The three big lessons we didn’t learn from the economic crisis
Ten years ago, after making piles of money gambling with other people’s money, Wall Street nearly imploded, and the outgoing George W. Bush and incoming Obama administrations bailed out the bankers.
America should have learned three big lessons from the crisis. We didn’t, to our continuing peril.
First unlearned lesson: Banking is a risky business with huge upsides for the few who gamble in it, but bigger downsides for the public when those bets go bad.
Which means that safeguards are necessary. The safeguards created after Wall Street’s 1929 crash worked for more than four decades. They made banking boring.
But starting in the 1980s, they were watered down or repealed because of Wall Street’s increasing thirst for profits and its growing political clout. As politicians from both parties grew dependent on the Street for campaign funding, the rush to deregulate turned into a stampede.
It began in 1982, when Congress and the Reagan administration deregulated savings and loan banks, allowing them to engage in risky commercial lending while continuing to guarantee them against major losses. Not surprisingly, the banks got into big trouble, necessitating a taxpayer-funded bailout.
The next milestone came in 1999, when Congress and the Clinton administration, under then-Treasury Secretary Robert Rubin, repealed the Glass-Steagall Act, a 1930s safeguard that had prohibited banks from gambling with commercial deposits. (For the record, I was no longer in the Cabinet.)
Then, in 2000, Congress and Clinton barred the Commodity Futures Trading Commission from regulating most over-the-counter derivative contracts, including credit default swaps.
The coup de grace came in 2004, when George W. Bush’s Securities and Exchange Commission allowed investment banks to hold less capital in reserve.
All of this ushered in the 2008 near-meltdown — which was followed by another attempt to impose safeguards, the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010.
And now? The Street’s political clout is as great as ever, which explains why the Dodd-Frank safeguards are now being watered down, clearing the way for another crisis.
The second lesson we should have learned but didn’t is how widening inequality makes our economy susceptible to financial disaster.
In the decades leading up to 2008, stagnant wages caused many Americans to go deep into debt — and they used the rising values of their homes as collateral. Much the same thing had happened in the years leading up to 1929.
Wall Street banks were delighted to accommodate — lending willy-nilly and often in predatory ways — until the housing and debt bubbles burst.
And now? The underlying problem of stagnant wages, with most economic gains going to the top, is still with us. Once again, consumers are deep in debt, inviting another crisis.
The third big lesson we didn’t learn concerned the rigging of American politics. After the crisis, many Americans realized that Wall Street, big corporations and the wealthy had essentially bought up our democracy.
Americans saw the Street get bailed out while homeowners, suddenly owing more on their homes than the homes were worth, got little or nothing.
Millions lost their jobs, savings, pensions and homes, but the bankers and big investors came out richer than before.
Bankers who committed serious fraud escaped accountability. No executive went to jail. Big banks such as Wells Fargo continued to break laws with impunity.
Many officials involved in deregulating the Street became top executives in the Wall Street banks that benefited from deregulation. Some involved in writing the Dodd-Frank Act are now employed by the same financial institutions that are watering it down.
Meanwhile, big corporations and wealthy individuals continue to flood Washington with money, making it the capital of “crony capitalism.”
Widespread outrage at all this fueled the tea party on the right and the brief “Occupy” movement on the left. Both eventually morphed into the two anti-establishment candidacies of 2016 — authoritarian populist Donald Trump and democratic populist Bernie Sanders.
And now? Anti-establishment fury remains the strongest force in American politics.
Trump has been using it to conjure up racist and xenophobic conspiracies and to create the most authoritarian regime in modern American history. He promised to “drain the swamp” but has made it bigger and filthier.
Democrats don’t know whether to simply oppose Trump and his authoritarianism or get behind a reform agenda to wrest control of politics and the economy from the moneyed interests.
But to do the latter, they’d have to take on those that have funded them for decades. I wish I had more confidence they will.
Sad to say, 10 years after the near-meltdown of Wall Street, we seem to have learned very little. Only worse: We now have Trump.
Robert Reich’s latest book is “The Common Good,” and his newest documentary is “Saving Capitalism.”
(c) 2018 By Robert Reich; Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC
In The News
Since President Biden announced his preference for South Carolina to be the first Democratic presidential primary state, many have put... Read More
Since President Biden announced his preference for South Carolina to be the first Democratic presidential primary state, many have put in their two cents on the matter. As the South Carolina state director for Beto O’Rourke’s 2020 presidential campaign, I’m proud to have joined a group... Read More
Republican efforts to punish corporations for social advocacy are hypocritical and go against what voters want. "Go woke. Go broke." ... Read More
Republican efforts to punish corporations for social advocacy are hypocritical and go against what voters want. "Go woke. Go broke." Tweets and statements like this from Rep. Jim Jordan, R-Ohio, and other Republican policymakers send a clear message, that Republicans in Congress are deeply opposed to corporations speaking out... Read More
In the six months since the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in the Castro-Huerta case, the majority opinion has been universally... Read More
In the six months since the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in the Castro-Huerta case, the majority opinion has been universally condemned by leading Indian Country legal scholars. It has been described as an unconstitutional “act of conquest” that flips 200 years of federal Indian law on... Read More
This past November, Democrats defied political gravity to hold on to the Senate and minimize losses in the House. The... Read More
This past November, Democrats defied political gravity to hold on to the Senate and minimize losses in the House. The message from voters was clear: Despite deep economic anxieties, most Americans believe that the Biden administration has a chance to overcome political division and do right... Read More
Every holiday season the cost of travel, gifts and meals add up fast, forcing many people to stretch their budgets... Read More
Every holiday season the cost of travel, gifts and meals add up fast, forcing many people to stretch their budgets to close out the year. The skyrocketing price of everything from turkey to toys means this year Americans are feeling an even bigger pinch, and many... Read More
Rare diseases are, by definition, uncommon. For a disease to qualify as rare, it must affect fewer than 200,000 Americans... Read More
Rare diseases are, by definition, uncommon. For a disease to qualify as rare, it must affect fewer than 200,000 Americans — or less than .06% of the U.S. population. While the odds of being diagnosed with any individual rare disease are low, the universe of rare... Read More