Voters Largely Satisfied With Both DeSantis and Whitmer, Despite Stark Policy Differences
COMMENTARY

May 15, 2023by Erin Norman, Senior Messaging Strategist, State Policy Network
Voters Largely Satisfied With Both DeSantis and Whitmer, Despite Stark Policy Differences

Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis recently headed to Michigan for a few speaking engagements that informally confirmed his intention to run for president in 2024. The governor of the once-swing-now-red Florida brings a stark contrast to Michigan’s Democratic Gov. Gretchen Whitmer and her newly minted blue trifecta. 

On every major issue of the day, Florida and Michigan have taken opposite approaches. One-thousand miles away on the same day in April, Whitmer signed a bill repealing Michigan’s 1931 abortion ban while Florida passed a DeSantis-backed bill that bans abortion after six weeks. In Michigan, Whitmer signed an 11-bill gun control plan while DeSantis recently enacted a law that allows concealed carry without a permit in Florida. Michigan recently made headlines by being the first state to repeal a right-to-work law since 1965 while in Florida DeSantis passed a law that would prohibit public employers from directly deducting union dues, instead making union members arrange dues payments on their own.

It seems that the vastly different approaches are serving both governors well. Recent Morning Consult polling shows that Whitmer and DeSantis have identical approval ratings of 56%, significantly beating President Biden’s 43% rating. Both governors won their 2022 reelections with considerable room to spare and, for whatever it’s worth, both draw the ire of former President Donald Trump. 

The similarities of political outcomes for the two states match economic markers. Florida is ranked the fourth-most business friendly state and Michigan the 12th by the Tax Foundation, a relative positioning confirmed by CNBC’s 2022 rankings. The median income in both states is within a few hundred dollars. The total state and local tax burden is 8.6% for Michigan and 9.1% for Florida, ranked fifth and 11th, respectively. 

How can two states with such wildly different governors and approaches to public policy end up at approximately the same place? Each state is governed by officials who are ultimately held accountable to meeting the needs and value expectations of their specific population. The structure of American government — that gives states the flexibility to be responsive specifically to its citizens — is how vastly different approaches can lead to the same level of satisfaction.

The majority of Americans agree with this structure. According to a recent State Policy Network State Voices poll, 59% of Americans, a two-to-one-margin, think states should be able to make laws that reflect the different values, priorities and needs of their people instead of having one set of laws for everyone across the nation. Furthermore, State Policy Network’s polling shows that 61% believe state and local politicians, rather than national ones, are more focused on getting things done, indicating people think it’s not just preferable but also more successful. 

There is a push from both parties to federalize issues that can and traditionally have been handled at the state level. Moving to a one-size-fits-all approach to governing our vast and diverse nation will only serve to increase political divisiveness and destabilize the country. The ability for each state to be able to set their own laws, and not have to come to a full national consensus on every issue, is a benefit, not a drawback, of the American system of government. 

Perhaps on his trip through Michigan, DeSantis won over enough voters in the blue-leaning state to ultimately secure a presidential win. Whether it’s DeSantis or someone else sitting in the White House in January 2025, the president, and the federal government, must continue to respect the state autonomy that leaves Michigan and Florida voters largely satisfied with vastly different policies.


Erin Norman is the Lee Family fellow and the senior messaging strategist at State Policy Network. You can reach State Policy Network on Twitter.

A+
a-

In The News

Health

Voting

Opinions

Poor Guidance From Influential Math Educators Is Impairing Students

Could it be that the nation’s large fraction of students lacking math proficiency is caused by significant numbers of students not having... Read More

Could it be that the nation’s large fraction of students lacking math proficiency is caused by significant numbers of students not having their multiplication tables memorized? In a California K-12 district with 15% of students proficient in math, according to state testing, only about 25% of fourth graders were found to have... Read More

Choose Wisely: Medicaid Cuts Could Cripple Trump’s America First Agenda

In Washington, D.C., there is one rule you can count on: nothing is ever as it seems. The mirage of... Read More

In Washington, D.C., there is one rule you can count on: nothing is ever as it seems. The mirage of smoke and mirrors provides the ambiance, but not the needed reflection. The current debate over cutting Medicaid is no different. It’s not just a budget fight... Read More

Reform Supplemental Oxygen for Chronically Ill Patients

For the 1.5 million Americans living with chronic lung and heart disease and other respiratory conditions, supplemental oxygen is not... Read More

For the 1.5 million Americans living with chronic lung and heart disease and other respiratory conditions, supplemental oxygen is not a luxury or something that would be nice to have — it is a literal lifeline. Supplemental oxygen allows patients to live more active, independent lives... Read More

Hartford Has a Solution to the Student Debt Crisis

America is facing a student debt crisis. Over the past 50 years, college tuition has tripled and over the past... Read More

America is facing a student debt crisis. Over the past 50 years, college tuition has tripled and over the past two decades student loan debt has doubled — creating an economic storm that is stifling our nation’s economic growth.  This storm is only intensifying and may... Read More

Mandating ‘Preventive Services’ Not What the Doctor Ordered

The Affordable Care Act, aka Obamacare, has been anything but affordable. Despite all the talk about “bending the cost curve,”... Read More

The Affordable Care Act, aka Obamacare, has been anything but affordable. Despite all the talk about “bending the cost curve,” benefit costs have far outpaced inflation since the 2010s and national annual health care spending is now an astounding $5 trillion. The good news is that the Supreme Court... Read More

Trump’s Crackdown on China Should Include Illegal Vapes

While tariffs and deportations share a spot at the top of headlines and Americans’ minds at the moment, for the... Read More

While tariffs and deportations share a spot at the top of headlines and Americans’ minds at the moment, for the last few years our children and small businesses have been facing a serious and, in some cases, deadly threat that has yet to receive the attention... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top