New Political Maps Pass NC Legislature, Judges Will Now Review

September 18, 2019by Will Doran
North Carolina Gov. Roy Cooper during a debate at WRAL studios in Raleigh, N.C., on October 18, 2016. (Chris Seward/Charlotte Observer/TNS)

RALEIGH, N.C. — North Carolina’s new political maps gained final approval from the N.C. House and Senate on Tuesday. Nearly all Republicans supported them, and Democrats were split.

The maps can’t be vetoed by Gov. Roy Cooper — the state constitution specifically forbids it — but they aren’t necessarily the final word. A panel of judges still gets to weigh in on the maps, which will happen over the coming days, and could potentially order them redrawn yet again.

During a vote Monday night, Republican Sen. Ralph Hise said he thinks the maps meet all the court’s criteria.

“We have drawn these maps without any consideration of partisan data,” Hise, the top Senate redistricting official, told his colleagues Monday. “We have drawn this map without any consideration of racial data.”

The final decision will be up to the same three judges who earlier this month ruled North Carolina’s current legislative maps to be unconstitutional partisan gerrymanders that were drawn in order to disenfranchise Democratic voters and give Republicans outsize influence.

They ordered the legislature to redraw a number of House and Senate districts, ignoring any political data or considerations, and to do so under the strictest rules for transparency North Carolina has ever seen in a redistricting process. That meant, for the first time, the public could see the inner workings of something that normally happens behind closed doors.

The legislature broadcast all its meetings live over the internet. They also live-streamed the screens of the individual computers lawmakers and staffers were using to draw the maps, so people could follow each motion of the cursor on the screen if they wanted. Hundreds of people submitted written comments, and several dozen came to Raleigh for a public hearing Monday afternoon.

“These are the fairest maps, and this was the fairest process, in North Carolina in my lifetime,” Democratic Sen. Jeff Jackson said of the Senate maps.

Jackson, however, still voted against the maps. He said he opposes any political maps drawn by politicians, and “independent redistricting would look just like the process we just went through, except it wouldn’t be politicians doing it.”

Unlike Jackson, though, most Senate Democrats voted for the maps of their chamber after Sen. Dan Blue, the top Democrat, vouched for them. Blue, a former N.C. speaker of the House, has been involved in numerous redistricting efforts in past decades in North Carolina and was in the thick of this one as well.

“I think it was a remarkable experience, especially when you consider the current political climate,” he said.

Only eight of the 21 Democratic senators voted against the Senate maps.

The process was more contentious in the House, however, where there was no such bipartisan agreement when they first passed their maps last Friday.

Most of the maps the House produced were uncontroversial. However, Democrats said they were voting against the whole process due to concerns over a lack of public hearings before the vote, as well as concerns that a group of districts in southeastern North Carolina, along the South Carolina border, had been drawn with political considerations in mind.

“You don’t have to be very astute to know what we are doing in this bill is partisan gerrymandering in the benefit of a member,” Democratic Rep. Joe Sam Queen said Friday before voting against the maps.

Republicans denied that, however and they had enough votes to pass the maps over the Democratic objections.

Current and former officials from one of the southeastern counties in question, Columbus County, came to Monday’s public hearing to oppose the new maps. However, those comments did not lead to any changes in the map.

Republicans and Democrats have rarely agreed on high-profile issues recently, culminating in a controversial budget veto override in the House last week that made national headlines. But talking about the Senate maps specifically, Jackson said he wanted to credit his Senate Republican colleagues for the way the redistricting process played out.

“You did appear to me to be acting in good faith,” Jackson said. “And that’s remarkable in North Carolina, and you deserve recognition for that.”

Two Democrats on the redistricting committee, where the map-making work happened, alluded to attempts by politicians to rig the new districts that they said they caught and shot down.

“I believe we shut down attempts to re-gerrymander districts,” said Democratic Sen. Natasha Marcus.

Marcus voted for the Senate maps. But she later voted against the maps the House put forward.

“I know gerrymandering when I see it and I see it in these proposed House maps,” Marcus said in a tweet Tuesday.

“The court’s ruling against partisan gerrymandering was a historic victory for the people of North Carolina, setting a clear requirement for drawing districts completely free from partisan politics and with total transparency,” Brent Laurenz, deputy director of Common Cause NC, which helped challenge the old maps, said in a statement. “We look forward to the next steps in this ongoing remedial process, which includes the court thoroughly reviewing the new districts to ensure that they fully comply with the ruling.”


©2019 The News & Observer (Raleigh, N.C.)

Visit The News & Observer (Raleigh, N.C.) at

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

State News

San Francisco Elects an Underdog as Next DA State News
San Francisco Elects an Underdog as Next DA

When Chesa Boudin learned he had won a tight race to become San Francisco’s new district attorney, he was flying home from a visit with his father at a prison in upstate New York. Boudin was 14 months old when his left-wing activist parents were incarcerated... Read More

Ohio Judge Rules In Favor of Late-Jailed Voters Voting
Ohio Judge Rules In Favor of Late-Jailed Voters
November 8, 2019
by Dan McCue

A federal judge in Ohio ruled the state must discontinue its practice of disenfranchising eligible voters who are arrested and held in pre-trial detention in the final days leading up to an election. The case has its roots in the 2018 midterm election. Just days before... Read More

North Carolina Governor Vetoes Voting Restrictions, Restores Saturday Voting State News
North Carolina Governor Vetoes Voting Restrictions, Restores Saturday Voting
November 8, 2019
by Dan McCue

North Carolina Gov. Roy Cooper vetoed a bill earlier this week that would have removed foreign citizens from voting rolls. At the same time, he signed into law a bill that restores early voting on the last Saturday before elections. “Only citizens should be allowed to... Read More

Republicans Urge Bevin to Provide Proof of Election Fraud or Concede State News
Republicans Urge Bevin to Provide Proof of Election Fraud or Concede

LEXINGTON, Ky. — A growing number of Republican lawmakers are urging Kentucky Gov. Matt Bevin, a fellow Republican, to either provide evidence of the voting “irregularities” he has alleged or concede Tuesday’s election to Gov.-elect Andy Beshear, who defeated him by 5,189 votes. “The best thing... Read More

City Moves Toward Ban on Conversion Therapy for LGBTQ Youth State News
City Moves Toward Ban on Conversion Therapy for LGBTQ Youth

KANSAS CITY, Mo.—Kansas City took a step Wednesday toward becoming the second city in Missouri to ban conversion therapy for minors following more than an hour of emotional testimony from a packed room of LGBTQ residents and advocates. Conversion therapy, often associated with religious groups, is... Read More

Democrat Beshear Declares Victory in Race for Ky. Governor State News
Democrat Beshear Declares Victory in Race for Ky. Governor

LEXINGTON, Ky. — Kentucky voters appeared to reject Gov. Matt Bevin on Tuesday, bucking a statewide Republican trend as they turned their backs on a politician known as much for his blustery personality as his conservative values. Democrat Andy Beshear, who ran a campaign as the... Read More

Straight From The Well
scroll top