Would You Rather Burn Dollar Bills or Permit and Even Encourage Stock Buybacks? A Tax on Buybacks Is Not Grounded in Basic Corporate Finance
COMMENTARY

March 7, 2023by Jonathan F. Foster, Managing Director, Current Capital Partners LLC
Would You Rather Burn Dollar Bills or Permit and Even Encourage Stock Buybacks? A Tax on Buybacks Is Not Grounded in Basic Corporate Finance

From guns to masks and more, too many issues today have become politicized and are not addressed based on dispassionate facts and common sense. The current tax on stock buybacks and the talk of quadrupling it is yet another such issue — although certainly not one that is about life and death. But it is misguided and reflects a lack of understanding of simple corporate finance.

As part of the Inflation Reduction Act passed by Congress and signed into law by President Biden late last year, there is generally a 1% tax on the dollar amount of stock bought back by publicly traded companies. Now, there is talk of increasing this tax to 4%.

Some have argued that this tax helps to reduce a glitch in the tax system where dividends are taxable for many shareholders, but stock buybacks were typically not a taxable event for companies or shareholders (who do not sell their shares). On the other hand, the Business Roundtable has said that this tax will discourage investment and growth.

But much of the fuel for this part of the Inflation Reduction Act came from some loud voices claiming that, if companies did not use capital to buy back stock, they would use that liquidity to invest in their people and communities. For example, Sens. Ron Wyden, D-Ore., and Sherrod Brown, D-Ohio, introduced the Stock Buyback Accountability Act in September 2021. Wyden said, “Rather than investing in their workers, mega-corporations used the windfall from Republicans’ 2017 tax cuts to juice their stock prices and reward their wealthiest investors and their executives through massive stock buybacks.” Brown added that “instead of spending billions buying back stocks and handing out CEO bonuses, it’s past time Wall Street paid its fair share and reinvested more of that capital into the workers and communities who make those profits possible.”

A basic tenant of corporate finance is that a company should invest only if a given project has a return in excess of its weighted average cost of capital or WACC. This calculation is the blended cost of equity (typically calculated with the well known Capital Asset Pricing Model) and, for tax payers, the after tax cost of debt. Assume that a company has a 10% WACC. If a company invests in a project with an 8% expected return, it will not realize its cost of capital and is figuratively and almost literally “burning dollar bills.”

It is certainly not the case that well-governed and well-managed companies approve investments below their cost of capital. It is very much the case that well-governed and well-managed companies seek to maximize long-term shareholder value. Therefore, stock should be bought back with excess capital if such efforts are expected to increase earnings per share with acceptable pro forma leverage.

And it is simplistic and just wrong that, if companies with excess cash and debt capacity do not buy back stock, they will invest those monies in workers and communities. First, there are numerous companies that have bought back substantial stock and made major investments in their most valuable assets, employees and their communities. In addition, if a company has excess capital, does not buy back stock and believes that it has invested sufficiently in human capital and communities, it can simply keep that cash on its balance sheet or reduce debt.

Politicized decisions not based on dispassionate analysis are suspect. Much of the rationale for the tax on stock buybacks is just incorrect, and a tax on stock buybacks shows a lack of understanding of basic corporate finance.


Jonathan F. Foster is the founder and a managing director of Current Capital Partners LLC, a mergers and acquisitions advisory, corporate management services and private equity investment firm. Jon has over 30 years of experience as an advisor focused largely on industrial and services companies. He has also been on the boards of 40 companies. In addition, as an expert witness in major corporate litigation, Jon has filed numerous reports, as well as been deposed many times and testified in court about mergers and acquisitions, valuation and governance issues. You can reach Jon by email or on LinkedIn.

A+
a-

In The News

Health

Voting

Opinions

Empty Cruise Ships Another Absurd Result of 1886 Maritime Law

Cruise ships sailing empty? It’s a recipe for financial loss, and cruise operators avoid it whenever possible. But it does... Read More

Cruise ships sailing empty? It’s a recipe for financial loss, and cruise operators avoid it whenever possible. But it does happen.  As reported by Newsweek, it happened in May, when Royal Caribbean’s Adventure of the Seas sailed without guests from Galveston, Texas, to Fort Lauderdale, Florida, as part of... Read More

Four Ideas Worth Stealing in 2024

At this moment of chaos at the federal level, state and local leaders continue to step up to the plate... Read More

At this moment of chaos at the federal level, state and local leaders continue to step up to the plate to develop and implement bold, effective policy ideas. Whether it’s programs utilizing historic investments to boost economic development, supporting our democratic institutions or making it easier... Read More

Called Out — Reducing Risk in Youth Sports

Imagine you could do something to inexpensively protect thousands of kids and also safeguard sports, like football and baseball, which... Read More

Imagine you could do something to inexpensively protect thousands of kids and also safeguard sports, like football and baseball, which are part of the fabric of this nation. You would do it without hesitation … right?   The New York Times posted a video by Wyatt Bramwell, who was... Read More

The End of Smoking Begins With Better Choices

I’ve dedicated my entire career to improving public health for a simple reason: I lost my beloved grandparents to cancer... Read More

I’ve dedicated my entire career to improving public health for a simple reason: I lost my beloved grandparents to cancer and heart disease — both preventable illnesses that can be caused by smoking. I worked as a public health scientist for over 20 years at the... Read More

We Must Embrace America’s Welcoming History in This Difficult Moment

I’m Jewish. He’s Palestinian. We are both immigration lawyers. And while we come from markedly different cultures and religions, we... Read More

I’m Jewish. He’s Palestinian. We are both immigration lawyers. And while we come from markedly different cultures and religions, we have the same core values and beliefs. We are also both Americans and proud of our nation’s history of providing refuge to so many for 247 years.... Read More

What Americans Really Want From Government 

A new poll from Gallup shows that a majority of Americans think the government is trying to do too many things that... Read More

A new poll from Gallup shows that a majority of Americans think the government is trying to do too many things that should be left to individuals and businesses. What’s more, except for one brief point of time during the COVID-19 pandemic, Gallup’s data shows this has been... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top