McGahn Defies Subpoena, No-Show at House Hearing

May 21, 2019 by Dan McCue

House Judiciary Chairman Jerrold Nadler, D-N.Y., on Tuesday opened the panel’s hearing on Russia interference in the 2016 election by warning the visibly absent former White House Counsel Don McGahn that he will be held in contempt for failing to appear despite the committee’s subpoena.

“Our subpoenas are not optional,” Nadler said as he stared down the empty witness chair and the placard reading “Mr. Donald F. McGahn II.”

Nadler went on to say the House Judiciary Committee will hear from McGahn one way or another, adding “The committee will have no choice but to enforce the subpoena against him.”

“We will not allow the president to stop this investigation,” the chairman added.

Nadler later issued subpoenas to McGahn’s former chief of staff, Annie Donaldson, and former White House communications director Hope Hicks.

Spectators said they turned out for the Tuesday’s brief hearing just to take in the sight of the empty chair and the verbal fireworks they knew would follow the banging of the chairman’s gavel.

President Donald Trump ratcheted up the clash between the executive branch and Capitol Hill on Monday by instructing McGahn to ignore the committee’s subpoena.

That directive came soon after the Justice Department released a 15-page legal opinion arguing the former White House counsel had no legal obligation to comply.

“Congress may not constitutionally compel the President’s senior advisers to testify about their official duties,” the Office of Legal Counsel opinion stated.

It continued: “The immunity of the President’s immediate advisers from compelled congressional testimony on matters related to their official responsibilities has long been recognized and arises from the fundamental workings of the separation of powers.”

In a written statement released Monday night, White House spokeswoman Sarah Sanders said “this action has been taken … to ensure that future presidents can effectively execute the responsibilities of the Office of the Presidency.”

Democrats on the judiciary panel contend that it is important to hear from McGahn so that they can better understand the president’s handling and statements related to Special Counsel Robert Mueller’s probe of Russian election interference and possible collusion with members of the Trump campaign.

But Representative Doug Collins, R-Ga., the ranking Republican on the committee said Tuesday’s hearing was little more than a “circus”.

Democrats are “trying desperately to make something out of nothing,” he said.

The committee voted to adjourn the hearing following Collins’ remarks.

McGahn’s refusal to testify is just the latest move by the White House to block Democratic investigations into the administration, its ties to Russia, and the president’s outside business activities.

The House Judiciary Committee voted to hold Attorney General William Barr in contempt earlier this month after he declined to provide an unredacted version of special counsel Mueller’s report.

The House intelligence committee is expected to vote on a separate “enforcement action” against the Justice Department this week after Barr declined a similar request from it.

McGahn’s lawyer, William Burck, said in a letter to Nadler that McGahn is “conscious of the duties he, as an attorney, owes to his former client” and would decline to appear Tuesday.

But Burck went on to suggest that there’s room to negotiate with the White House over his client’s testimony.

He said McGahn “again finds himself facing contradictory instructions from two co-equal branches of government.”

In a Monday night letter to McGahn, Nadler promised to use “all enforcement mechanisms” available to force McGahn to testify, threatening “serious consequences” if he did not show up.

McGahn was a key figure in Mueller’s investigation and is cited 157 times in the special counsel’s report — more than any other interviewee. Democrats hope to question him as a way to focus attention on Mueller’s findings and further investigate whether Trump did obstruct justice.

Tuesday’s brief hearing took place against a backdrop of increasing calls for the judiciary committee to start a formal impeachment inquiry against the president.

During a closed door Democratic leadership meeting on Monday afternoon, at least five attendees pressed House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., to allow such a step, arguing, according to the Washington Post, that it “would help investigators obtain documents and testimony Trump has blocked.”

Nadler met separately with Pelosi after the session and also reportedly made the case for starting such an inquiry.

Afterwards he said, “the president’s continuing lawless conduct is making it harder and harder to rule out impeachment or any other enforcement action.”

So far, Pelosi has been content to take a methodical approach to the House’s running battles with the president, saying witnesses should be called, subpoenaed if they fail to appear, and then, if they still defy Congress, that matter should be turned over to the courts.

Democrats got an indication this strategy is working Monday night when a federal judge ruled against Trump on Monday in a financial records dispute with the House. Trump’s team filed notice Tuesday that they would appeal.

In the meantime, calls for Trump’s impeachment became bipartisan for the first time Saturday, when Representative Justin Amash, R-Mich., said it’s clear from the Mueller report the president committed obstruction of justice during the special counsel’s investigation.

On Monday, the House Freedom Caucus, a conservative Republican caucus, voted to formally condemn Amash.

On Tuesday, Amash refused to bow to such pressure, saying he hasn’t ruled out challenging Trump for the White House as a Libertarian.

As for McGahn, a contempt vote is not expected to take place until June, as Congress is about to leave town for a weeklong recess.

Political News

Mulling Presidential Run, Mark Sanford Says Government’s Precarious Finances Are Nation’s Biggest Threat Political News
Mulling Presidential Run, Mark Sanford Says Government’s Precarious Finances Are Nation’s Biggest Threat
August 16, 2019
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON - Back home in South Carolina after a mid-week trip to New Hampshire, former Rep. Mark Sanford said Friday he was pleased with how things went in the Granite State and his decision on whether to mount a primary challenge against President Trump will be... Read More

Trump, Battered In New Poll, Says 'Love Me Or Hate Me' You Have to Vote For Me Political News
Trump, Battered In New Poll, Says 'Love Me Or Hate Me' You Have to Vote For Me
August 16, 2019
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON - With polls suggesting his disapproval rating is near an all-time high, President Donald Trump told attendees at a boisterous New Hampshire campaign rally Thursday night they had to vote for him "whether you love me or hate me." A Fox News survey on Wednesday... Read More

Trump Administration Hits Brakes On Law To Curb Unneeded Medicare CT Scans, MRIs Political News
Trump Administration Hits Brakes On Law To Curb Unneeded Medicare CT Scans, MRIs

Five years after Congress passed a law to reduce unnecessary MRIs, CT scans and other expensive diagnostic imaging tests that could harm patients and waste money, federal officials have yet to implement it. The law requires that doctors consult clinical guidelines set by the medical industry... Read More

Nation’s Top Cops Ask Congress To Ban Assault Weapons In The News
Nation’s Top Cops Ask Congress To Ban Assault Weapons

LOS ANGELES — After back-to-back mass shootings killed at least 31 people and injured dozens more in Texas and Ohio, police chiefs in the nation’s largest cities, including Los Angeles, called on the nation’s top lawmakers to enact another ban on assault weapons and other measures... Read More

All Those Presidential Promises? Democrats Better Win The Senate Too 2020 Elections
All Those Presidential Promises? Democrats Better Win The Senate Too

The Democrats running for president are promising the sun, the stars and a full moon to boot. Elect me, they say, and I’ll deliver high-quality healthcare for all. Affordable college. A tax system that rewards hard work and not just the well-off and well-connected. And on.... Read More

Hickenlooper Ends Presidential Bid With An Eye Toward U.S. Senate Seat Political News
Hickenlooper Ends Presidential Bid With An Eye Toward U.S. Senate Seat
August 15, 2019
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON - Former Colorado Gov. John Hickenlooper dropped out of the race for the Democratic presidential nomination Thursday, fueling speculation that he will now set his sights on a U.S. Senate bid. Hickenlooper, 67, ran as a moderate, but never made any headway in a crowded... Read More

Straight From The Well
scroll top