NFIP Is the Anti-Robin Hood of Disaster Relief
COMMENTARY

April 10, 2020 by Steve Pociask
NFIP Is the Anti-Robin Hood of Disaster Relief
New York Urban Search and Rescue team members evaluate a flooded section of Bragg Boulevard in Spring Lake, N.C., Tuesday Sept. 18, 2018. (Julia Wall/Raleigh News & Observer/TNS)

Floods are America’s most common natural disaster,
causing millions of dollars of damage each year. To protect consumers, FEMA’s National
Flood Insurance Program (NFIP)
provides coverage for over 5 million policyholders.
But analysis of recently released FEMA data shows that the taxpayer-funded
program first and foremost bails out wealthy homeowners. Given that the program
is already saddled with tens of billions of dollars’ worth of debt, it’s time to relieve
taxpayers of this disaster.

According to recent analysis by Hazard Hub, among NFIP policyholders who made
claims, the wealthiest 30% made almost half of the claims between 2010 and 2018.
Put in other words—the richer you are, the more claims you’re likely to file. High
income households were also found to pay on average a lower premium than their middle-
and low-income counterparts. Moreover, following the passage of the 2015 Homeowner Flood Insurance Affordability Act, low-income household premiums have
flatlined while those of high income home-owners have fallen significantly.

If premiums were to truly reflect the risk of
flooding, climate change and rising sea levels will very likely result in even higher
premiums—particularly harming low-income residents who can’t simply abandon their communities. This affordability challenge sits in
stark contrast to the wealthy homeowners who make prolific claims through the NFIP, with the knowledge that the public
piggybank will pick up the tab if and when things go awry.

This moral hazard is made all the more egregious by
the fact that it is subsidized by the length and breadth of American taxpayers.
To slash this gilded welfare, high income earners should be ineligible for NFIP-backed
plans. Much like the rationale behind Medicaid, federal tax dollars should be a
last resort only for those who truly need it.

Similarly, stricter mitigation rules would pare down
the number of repeat claimants. While access to the NFIP is conditional on
communities taking precautionary measures in floodplains, these rules don’t go far
enough. New and reconstructed homes in high flood risk areas should be built to
resist the commensurate weather damage they expect to face. While construction
mandates can adversely impact housing affordability, taxpayers simply cannot be
expected to foot the bill when homeowners choose to ignore the risks build in
precarious locations.

These policies could all be matched with land zoning
reform to give consumers choice and mobility. It is unsurprising that house
location and neighborhood play a significant defining role in access to
services, employment, and upward economic mobility. But high residential prices, fostered in
part by onerous land regulation, lock countless Americans out of productive economic areas. For
consumers who want to leave areas that are prone to flooding, a similar
scenario occurs. Slashing zoning regulations in low-risk areas allows consumers
to live where they want, without being kept under the shadow of perpetual
flooding and with a reliance on the NFIP.

With over $20 billion worth of debt, and in the face of rising sea levels, it
is clear that the current National Flood Insurance Program is unsustainable.
Shifting high-income households off publicly-backed plans and into the private
market is a clear first step to ending this welfare for the rich. Similarly,
mitigation and mobility policies will be key to managing flood risk in the
future.

A+
a-

In The News

Health

Voting

Opinions

Cuomo for NYC Mayor Isn’t a Given

As New York Democrats vied on stage recently to be the next mayor of America’s largest city, former Gov. Andrew Cuomo bore the... Read More

As New York Democrats vied on stage recently to be the next mayor of America’s largest city, former Gov. Andrew Cuomo bore the brunt of attacks by the other hopefuls. He had a target on his back for raising the most funds out of all the Democratic candidates, leading most conducted polls by double-digits, and amassing the... Read More

Keep HSAs in the One Big, Beautiful Bill

Last month, House Republicans narrowly passed a comprehensive budget bill by a single vote, legislation that included some of the most significant... Read More

Last month, House Republicans narrowly passed a comprehensive budget bill by a single vote, legislation that included some of the most significant changes to our health care system in over a decade. The Senate has promised to amend this "One Big, Beautiful Bill Act." One thing they shouldn’t... Read More

‘Most Favored Nation’ Drug Pricing Wouldn't Actually Save Medicaid Money

Congressional Republicans recently advanced a sweeping budget bill that exceeds their initial savings goal, aiming to reduce federal spending by... Read More

Congressional Republicans recently advanced a sweeping budget bill that exceeds their initial savings goal, aiming to reduce federal spending by nearly $1 trillion. A large share of those reductions would come from changes to Medicaid, including new work requirements, copay adjustments and stricter eligibility checks. During... Read More

Public Universities Remain America's Best Investment — and They’re More Affordable Than You Think

“Colleges aren’t turning out the right kind of student[s].” That was the take offered by Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg in a recent... Read More

“Colleges aren’t turning out the right kind of student[s].” That was the take offered by Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg in a recent podcast appearance, where one of the leading voices in the tech industry echoed an argument we're hearing far too often: college is no longer an investment... Read More

June 4, 2025
by Andres Ramirez
Ballot Access: Federal and State Efforts on Voting Rights

The current debate over proof-of-citizenship and other voting restrictions is the latest chapter in a long history of battles over... Read More

The current debate over proof-of-citizenship and other voting restrictions is the latest chapter in a long history of battles over access to the ballot in America. For decades, the Voting Rights Act of 1965 provided robust federal protections against discriminatory voting laws, especially in states with... Read More

Health Care Needs a New Pot of Money

The United States has the worst-performing health care system despite spending the most on health care among nine other high-income nations. Americans,... Read More

The United States has the worst-performing health care system despite spending the most on health care among nine other high-income nations. Americans, especially in rural communities, have lower life expectancy, higher prevalence of chronic disease, dismal maternal mortality outcomes, significant mental health challenges, and growing obesity rates.  The health of Americans is declining, but we can... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top