Hospitals: As We Fight COVID-19, Drop the Lawsuits Stop Suing the Government, Taxpayers, and Patients
COMMENTARY

April 21, 2020 by Cynthia Fisher
Hospitals: As We Fight COVID-19, Drop the Lawsuits Stop Suing the Government, Taxpayers, and Patients

A recent survey found 91 percent of Americans want healthcare price transparency – and support that hospitals and healthcare facilities be required to publicly disclose the prices of their services.

Hospitals – which, in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, have already received more than $100 billion in stimulus funds – do not want to comply with any transparency rules. In fact, when the Trump administration announced that it would be requiring hospitals to reveal their negotiated rates by January 2021, hospitals responded with a lawsuit.

The American Hospital Association and its allies went as far as to argue that being required to disclose their private negotiations with insurers is a violation of their First Amendment Rights.

As lawmakers discuss the next round of stimulus funding, hospitals are back in line with their hands out – seeking another $75 billion more of taxpayer money.

Here’s a thought: Hospitals should stop suing the government – and, thereby, American taxpayers. Instead, these entities should step up to the plate and post real cash prices, as well as negotiated rates, online.

This transparency would support greater accountability, enhance patient care, and cut waste.

In the last four weeks, 22 million Americans have filed for unemployment benefits.

Hardworking taxpayers – perhaps now more than ever – need hospitals to behave like the compassionate, ethical institutions they profess to be. As the coronavirus pandemic ravages families and industries alike, it is time for hospitals to drop the lawsuit against the same government that is bailing them out.

Furthermore, they should put a moratorium on medical collections.

Our nation’s leaders must mitigate the cost of this virus. It is the consumers of healthcare – patients, American taxpayers, workers, and businesses – who pay for coverage and treatment. When armed with real prices, consumers are empowered to smartly shop for the best quality care at the lowest possible price.

Ultimately, Americans trust that this transparency – which would allow them to shop in a competitive market – will drive down the cost of care.

Sans transparency, price-gouging, overcharging, waste, and even fraud will run rampant. Along with mitigating cost, transparency will also help restore trust in the U.S. healthcare system.

According to a pre-coronavirus survey, 64 percent of Americans have avoided getting needed medical care because they were afraid of the unknown cost. One in five Americans has medical debt in collections, and one-third has debt due to medical expenses.

Why is the physical and financial health of Americans on the line, while the healthcare industry thrives?

In addition to receiving a $100 billion bailout, nearly two-thirds of our nation’s hospitals don’t pay any taxes. In exchange for paying zero income, property, or sales tax, these “nonprofits” are supposed to provide charitable care to the sick and poor.

Instead, hospitals sue low-income patients for medical debt, garnish the wages of persons living paycheck to paycheck, and even put liens on personal property.

Mary Washington Hospital in Virginia garnished the wages of more than 1,500 low-income patients last year alone. Over a period of just five years, Methodist Le Bonheur Healthcare, a nonprofit healthcare system in Memphis, filed more than 8,300 lawsuits against its poor patients for unpaid medical bills. Coffeyville Regional Medical Center, a nonprofit hospital in rural Kansas, went as far as to sue patients for not paying their bills, which resulted in jail time for some patients.

Even John Hopkins University, an institution well respected for innovation and coronavirus tracking, was egregiously suing patients.

Adding insult to injury, nonprofit hospitals likely pay their attorneys – prominent law firms paid hefty sums to chase down unpaid debt from vulnerable persons – with the taxpayer dollars that keep their doors open. Patients, in turn, are at times paying the legal fees of the lawyers they are forced to go up against in court.

As the economy struggles under the weight of a life-threatening virus, and as Americans fight for their health and the health of their loved ones, it is time for the hospital industry to redirect its energies and resources toward combating this national crisis, rather than adding to it.

Cynthia A. Fisher is a life sciences entrepreneur, Founder & Chairman of PatientRightsAdvocate.org, and the founder and former CEO of ViaCord, Inc.

A+
a-

In The News

Health

Voting

June 12, 2025
by Dan McCue
House Republicans Narrowly Pass Bill to Claw Back PBS, NPR Funding

WASHINGTON — The House voted 214-212, largely along party lines, to cut federal funding for public media and foreign aid,... Read More

WASHINGTON — The House voted 214-212, largely along party lines, to cut federal funding for public media and foreign aid, a move intended to enshrine the first major cuts proposed by President Donald Trump's Department of Government Efficiency. Four Republicans voted with House Democrats against the... Read More

June 12, 2025
by Dan McCue
Senator Pushed, Forced to Floor During Noem Presser in Los Angeles

WASHINGTON — Sen. Alex Padilla, D-Calif., was forcibly removed from Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem’s news conference in Los Angeles... Read More

WASHINGTON — Sen. Alex Padilla, D-Calif., was forcibly removed from Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem’s news conference in Los Angeles on Thursday, and was ultimately forced to the ground as he tried to speak on the immigration raids that have led to protests across the country.... Read More

Kennedy Picks for CDC Panel Proudly Boast Vaccine Skepticism

WASHINGTON — Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has chosen eight new members for the panel of experts that advises... Read More

WASHINGTON — Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has chosen eight new members for the panel of experts that advises the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention on vaccine policy, including a number of well-known vaccine skeptics. The panel, the CDC Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices,... Read More

June 12, 2025
by Tom Ramstack
Senate Aviation Bill Seeks to Prevent Helicopter-Airline Collisions 

WASHINGTON — A Senate committee that oversees aviation safety is considering legislation intended to prevent the kind of collision that... Read More

WASHINGTON — A Senate committee that oversees aviation safety is considering legislation intended to prevent the kind of collision that killed 67 people at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport in January. The collision resulted from an American Airlines regional jet slamming into an Army Black Hawk... Read More

June 12, 2025
by Dan McCue
Road Closures Mounting as Army’s 250th Birthday Parade Approaches

WASHINGTON — Road closures are beginning to mount in and around downtown D.C. as preparations continue for Saturday’s big 250th... Read More

WASHINGTON — Road closures are beginning to mount in and around downtown D.C. as preparations continue for Saturday’s big 250th birthday parade for the U.S. Army. Constitution Avenue has been mostly closed since Wednesday to accommodate parade preparations, following a similar closure mid-Tuesday on 15th Street... Read More

Brian Wilson, Beach Boys Visionary Leader and Summer's Poet Laureate, Dies at 82

Brian Wilson, the Beach Boys’ visionary and fragile leader whose genius for melody, arrangements and wide-eyed self-expression inspired “Good Vibrations,” “California... Read More

Brian Wilson, the Beach Boys’ visionary and fragile leader whose genius for melody, arrangements and wide-eyed self-expression inspired “Good Vibrations,” “California Girls” and other summertime anthems and made him one of the world’s most influential recording artists, has died at 82. Wilson's family posted news of his... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top