We Promised My Grandparents Never Again.

September 15, 2018 by Nathan Kasai
Source: Third Way

After widespread and unwavering backlash, President Trump tried to control the fallout from his self-created family separation crisis, signing an executive order that claims to keep asylum-seeking families together. But the President’s executive order simply trades one cruel policy for another. Instead of taking children from their parents, it imprisons families in twenty-first century internment camps — something we, as a nation, promised my grandparents we would never tolerate again.

Seventy-six years ago, the government sent my grandparents to prison camps despairingly similar to the ones families fleeing violence will be sent to under Trump’s new policy. Japanese Americans are painfully aware of the lasting damage these camps will inflict. We have the family memories to know exactly what this will do.

The camps were brutally traumatic for my grandparents. So much so that my grandfather never spoke about his time in them. He was just a teenager when his father was taken and jailed separately in a different camp because of his stature in the Japanese-American community. Returning to those memories was simply too painful.

She told me how she feared there would never be a place for her in this country if she was released.

My grandmother, though, was determined that I would know our history so that we would not sit by if the government repeated its past outrages. She told me how her heart sank when she first walked into her barrack that housed three other families and had no walls for privacy between them. She told me how she grew up behind barbed wire, playing under the constant watch of armed soldiers. She told me how she feared there would never be a place for her in this country if she was released. She told me how she couldn’t understand why a country built on the ideals of liberty and equality would categorically imprison families.

Hearing these stories, it seemed preposterous to think that the United States could ever repeat the injustices inflicted on our family. Those were the injustices of past generations, not mine. It seemed we had learned that some tactics were too brutal to be utilized again in America.

But here we are.

Today, families presenting good faith asylum claims, who are following the law and the prescribed process to petition for that status, are facing the same widespread and prolonged captivity my then-teenage grandparents did.

Families asking our country for protection from imminent danger in their home country are more than willing to follow the rules.

Just like when my grandparents were imprisoned, the President claims he has no choice. But there is always a choice. Before June 2017, the government placed asylum-seeking families into the Family Case Management Program — monitoring them closely, but allowing them to live outside of detention facilities. And despite the President’s claim this created a “catch and release” system, it worked exceptionally well until he ended it. The government’s own records show that over 99% of participants appeared at their immigration court hearings. Families asking our country for protection from imminent danger in their home country are more than willing to follow the rules. No matter how many times President Trump, Homeland Security Secretary Nielson, and Attorney General Sessions lie and claim that they have no choice, it will never be true.

We’ve turned our back on compassion and decency before. We’re doing it again. If my grandparents were alive now, they would be horrified to see what their country is becoming. Then they’d stand up and fight back.

Families belong together, and not in prisons.

Opinions

Commentary | Energy Was On The Ballot This November
Opinions
Commentary | Energy Was On The Ballot This November

Two years ago, Democrats won back control of the U.S. House by nominating largely moderate candidates in swing districts who ignored litmus test issues like the Green New Deal and refused to be defined by extreme economic and energy policies like bans on fracking.  Two years... Read More

Abolish Electoral College? Sure, and Why Not Let ‘Majority Rule’ on the Bill of Rights?
Opinions
Abolish Electoral College? Sure, and Why Not Let ‘Majority Rule’ on the Bill of Rights?
November 18, 2020
by John Kass

When we were kids on the playground and there was an angry dispute, someone would always shout “majority rules.” And we’d vote. If the losers didn’t like the outcome, there were two options: punch the winners in the stomach or take the ball and go home.... Read More

Now More Than Ever We Need Science, Not Politics
Opinions
Now More Than Ever We Need Science, Not Politics

The global COVID-19 pandemic, with all its devastating consequences, has reaffirmed why science must be at the center of policy considerations, political debate, and media attention. But, lamentably, it is often at the center for all the wrong reasons. Against a backdrop of growing tensions and... Read More

Can Biden Heal America When Trump and His Allies Don’t Want It Healed?
Opinions
Can Biden Heal America When Trump and His Allies Don’t Want It Healed?
November 9, 2020
by Robert B. Reich

In case you missed the news, Joe Biden was elected president of the United States. With almost all ballots counted, Biden has more than 75 million votes and Trump some 71 million. The Electoral College isn’t even close. But Donald Trump still has not conceded, and... Read More

The Election of 2020 Has Ended at Last
Opinions
The Election of 2020 Has Ended at Last
November 7, 2020
by Leonard Pitts

Forgive me for being the ant at the picnic. Certainly, this is a glad moment, an ecstatic and delirious moment. The election of 2020 has ended at last. Joe Biden is finally the president-elect and Donald Trump is finally consigned to the dank well of ignominy... Read More

Make America Big Again
Opinions
Make America Big Again
November 7, 2020
by Make America Big Again

Fans of Donald Trump typically say, “I wish he wouldn’t tweet so much, but I like his policies.” As you peel back more layers of the onion, they really mean they like his tax cuts and conservative appointments to the federal judiciary, but wish they didn’t... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top