Revised North American Trade Deal Overwhelmingly Passes House

December 20, 2019 by Dan McCue
Deputy Prime Minister of Canada Chrystia Freeland, left, Mexico's top trade negotiator Jesus Seade, center, and U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer, sign an update to the North American Free Trade Agreement, at the national palace in Mexico City, Tuesday, Dec. 10. 2019. Observing from behind are Mexico's Treasury Secretary Arturo Herrera, left, Mexico's President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador, second left, Mexico's Labor Secretary Maria Alcade, third left, and The President of the Mexican Senate Ricardo Monreal. (AP Photo/Marco Ugarte)

WASHINGTON – In a strong show of bipartisan cooperation just hours after they were at each other’s throats over the impeachment of President Donald Trump, Democrats and Republicans threw their support behind a new trade agreement with Canada and Mexico.

The 385-41 vote in the House on Thursday clears the way for the bill’s anticipated passage in the Senate and its being signed promptly by President Trump in the White House.

However, a vote in the Senate isn’t expected until after the new year, as Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., said he will wait to hold a vote until the conclusion of an impeachment trial.

The passage of what is, technically, the implementing legislation for the revised United States-Mexico-Canada trade deal, came after months of negotiations involving U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and a working group comprised of Democratic lawmakers.

It also followed nearly two years of sometimes fraught talks with officials in Canada and Mexico.

While many of the provisions in the more than 2,000 page document simply update the original NAFTA agreement, it also includes changes that will discourage the “nearshoring” — moving factories and assembly plants to nearby, less expensive countries — that made the original deal such a boon for the North American neighbors of the U.S..

The USMCA adds new rules for food safety and e-commerce, includes provisions intended to prevent labor violations, and eliminates a special arbitration system that lawmakers on Capitol Hill long considered odious.

Lighthizer, who was on hand for the House vote, said the USMCA’s passage “with such huge bipartisan support is a major milestone.

“The USMCA is expected to create between 176,000 and 589,000 new American jobs and substantially increase economic growth. The International Trade Commission’s analysis shows that USMCA will have a more positive impact on our economy, jobs and wages than any other U.S. trade agreement ever negotiated.”

The International Trade Commission projected in April that the agreement would boost the economy by $68 billion and add 176,000 jobs six years after taking effect.

Thursday’s vote also allows lawmakers from both parties to head into the Christmas recess touting their support of an agreement sought by farmers, ranchers and business owners anxious to move past the months of trade tensions that have complicated spending and hiring decisions.

“Twenty-six years ago, I opposed NAFTA with every bone in my body,” said Rep. John Lewis, D-Ga. “I never thought the day would come when we would have the opportunity to right some of the wrongs in that agreement.”

Rep. Derek Kilmer, D-Wash., chairman of the New Democrat Coalition, a caucus that was an early and consistent supporter of modernizing NAFTA, said, “We do better when our communities nationwide are better able to export ‘Made in America’ products around the world.

“The updated USMCA makes critical improvements to a 25-year-old trade agreement to address 21st century issues, support workers, and improve our environment,” Kilmer continued. “This new deal is infinitely better than NAFTA, and I’m proud of the critical role NDC Members played in getting an agreement that can serve as a template for bipartisan consensus in future agreements.”

“Bringing the USMCA to a vote is good for the American people,” said Problem Solvers Caucus co-chair Rep. Tom Reed, R-N.Y., “Its passage through the House is a huge victory where people are put ahead of politics, and I thank my colleagues in the Problem Solvers Caucus for supporting this effort. It is time to get this to the President’s desk, as it is particularly good for our American farmers and workers.”

Rep. Jimmy Panetta, D-Calif., voted for the deal because, “Our agriculture on the central coast of California relies heavily on our leading trade partners Canada and Mexico. The USMCA will provide our farmers and ranchers with improved and continued access to those critical export markets and give them the certainty that they deserve.”

Rep. Anthony Brindisi, D-N.Y., sounded a similar note, saying “This trade deal will help our family farmers, small businesses, and workers.

“I worked hard, with Democrats, Republicans, and key members of the Administration to get this deal done. USMCA will make sure our dairy farmers have access to markets, hold Mexico and Canada accountable, and help keep good-paying jobs in our country,” he said.

The original NAFTA phased out nearly all tariffs on goods produced and traded within North America.

But Democrats for years have charged that NAFTA led to massive losses of high-paying manufacturing jobs in the U.S. as companies moved production to low-wage Mexico.

