Wind Generators Faces Support and Skeptics as Government Seeks Renewable Energy
WASHINGTON — The wind drove federal lawmakers Thursday to consider whether offshore turbines should become a major new source of electricity for American consumers.
As environmentalists tried to convince a congressional panel that wind energy is a cost-effective investment, detractors said hidden expenses mean it’s not worth the money.
“It’s a game changer for renewable energy,” said Rep. Mike Doyle, D-Pa., a member of the House Energy and Commerce subcommittee on energy.
President Joe Biden proposes generating 30 gigawatts of electricity from offshore wind generators by 2030, which would be nearly 700 times more than now.
However, the cost estimates and benefits are widely disputed, which prompted much of the debate during the congressional hearing Thursday.
“We need to look before we leap and we need to gather those facts,” said Rep. Fred Upton, R-Mich.
Rather than projecting years into the future about what wind generators might provide, the federal government should be dealing with more immediate energy problems, he said.
“We’re in an energy crisis right now,” Upton said as he discussed the upcoming winter.
Nationally, home heating oil prices are up 43 percent in the past year for an average of $1,700 per year per household, according to energy industry estimates. Nearly half of U.S. homes use natural gas for heat, which means an average of a 30 percent bigger bill than one year ago.
Environmentalists who testified to the subcommittee called arguments against wind energy short-sighted and dangerous in a world moving toward climate crisis caused by fossil fuels.
“The beauty of offshore wind is that wind is free,” said Heather Zichal, chief executive officer of the environmental group American Clean Power Association.
She addressed skeptics’ concerns about the high costs of manufacturing, installing and operating the generators by saying the costs are falling.
“The cost of wind [energy] has come down 71 percent since 2009,” Zichal said. Further reductions are likely with improving technology, she added.
The Biden plan for an estimated 2,000 wind generators would produce as many as 83,000 well-paying jobs and $25 billion in annual revenue, Zichal said.
However, the plan could only become practical with a long-term government commitment and certainty for the energy industry about regulatory requirements, she said.
Mark Menezes, a former U.S. Energy Department deputy secretary, warned against rushing into a massive wind energy development project.
Finding the best sites for the generators and installing the base equipment could be prohibitively expensive, he said. In addition, the electricity needs to be stored in batteries, which cannot yet store it long enough to be cost-effective, he said.
“The cost is going to be put on ratepayers,” Menezes said.
Several lawmakers asked about lessons that could be learned from European countries, such as the United Kingdom. It derives about a quarter of its electricity from offshore wind generators.
Their electrical grid has been plagued by unreliable generation and high prices for consumers in recent years.
Nevertheless, several states are positioning themselves for wind energy projects as the U.S. Interior Department asks about their interest. They include Massachusetts, New York and Oregon.
In addition, the technology is evolving quickly. In a recent development, Norwegian company Wind Catching Systems said it has developed a floating offshore wind power platform that looks like a wall of small generators instead of a single big one.
The floating Windcatcher stacks 126 small rotors on a 1,000-foot-high frame, which can produce electricity equivalent to 25 traditional wind turbines at about half the price, the company says on its website.
Tom can be reached at email@example.com.
In The News
WASHINGTON — Rep. Devin Nunes, R-Calif., will resign from Congress at the end of the month to become chief executive... Read More
WASHINGTON — Rep. Devin Nunes, R-Calif., will resign from Congress at the end of the month to become chief executive officer of former President Donald Trump’s fledgling social media entity, the company announced Monday. "Congressman Devin Nunes is a fighter and a leader,” said Trump, who... Read More
SAN ANTONIO — Researchers from the University of Colorado at Boulder found viewers’ consumption of Fox News was connected to... Read More
SAN ANTONIO — Researchers from the University of Colorado at Boulder found viewers’ consumption of Fox News was connected to lowered perceptions of election legitimacy while consumption of other outlets led to higher perceptions of election legitimacy. The study, published on Friday in the journal PLOS... Read More
WASHINGTON — The stopgap spending bill President Joe Biden signed last week keeps the federal government running but did nothing... Read More
WASHINGTON — The stopgap spending bill President Joe Biden signed last week keeps the federal government running but did nothing to resolve differences of opinion that are forcing Congress to extend its legislative session. It was supposed to end this week. The House already voted for... Read More
WASHINGTON — House and Senate Democrats on Monday raised their objections to the pending $43 billion merger of WarnerMedia and... Read More
WASHINGTON — House and Senate Democrats on Monday raised their objections to the pending $43 billion merger of WarnerMedia and Discovery, arguing it will hurt the Hollywood jobs market and squelch diversity in the entertainment workforce. In a letter sent Monday to Attorney General Merrick Garland... Read More
WASHINGTON — The Justice Department sued Texas on Monday over the state’s new redistricting plan, alleging it violated Section 2... Read More
WASHINGTON — The Justice Department sued Texas on Monday over the state’s new redistricting plan, alleging it violated Section 2 of the federal Voting Rights Act by diluting the Latino vote. “The attorney general has made clear that the Justice Department will not stand idly by... Read More
WASHINGTON – Democrats in Congress are waiting to see whether House Speaker Nancy Pelosi follows through on a reported promise... Read More
WASHINGTON – Democrats in Congress are waiting to see whether House Speaker Nancy Pelosi follows through on a reported promise of sanctions against a Republican congresswoman who made anti-Islamic statements about a political rival. Rep. Ilhan Omar, D-Minn., said Sunday that Pelosi made a “promise to... Read More