,” she said of Obama’s Republican predecessor.

But partisanship can’t entirely explain the disparity between the economy’s performance and evaluations of Trump.

In a Wall Street Journal/NBC News poll in September, nearly 7 in 10 voters surveyed expressed satisfaction with the economy, and a plurality, 41 percent, said the president’s policies had helped. Still, nearly 6 in 10 — including nearly a third of Republicans — said they wanted a change from the direction Trump was headed, suggesting the economy was hardly paramount in weighing their vote.

Liza Maupin, for one, believes that presidents have very little control over the economy, and that Trump is no exception.

“I don’t think you can credit anyone personally. I know lots of people are taking credit,” the 55-year-old Republican said with a knowing laugh. “The economy’s cyclical. Things go up and down.”

For that reason, she’s focused on other issues, including immigration, human rights and which candidates she believes will work best across party lines. Maupin won’t be supporting Dean Heller, the state’s Republican senator, as he seeks a second term and ties himself closely — too closely for her taste — to the president.

“I’m no fan of Trump,” said Maupin, who recently retired from running a local charity. “I’ll just leave it at that.” (Trump lost Nevada to Hillary Clinton, and though his approval rating is better here than in other states, it still stands below 50 percent.)

It is striking, given Nevada’s dramatic turnaround, that the economy hasn’t been an overriding issue in Heller’s re-election fight, the campaign to succeed Sandoval or a pair of competitive congressional races.

Unemployment peaked at 13.7 percent in 2010, the highest in the nation, and for a time Nevada also led the country in home foreclosures and personal bankruptcies. Today, unemployment is 4.5 percent, job growth is more than twice the national average and taxable retail sales have hit the highest level in state history, according to Applied Analysis, an economic forecasting and research firm.

But instead of talking up the state’s comeback, GOP candidates have focused mainly on tearing down their Democratic opponents.

Heller portrays Jacky Rosen, a Las Vegas congresswoman, as a cackling Hillary Clinton clone with nothing to show for her single term in the House. Former Republican Rep. Cresent Hardy depicts former Democratic Rep. Steven Horsford, his rival for a House seat representing Las Vegas, as a deadbeat who failed to pay his bills and had his driver’s license suspended for ignoring a traffic ticket.

“Not a lot of morning in America,” said former Nevada Gov. Robert List, a Republican, referring to the radiant TV spot that President Reagan ran amid the prosperity that helped usher him to a second term.

Eric Herzik, a longtime student of Nevada politics, said candidates were smart not to place too much emphasis on the economy, since the state in some ways is still recovering from its years-long downturn.

Unemployment is still higher than the national 3.7 percent jobless rate. Home prices and median household incomes, while considerably higher, have still not reached their pre-recession levels.

“Most voters would say, yes, this is good but not ‘great,’ ‘tremendous’ or whatever superlative Trump uses on a given day,” said Herzik, who heads the political science department at the University of Nevada, Reno.

“Everybody’s happy the recession is over,” he said. “Everybody would say the economy is very strong … but there are still a lot of people who don’t feel completely on their feet and that the economy is benefiting them personally.”

All of which make the Nevada contests too close to call with less than three weeks to Election Day.


©2018 Los Angeles Times

Visit the Los Angeles Times at www.latimes.com

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

  • TNS
  • Economy

    House Democrats Unveil New Coronavirus Relief Plan
    House Democrats Unveil New Coronavirus Relief Plan

    WASHINGTON — House Democrats unveiled a $2.2 trillion pandemic relief package Monday night as part of a last-ditch attempt to secure new aid before the Nov. 3 elections. Even as talks resumed between Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin on a potential compromise, Democrats... Read More

    Govs. Whitmer, Cuomo Call for Investigation of Trump’s ‘Politicization’ of Coronavirus Pandemic
    Political News
    Govs. Whitmer, Cuomo Call for Investigation of Trump’s ‘Politicization’ of Coronavirus Pandemic
    September 28, 2020
    by Reece Nations

    New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo and Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer jointly released a statement urging Congress to open an oversight investigation concerning “the Trump administration’s politicization of government functions,” that undermined the nation’s pandemic response. In their statement, the governors contend President Donald Trump and his... Read More

    Pelosi Says Democrats Will Make New Aid ‘Proffer’ to Mnuchin
    Pelosi Says Democrats Will Make New Aid ‘Proffer’ to Mnuchin

    Speaker Nancy Pelosi said there’s a chance she and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin can still reach a deal on a coronavirus stimulus package, and that Democrats will unveil a new “proffer” shortly. “I trust Secretary Mnuchin to represent something that can reach a solution, and I... Read More

    Threats of Arrest, Job Loss and Surveillance. China Works to Erase Its ‘Model Minority’
    Threats of Arrest, Job Loss and Surveillance. China Works to Erase Its ‘Model Minority’

    BEIJING — The herder couldn’t speak for long. His phone was being monitored, he said, as are those of many other Mongols around him. “We have no way out. There’s nothing we can do,” said Gangbater, a herder in Xilingol League, a central part of China’s... Read More

    US Jobless Claims Remain Elevated in Sign of Gradual Recovery
    US Jobless Claims Remain Elevated in Sign of Gradual Recovery

    Applications for U.S. unemployment benefits were little changed last week, contrasting with estimates for a decline and highlighting an economic recovery that’s coming in fits and starts. Initial jobless claims in regular state programs increased by 4,000 to 870,000 in the week ended Sept. 19, according... Read More

    House Democrats Drafting $2.4 Trillion Coronavirus Relief Bill
    House Democrats Drafting $2.4 Trillion Coronavirus Relief Bill

    WASHINGTON — Speaker Nancy Pelosi has directed House committee leaders to put together a more slender coronavirus relief package than the one that previously passed the chamber, in their latest offer in talks with the White House. The House could vote on that as-yet-unreleased $2.4 trillion... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top