Trump made tossing  the North American Free Trade Agreement a hallmark of his presidential run in 2016 as he tried to win over working-class voters in states such as Michigan, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania.

“Is the USMCA a perfect trade deal? No—no trade deal ever is,” said Rep. Denny Heck, D-Wash., “But as I see it, we have three possibilities: the old NAFTA, no NAFTA, or a new and improved NAFTA. The USMCA is the third of those options, a trade deal that is a significant improvement over the one it will replace.”

The prospects for passing the trade deal got a boost just last week when both the AFL-CIO and the Teamsters endorsed it. They joined a number of business groups who supported the deal, including the U.S. Chamber of Commerce.

However, others expressed dissatisfaction with the deal.

Rep. Tony Cárdenas, D-Calif., said he couldn’t support USMCA because he didn’t believe it was a fair deal for American workers.

“Today, I voted against NAFTA 2.0 because I do not believe it was a fair deal for American workers. While I do appreciate the efforts of my Democratic colleagues to fix the problems of the original NAFTA deal, this new trade agreement does not go far enough in protecting American workers and raising American wages, and it does not meet the environmental standards of a trade deal in the 21st century,” he said.

He also lamented that the final text of the bill omitted any mention of climate change.

The PASS USMCA coalition, which represented a range of industries including pharmaceuticals, withdrew its support for the measure after months of lobbying for it, decrying the removal of “certain intellectual property protections” that it said “puts American scientists and creators at a serious disadvantage abroad.”

Also unhappy was the Competitive Enterprise Institute, a nonprofit public policy organization that advocates limited government. In a joint statement, Iain Murray, the Institute’s vice president, and Ryan Young, a senior fellow, said, “While USMCA is not that different from NAFTA, its trade-unrelated provisions and political giveaways set precedents that could harm future trade agreements for decades to come.

“USMCA’s acronym, which scraps NAFTA’s “F” and “T” standing for “Free Trade,” is more telling than its drafters likely intended,” they said.

Trade

Justices Rule Firm Chartering Vessel For Transport of Oil Obligated to Provide Safe Berth
Energy
Justices Rule Firm Chartering Vessel For Transport of Oil Obligated to Provide Safe Berth
March 30, 2020
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON - In a case with implications to both maritime transportation and international trade, the Supreme Court ruled a firm that contracted for a delivery of oil was obligated to provide “safe berth” for the vessel carrying it. The underlying facts of the case go back... Read More

Expert Says USMCA Will Make North American Firms More Competitive
Trade
Expert Says USMCA Will Make North American Firms More Competitive
March 27, 2020
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON - Although it barely caused a ripple given the understandable focus on the worldwide coronavirus outbreak, a historic new chapter in North American commerce began two weeks ago Friday, when Canada became the third and final country to ratify the region's new trade pact. The... Read More

First Post-USMCA Challenge: COVID-19 Border Closures
Trade
First Post-USMCA Challenge: COVID-19 Border Closures
March 20, 2020
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON - The Canada-U.S. border will close to all non-essential travel in both directions Friday night, and officials are set to impose similar restrictions at the U.S. border with Mexico later today. It was only two months ago President Donald Trump signed the implementing legislation for... Read More

Trump Signs USMCA, Declaring an End to 'the NAFTA Nightmare'
Trade
Trump Signs USMCA, Declaring an End to 'the NAFTA Nightmare'
January 29, 2020
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON - President Donald Trump signed the new North American trade deal into law on Wednesday, declaring an end to "the NAFTA nightmare" and the beginning of a "glorious future." During an outdoor signing ceremony at the White House, Trump said, "This is a cutting-edge, state-of-the-art... Read More

Senate Approves Revised USMCA Trade Deal by Huge Margin
Trade
Senate Approves Revised USMCA Trade Deal by Huge Margin
January 17, 2020
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON — The Senate handed President Donald Trump a policy victory on Thursday, backing USMCA, the new North American trade deal, the same day the chamber turned its attention to the president's impeachment trial. Once it's signed by Trump, USMCA will replace the 25-year-old North American... Read More

Analysis: New US-China Trade Deal Leaves the Thorniest Problems Unresolved
Trade
Analysis: New US-China Trade Deal Leaves the Thorniest Problems Unresolved

WASHINGTON — After nearly two years of a bruising trade war, President Donald Trump signed a trade deal with China on Wednesday that provides the president with political bragging rights but allows both sides to put off the most difficult disputes until after the November election.... Read More

Straight From The Well
scroll top