Committee for Responsible Federal Budget Estimates True Cost of Campaign Plans

October 12, 2020 by Kate Michael
The U.S. Capitol as seen from the national botanical garden fountain. (Photo by Dan McCue)

WASHINGTON — The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, an independent non-profit organization, released its anticipated report on the estimated costs of both Trump’s and Biden’s campaign plans last week. Not surprisingly, they are very expensive plans. 

Both candidates have ambitious proposals and policy priorities if elected, but fiscal challenges await the president regardless of who wins in the upcoming election, so CRFB dug through each proposal to determine its estimated true cost as well as its meaning for the ongoing fiscal health of the country.

Marc Goldwein, senior vice president of policy at CRFB, spearheads the organization’s U.S. Budget Watch 2020, which seeks to offer budgetary transparency and accountability in the presidential race. 

CRFB’s goal is to identify suggested legislative priorities based on the candidate’s campaign plans and promises. 

“We estimate what are ultimately relatively vague promises relative to the realities of legislation or even a president’s budget,” said Goldwein. “[We’re] culling through the websites of candidates and identifying anything that could possibly be a policy and trying to figure out what they mean, because often we get different levels of detail. And then, [we’re] looking for credible scores of either that… or a similar policy.”

Goldwein says ascertaining Biden’s proposals was fairly straightforward as he outlines 48 distinct plans on his website from which CRFB analysts were able to identify 800 policy proposals and examine their fiscal impact. 

Biden’s largest proposals involve expanding access and affordability to childcare and schooling, including universal pre-school, K-12 education, student loan forgiveness, and some free college. Health care is another large priority, expanding the Affordable Care Act and decreasing prescription drug costs. Biden wants to invest heavily in green infrastructure, including research and development, roads, bridges, and housing. He plans to increase Social Security and Supplemental Security Income (SSI) benefits. And to do all of this, he would increase taxes, especially for corporations, investors, and higher-income households. 

Aside from his annual budgets — which are not campaign promises — Trump’s proposals didn’t have the same level of detail. CRFB analysts were able to identify, however, a 54 point agenda for Trump’s second term as well as a “Platinum Plan” for Black Americans on Trump’s website that “gave clues as to what he was supporting,” according to Goldwein. 

Trump’s main proposals include cutting taxes for individuals and creating tax incentives for domestic investment and manufacturing. Increasing infrastructure spending is a large priority, as is decreasing drug costs. He wants to increase America’s investment in space travel, including the Space Force, Mission to Mars, and establishing a base on the moon. Trump’s larger proposals also increase funding for the military and veterans. 

While CRFB constructed low, central, and high estimates to account for various interpretations of the policies, Goldwein stressed that “the exact same policy could cost different amounts depending on how you estimate…. and how much benefit of the doubt you want to give.” 

The biggest spending for Biden, with CRFB’s central cost estimate, involves $2.7 trillion on childcare and education with $1.5 trillion of that used for loan forgiveness on higher education. His proposal for expanding Social Security and SSI would cost $1.1 trillion and would roughly double the current spending on SSI. 

Trump’s biggest spending under the same central cost estimate would involve $2 trillion more for infrastructure, $550 billion for national defense, and $650 billion dedicated to space.

Given that the United States’ debt just exceeded the size of the economy — debt is now 102% of GDP and is headed into a record high in the next term — the long term effects of both candidate’s plans are staggering. According to Goldwein, typical election cycles see spending proposals in the hundreds of billions, but both plans are “unusually large… [though they] come about it in very different ways.”

“The candidates [may be] intending to be budget neutral, but they are still raising the debt at record highs,” said Goldwein. “Both candidates would take the debt situation and make it worse.” 

Trump both spends a lot and cuts taxes. Biden, on the other hand, spends a lot more money but has more offsets, including a substantial increase in corporate and capital gains taxes. These cost estimates only include each candidate’s steady-state policies and do not include any COVID relief. 

According to CRFB’s central estimate, Trump’s campaign proposals would raise the country’s debt by an estimated $4.9 trillion, while Biden’s would raise it even higher by an estimated $5.6 trillion. Trump’s plan would cause the national debt to rise by 125% of GDP by 2030. Biden’s would force the debt even higher to 128% of GDP by 2030, rising a bit more slowly after that.

“These fellows are making a lot of promises that are very expensive if additional pay-fors are not mentioned,” said Goldwein. “Both candidates would worsen an already dismal fiscal situation.” 

In The News

Health

Voting

Political News

Maryland Enacts Sweeping Reforms to Make Police More Accountable
In The States
Maryland Enacts Sweeping Reforms to Make Police More Accountable
April 13, 2021
by Tom Ramstack

ANNAPOLIS, Md. - Maryland's General Assembly on Saturday enacted the nation’s most sweeping police reform legislation to make officers more accountable to the public. The new rules place more restrictions on use of force and no-knock warrants. Other provisions require body cameras and give civilians a... Read More

Congress to Honor 2nd Capitol Police Officer Slain This Year
Law Enforcement
Congress to Honor 2nd Capitol Police Officer Slain This Year

WASHINGTON (AP) — Slain U.S. Capitol Police Officer William "Billy" Evans will lie in honor in the Capitol Rotunda on Tuesday during the second such memorial ceremony this year for a force that has edged close to crisis in the wake of the Jan. 6 insurrection.President... Read More

Biden Aims for Bipartisanship But Applies Sly Pressure
White House
Biden Aims for Bipartisanship But Applies Sly Pressure

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden has begun publicly courting Republicans to back his sweeping infrastructure plan, but his reach across the aisle is intended just as much to keep Democrats in line as it is a first step in an uphill climb to any bipartisan... Read More

Biden Wants Infrastructure Deal, But GOP Doubts Persist
Congress
Biden Wants Infrastructure Deal, But GOP Doubts Persist

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden wants Congress to know he's sincere about cutting a deal on infrastructure, but Republican lawmakers have deep-seated doubts about the scope of his proposed package, its tax hikes and Biden's premise that this is an inflection point for the U.S.... Read More

U.S. Looks To Support Clean Infrastructure In India, Bangladesh
Geopolitics
U.S. Looks To Support Clean Infrastructure In India, Bangladesh
April 12, 2021
by Daniel Mollenkamp

Last week and over the weekend, U.S. Special Presidential Envoy for Climate John Kerry met with officials from the governments of India and Bangladesh to talk about strategies for improving climate resilience and adapting to climate change. Kerry emphasized recent U.S. aid projects to the two... Read More

Unintended Consequencs of Sex Trafficking Laws
Cybersecurity
Unintended Consequencs of Sex Trafficking Laws
April 12, 2021
by Victoria Turner

The two federal laws governing sex trafficking online have disproportionately harmed more sex workers than saved victims of human trafficking, said Danielle Borrelli, operations coordinator at the California Cybersecurity Institute, today at a Lincoln Network event moderated by Alexiaa Jordan.   Known and used collectively as SESTA-FOSTA,... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top