Congress: Listen to Young People on Gun Violence

February 8, 2019 by Mary Sanchez

President Donald Trump neglected to mention gun violence in his State of the Union address.

The following day, the congressional stalemate over what to do about the killing and mayhem played out at a House Judicial Committee hearing on gun violence. Most of the news coverage focused on a disgustingly misleading diatribe from Florida Republican Rep. Matt Gaetz, who tried to use the hearings as a forum to push for a wall at the U.S. southern border.

Overshadowed were the most powerful two speakers to testify before the committee. They were two young women, who happen to be diametrically opposed in their views on gun rights. Both spoke hurriedly, reading statements in the five minutes they were allowed to speak, too brief a span to describe the events that changed their lives.

Savannah Lindquist, 24, testified about what happened to her in the fall of 2016. She was in her senior year at her dream university, she said, finishing up studies in her dream major. Her prospects as a first-generation college graduate looked bright.

Then she was raped. The violence left her “completely shattered.”

Lindquist did what so many other college women do after they are sexually assaulted. She dropped out, fleeing not only to her childhood home but to her childhood bedroom. Isolated and deeply traumatized, she gained 100 pounds and her hair began to fall out.

Lindquist, a gun owner, told the committee that she had obeyed the laws of her state and did not carry a concealed firearm on campus.

“Because of so-called common-sense gun control laws, I was left defenseless that night,” Lindquist testified.

She asked the committee at least to consider the concerns of conscientious gun owners, people who might be negatively affected by new restrictions.

“I obeyed the law as a responsible gun owner, and it ended in me being raped,” she said.

Aalayah Eastmond, 18, spoke before Lindquist.

Her story is likely more familiar. She’s a senior at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Fla.

Nearly a year ago, on February 14, 2018, a gunman killed 17 students and faculty at her school. Eastmond survived by hiding under the dead body of her classmate.

One moment Nicholas Dworet was her partner during their studies of the Holocaust in their fourth period class. The next, he was a lifeless shield that protected Eastmond as “bullets riddled my classmates,” she said.

Eastmond told of how her mother, consumed by the stress, miscarried a baby shortly after her daughter so narrowly escaped death.

She accurately noted that African-American and Latino communities suffer the highest rates of deaths by gun homicide. She lost an uncle who was shot and killed in Brooklyn at the age of 18.

“Rather than listen to special interests, I urge you to listen to America’s young people,” Eastmond told the Judiciary Committee.

Lindquist had a message too. “In this debate, it is about emotion,” she said. Facts and viewpoints like hers, matter less.

The two young women were seated side-by-side. They clearly heard the power of each other’s testimony.

There is a way for Congress to fairly address both women.

And that is to remain focused on gun violence as a public health crisis rather than as a political talking point.

Nearly 40,000 Americans died by guns in 2017. They were shot in homicides, in acts of domestic violence and in accidents, which are nearly always preventable. And the largest category gun deaths is suicides.

One of the outrageous aspects of our national problem with gun violence is how haphazardly it has been studied. The data sets we have are incomplete and in some cases cherry-picked. It is not an exaggeration to say that the gun lobby has consistently undercut government funding for research into gun violence.

Amid the lack of statistical understanding, gun rights zealots have spread a lot of nonsense about the effectiveness of gun-free zones. They also like to moan that “laws already on the books” have failed to stop some dangerously mentally ill person whenever it’s convenient to explain away a mass killing, without mentioning their strenuous efforts to defang any law that might keep guns out of the hands of anybody, no matter how risky.

Eastmond believes that is going to change. “We are the generation that will end gun violence,” she told the committee.

That may well be true. But only if young people continue showing up, speaking out and being more honest about gun violence than their elders.

Readers can reach Mary Sanchez at [email protected] and follow her on Twitter @msanchezcolumn.


In The News




Becerra Confirmation Crucial to Addressing Health Inequities Deepened by the COVID-19 Pandemic
Becerra Confirmation Crucial to Addressing Health Inequities Deepened by the COVID-19 Pandemic

The fight against the COVID-19 pandemic has become more complicated, despite the breakneck speed of vaccine development. The country is facing the dual challenges of combating the spread of new variants of the virus while coordinating a nationwide vaccination effort. The need for strong health care... Read More

How to Spot the Moderate
How to Spot the Moderate
February 20, 2021
by How to Spot the Moderate

Can you spot the moderate? Ok, not Joe Manchin. That’s too easy. Spot the other one. You found her! Rep. Sharice Davids, the first congressional Democrat from Kansas in a decade was recently re-elected to her second term. A former mixed martial artist and lawyer, she... Read More

Stop Protecting Big Banks: End the War on Cryptocurrencies
Stop Protecting Big Banks: End the War on Cryptocurrencies

On the day President Joe Biden was sworn into office, he ordered a freeze on the blizzard of last-minute rules that the Trump Administration tried to ram through in its final days. They were a grab bag of favors to Republican special interests and big business... Read More

Macron is Becoming Everything Trump Should Have Been
Macron is Becoming Everything Trump Should Have Been
February 16, 2021
by Rachel Marsden

The gatekeepers of the establishment status quo don’t have Donald Trump to kick around anymore. Except that Trump’s voters — more than 74 million of them — aren’t going anywhere. These are people who chose Trump despite all of the daily shenanigans, tweets and drama, and... Read More

Trump is History; it’s Biden who’s Changing America
Trump is History; it’s Biden who’s Changing America
February 15, 2021
by Robert B. Reich

While most of official Washington has been consumed with the Senate impeachment trial, another part of Washington is preparing the most far-ranging changes in American social policy in a generation. Congress is moving ahead with President Joe Biden’s American Rescue Plan, which expands health care and... Read More

Vaccine Education is the Key to Saving Our Communities
Vaccine Education is the Key to Saving Our Communities

All eyes are on the vaccine rollout. We’ve all observed the challenges our government has faced supplying and distributing vaccines, as well as some of the early learnings. It would be easy to point fingers or poke holes in the perceived lack of progress. We could... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top