Under Risk Rating 2.0, High-Income Communities Finally Pay Their Fair Share
COMMENTARY

June 14, 2022 by Steve Pociask
Under Risk Rating 2.0, High-Income Communities Finally Pay Their Fair Share
Palm Bay officer Dustin Terkoski walks over debris from a two-story home at Palm Point Subdivision in Brevard County after a tornado touched down on Sunday, Sept. 10, 2017. A year after Irma, tens of thousands of Floridians are still waiting on money from insurance to fix their homes. (Red Huber, Orlando Sentinel/TNS)

Low-income neighborhoods face long roads to recovery as they are often disproportionately affected by natural disasters like hurricanes and flooding. Yet, instead of paying an equitable amount for the coverage they need, they continue to subsidize flood insurance for affluent, coastal communities. However, implementing a new FEMA flood pricing methodology, referred to as Risk Rating 2.0, will correct a longstanding inequality in insurance premiums by more closely aligning flood insurance pricing to risk.

Before Risk Rating 2.0 was Risk Rating 1.0 which intended to make rates fairer and more equitable. Unfortunately, it resulted in billions in accumulated debt and inadequate efforts to match expenses from flooding, especially as costs continued to increase. 

Highlighting FEMA’s priority of a “culture of preparedness,” Risk Rating 2.0 is the agency’s first line of defense. The new methodology allows FEMA to course-correct after identifying the prior program’s inequities and prioritize mitigation to reduce longer-term risks from future disasters. It also enables equitable increases and decreases in insurance rates that reflect a household’s risk level and property value more accurately while giving consumers the protection they need against storms.

Risk Rating 2.0 addresses the longstanding systemic pricing issues to root out financial inequalities while accurately adjusting flood risk as it relates to the property values of the 5 million National Flood Insurance Program policyholders. Higher-income communities will finally pay their fair share, thereby relieving some policyholders in lower-income communities from the burden of paying more than they should.

After 50 years of unequal NFIP rating estimates and Risk Rating 1.0’s inability to provide an equitable solution, low-value properties will be far less likely to subsidize high-value properties under Risk Rating 2.0. With the new methodology taking into account more risk variables and rating each home individually, these lower-value properties will see decreases in their overall insurance cost. In stark difference from its predecessor Risk Rating 2.0 will halt increases when a property reaches its full-risk rate.

High-risk properties, including many in high-income communities with multi-million-dollar beachfront homes, will now be responsible for paying insurance rates that reflect their risk. These are the property owners that have not paid their part of the bill in a long time and Risk Rating 2.0 will put an end to this inequitable cycle.

With an emphasis on property-specific risk, property buyers can enter into their financial transactions with complete insurance transparency and trust in the corrected system.

Through Risk Rating 2.0, FEMA will level the playing field that has long favored wealthy policyholders over others and end a form of welfare for the rich. After years of imbalance, prioritizing affordability and creating deterrents from building in high-risk zones will lead to more effectively and equitably insured communities. 

As climate change drastically worsens natural disasters and the scars they leave across our country, we must prioritize programs and policies like Risk Rating 2.0 that help us establish a more resilient and just system for American consumers. Risk Rating 2.0 will allow us to focus on the critical issues following a disaster: ensuring the safety and security of the communities affected. 


Steve Pociask is president and CEO of the American Consumer Institute, a nonprofit education and research organization. Follow ACI on Twitter @ConsumerPal.


A+
a-

In The News

Health

Voting

Opinions

The Greatest Threat to America’s Health Care System? Administrative Red Tape.

America is at the crossroads of a medical crisis. The nursing shortage continues to plague health care systems across the... Read More

America is at the crossroads of a medical crisis. The nursing shortage continues to plague health care systems across the country, but legislators have done little to support rehabilitating the sector. As critical gaps in care rapidly devolve into deep fissures felt throughout the industry at... Read More

Congress Has the Power — and a Responsibility — to Pass Legislation to Halt Dangerous Cuts to Medicare 

It will not come as a surprise to most Americans that our health care system is in crisis. We all... Read More

It will not come as a surprise to most Americans that our health care system is in crisis. We all have a loved one who waited months for an important appointment or traveled hours to receive specialized medical care. Maybe you’ve even faced such challenges yourself.... Read More

Protecting Access to Hospitals Is Crucial for Rural America

Maternal health care in rural America is in crisis. Declining birth rates and shrinking populations have played a role, but this crisis... Read More

Maternal health care in rural America is in crisis. Declining birth rates and shrinking populations have played a role, but this crisis is more acute now than ever because of widespread hospital closures in rural areas. On top of that, the dozens of maternity ward closures happening across the country have... Read More

The United Auto Workers Strike — Why Not Collaborate to Benefit All Parties?

The United Auto Workers strike is rightly front page news, as this major action involves the livelihoods of some 400,000... Read More

The United Auto Workers strike is rightly front page news, as this major action involves the livelihoods of some 400,000 families, threatens a major industry and could have a real impact on the fledgling economic recovery. Pro- or anti-union, Democrat or Republican, it is only logical... Read More

As Boomers Retire, Minority Entrepreneurs Can Aspire

America is on the brink of a great wealth transfer. As Baby Boomers enter retirement, their shift of fortune could... Read More

America is on the brink of a great wealth transfer. As Baby Boomers enter retirement, their shift of fortune could be monumental for one often-overlooked group: minority entrepreneurs. Over half of America’s business owners are 55 or older, with 40% of small-business owners also poised to exit the... Read More

Celebrate Today, Protect Tomorrow — Showcasing Bristol Bay’s Wild Sockeye Salmon Resource in the District

Over the coming weeks Alaska Natives, commercial fishermen, business leaders, sport lodge owners and others connected to Bristol Bay, Alaska,... Read More

Over the coming weeks Alaska Natives, commercial fishermen, business leaders, sport lodge owners and others connected to Bristol Bay, Alaska, are coming to Washington to celebrate the incredible wild sockeye salmon resource that sustains the region and feeds the world. They are in D.C. for the... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top