Josh Hawley Blind to Irony
COMMENTARY

January 31, 2021 by Leonard Pitts
Sen. Josh Hawley, R-Mo., asks questions during a Senate Homeland Security & Governmental Affairs Committee hearing to discuss election security and the 2020 election process on Dec. 16. Hawley's approval ratings have dropped in Missouri since the Jan. 6 Capitol riots. (Greg Nash/Abaca Press/TNS)

So last week, Sen. Josh Hawley complained that he was being “silenced.” He lodged this complaint on Fox “News” and in The New York Post.

As social media observers promptly pointed out, that’s a level of media exposure that effectively refutes the senator’s claim. But Hawley is in a snit because Simon & Schuster backed out of a contract to publish his book, and the Loews hotel chain declined to host one of his fundraisers after he encouraged protesters who rioted in the U.S. Capitol. Apparently, that’s left him blind to irony.

In the Post piece, he compared his experience to something out of communist China and declared himself a victim of “cancel culture.” Well beg pardon, but “cancel culture” — like the War on Christmas — is little more than a chimerical boogeyman created to frighten and appall. Truth is, there ain’t no such thing.

That declaration will affront those who consider cancel culture an outrage against free speech. They’ll point to James Gunn; the director was fired from a movie (he was later rehired) after offensive tweets surfaced. They’ll point to Shane Gillis; the comedian lost a job on “Saturday Night Live” after racist comments he made about Asians came to light. They’ll point to Mike Lindell; the My Pillow guy‘s product was pulled by major retailers after he voiced support for baseless conspiracy theories about the 2020 election. And they will point to Donald Trump; he lost his Twitter account for being, well . . . Donald Trump.

The argument goes that censorious liberals are offending free speech by shaming and ostracizing those who breach social or political orthodoxy. Tellingly, this claim against liberals is sometimes made by liberals, as well as by conservatives. But it collides with the same obvious paradox either way.

To wit: None of this affronts free speech. To the contrary, it is free speech, people and corporations using their influence and the withdrawal of their cooperation or economic support to make statements. That was the story of the 1955 Montgomery Bus Boycott. For that matter, it was the story of the 1997 boycott of The Walt Disney Company by conservative church groups after Disney extended employee benefits to same-sex domestic partners.

Nor is it immaterial that the one succeeded after a year while the other failed after eight. Ultimately, what we’re talking about is the free market — of economics and of ideas — at work, however imperfectly. The market will bear what the market will bear.

Make no mistake: There is a debate to be had here. Multiple debates, actually. Have we become too peevishly sensitive? Are we too quick to weaponize outrage? Have social media made it too easy to dial up a virtual lynch mob? Should there be a statute of limitations on punishment for stupid stuff you said or did way back when? But the baseline of that debate cannot be some misguided notion that it is wrong simply to censure that which offends. And on this subject a pundit may claim special insight.

To be a columnist, after all, is to have always just offended someone. Frequently, that someone will present the offense to an editor and demand the scoundrel be given the boot. Occasionally, the editor will comply, a decision that reduces both the columnist’s reach and his bank account. To be sure, this doesn’t make him happy.

But it also doesn’t make him a victim — at least, not of any force more nefarious than supply and demand. The market giveth and the market taketh away. Yes, freedom of speech is a constitutional right.

To have a platform, however, is a privilege.

©2021 Miami Herald. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

In The News

Health

Voting

Opinions

Becerra Confirmation Crucial to Addressing Health Inequities Deepened by the COVID-19 Pandemic
Opinions
Becerra Confirmation Crucial to Addressing Health Inequities Deepened by the COVID-19 Pandemic

The fight against the COVID-19 pandemic has become more complicated, despite the breakneck speed of vaccine development. The country is facing the dual challenges of combating the spread of new variants of the virus while coordinating a nationwide vaccination effort. The need for strong health care... Read More

How to Spot the Moderate
Opinions
How to Spot the Moderate
February 20, 2021
by How to Spot the Moderate

Can you spot the moderate? Ok, not Joe Manchin. That’s too easy. Spot the other one. You found her! Rep. Sharice Davids, the first congressional Democrat from Kansas in a decade was recently re-elected to her second term. A former mixed martial artist and lawyer, she... Read More

Stop Protecting Big Banks: End the War on Cryptocurrencies
Opinions
Stop Protecting Big Banks: End the War on Cryptocurrencies

On the day President Joe Biden was sworn into office, he ordered a freeze on the blizzard of last-minute rules that the Trump Administration tried to ram through in its final days. They were a grab bag of favors to Republican special interests and big business... Read More

Macron is Becoming Everything Trump Should Have Been
Opinions
Macron is Becoming Everything Trump Should Have Been
February 16, 2021
by Rachel Marsden

The gatekeepers of the establishment status quo don’t have Donald Trump to kick around anymore. Except that Trump’s voters — more than 74 million of them — aren’t going anywhere. These are people who chose Trump despite all of the daily shenanigans, tweets and drama, and... Read More

Trump is History; it’s Biden who’s Changing America
Opinions
Trump is History; it’s Biden who’s Changing America
February 15, 2021
by Robert B. Reich

While most of official Washington has been consumed with the Senate impeachment trial, another part of Washington is preparing the most far-ranging changes in American social policy in a generation. Congress is moving ahead with President Joe Biden’s American Rescue Plan, which expands health care and... Read More

Vaccine Education is the Key to Saving Our Communities
Opinions
Vaccine Education is the Key to Saving Our Communities

All eyes are on the vaccine rollout. We’ve all observed the challenges our government has faced supplying and distributing vaccines, as well as some of the early learnings. It would be easy to point fingers or poke holes in the perceived lack of progress. We could... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top