Asian American Judge Challenges Racism Inherent in ‘Equity’
COMMENTARY

March 31, 2021 by John Kass
Asian American Judge Challenges Racism Inherent in ‘Equity’
John Kass

Have you read, heard or seen that important news story about an Asian American federal judge — born in Taiwan and subject to discrimination growing up — who confronted and denounced those who discriminate by race?

No?

With all that’s been in the news lately about terrible anti-Asian attacks, with many pundits engaging, isn’t it odd that the stirring congressional testimony of an Asian American federal judge on a hot-button topic wouldn’t receive widespread national media attention?

His name is James C. Ho. He was born in Taipei, came to America as a toddler and graduated with honors from Stanford University and with high honors from the University of Chicago Law School. He is on the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals, based in Louisiana.

Ho recently testified in a House Judiciary Committee hearing called by U.S. Rep. Ted Lieu, a California Democrat, on the lack of racial diversity on the federal bench.

Ho suggests what many Asian Americans believe to be true in their bones, that the reason for that disparity is generations of discrimination at the nation’s most prestigious universities.

In his testimony, Ho told a story common to many of us from immigrant families.

“Most kids grow up learning English from their parents,” he said. “I grew up learning English from a bunch of puppets, from a place called Sesame Street. My classmates brought a kids’ lunch box to school. I brought a bento box to school. My food seemed normal to me. But it smelled funny to my classmates — or so they would tell me. And I remember racial slurs and jokes on the playground and on the football field.

“But I also learned that, if you work hard and prove yourself, you can find your place in America.”

Judge Ho still experiences racist hate. He says racism isn’t over. Yet he understands the dangers of categorizing, dividing, rewarding or punishing Americans by the use of immutable characteristics like skin pigment.

This is the definition of racism. This is what racists do.

He argues that equality of opportunity, not of outcomes, is fundamental to who we are as Americans.

He also argues that the new policy of “equity” pushed by the Democratic Party — that attempts to guarantee outcomes on the basis of race — is poisonous and racist.

Equality of opportunity, said Ho, means two things:

“It means we must do everything we can to ensure that everyone truly has the opportunity to succeed. And it means we must never bend the rules to favor anyone. Dr. King had it right: Choose people based on who they are, not what they look like.

“We must make sure that everyone has the opportunity to learn and to succeed, so that win, lose or draw, at least you got a chance — no matter who you are …

“But here’s the kicker: Once everyone has had full and fair opportunity to be considered, you pick on the merits. Both the Constitution and the Civil Rights Act make it clear that it is wrong to hire people based on race. That’s the law for a wide range of jobs. But it would be especially wrong to select judges based on race.”

Ho is the only Asian American on his court. He is the only immigrant on his court.

“But I would never suggest that a wise Asian would, more often than not, reach a better conclusion than a white judge,” he said. “That would be antithetical to our legal system and poisonous to civil society. No one should ever assume that I’m more likely to favor Asians or immigrants or anyone else — or that my colleagues are less likely to. Everyone should win or lose based on the law, period. That’s why Lady Justice wears a blindfold. That’s why judges wear black robes.”

Stop and consider how quickly we’re being herded down this poisonous path where “equality” is replaced by “equity.” The similar-sounding words are offered up, confusingly, on a regular basis without context in “straight” news media accounts and by Democratic Party politicians as if they were one and the same.

They’re not the same. Only one is about opportunity for all, which is why a poor immigrant from postwar Europe, who plowed his fields with a mule, could see one of his American-born sons rise in government service and another become a newspaper columnist. It is why Judge Ho’s parents came to America.

In high school, Ho’s college admissions adviser told him that his grades and test scores were “all strong enough to get me into my top choice of schools — if I wasn’t Asian.”

“I come to my views because racism is not behind us,” he said. “The last thing we should do is divide people by race. The last thing we should do is suggest the racists are right. We don’t achieve equality of opportunity by denying it to anyone — we achieve it by securing it for everyone.

“So make no mistake: It would be profoundly offensive — and un-American — to tell the world you’re restricting a judgeship to members of only one race. It’s offensive to people of other races. And it’s offensive to people of that race because you’re suggesting the only way they’ll get the job is if you rig the rules in their favor.”

Ho is a conservative. If you didn’t read about his comments in the news or hear or see them on radio or TV, you might want to ask yourself: Why not?

It is the message or the messenger?

It just might be both.

©2021 Chicago Tribune. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

A+
a-

In The News

Health

Voting

Opinions

New Poll Results Show Americans Are Concerned About Political Division and What Can Be Done to Fix It

As we head into this election year with a likely rematch between two relatively unpopular candidates, it may seem political divisions... Read More

As we head into this election year with a likely rematch between two relatively unpopular candidates, it may seem political divisions are higher than ever. Many controversial issues like immigration, taxes and debate over foreign aid dominate the news, so much so that many Americans may think... Read More

Ensuring Equity and Innovation in Kidney Care: a Call to Action During National Kidney Month

When you woke up this morning, you probably turned on the light, maybe looked at your phone or went to... Read More

When you woke up this morning, you probably turned on the light, maybe looked at your phone or went to get a glass of water, all without much thought. Electricity, phone service and running water are all essentials that we give little thought to until they’re... Read More

The American Rescue Plan Is (Still) Worth Celebrating

Just three years ago, our economy was in the midst of an unprecedented crisis. Communities across the nation were reeling... Read More

Just three years ago, our economy was in the midst of an unprecedented crisis. Communities across the nation were reeling not only from the health implications of the COVID pandemic, but also from high unemployment, business closures and frightening economic uncertainty. Bold and decisive action was... Read More

Cutting Through the Generative AI Noise: What Business Leaders Should Do Now

No matter what industry you’re in, there are two things that every business leader cares about: revenue growth and cost reduction. These are the... Read More

No matter what industry you’re in, there are two things that every business leader cares about: revenue growth and cost reduction. These are the metrics that CEOs talk about ad nauseam during earnings calls. They are the keys that unlock higher business valuations, individual performance bonuses and the ever elusive... Read More

Shield Our Eyes: Lawmakers Across the Country Must Ensure Eye Surgery Can Only Be Performed by Medical Eye Surgeons 

Training and experience matter, especially when health is on the line. Just as one would rightly be concerned to discover... Read More

Training and experience matter, especially when health is on the line. Just as one would rightly be concerned to discover a flight attendant, rather than a pilot, flying their airplane, so too would most people be alarmed to find the person performing surgery on and around... Read More

Fentanyl Kills More Than 150 Americans Each Day, but Some States Keep Overdose Rescue Medications Out of Reach 

Today’s growing overdose epidemic is being fueled by fentanyl, a synthetic opioid that is 50 times stronger than heroin and 100... Read More

Today’s growing overdose epidemic is being fueled by fentanyl, a synthetic opioid that is 50 times stronger than heroin and 100 times stronger than morphine. In fact, it’s so lethal that only a tiny amount — 2 milligrams, about the size of a pencil tip — can... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top