Missouri Lawsuit Over Realtor Fees In Home Sales Draws Justice Department’s Interest

October 4, 2019by Steve Vockrodt

KANSAS CITY, Mo. — Lawyers in the Justice Department’s antitrust division are taking a keen interest in a Missouri class action lawsuit that alleges a conspiracy among national real estate brokers to charge inflated fees, noting in a filing this week that it is investigating the matter.

A pair of Kansas City law firms earlier this year sued major residential real estate brokerage firms on behalf of Missourians who sold a house since April 2015, arguing that common practices among real estate agents stifle competition and harm owners.

Specifically, the lawsuit took aim at requirements that seller’s pay the buyer’s broker a commission, often an amount at or around 6% of the sale price of a house. It also accuses brokerage firms of charging inflated commissions more generally.

The lawsuit also challenges multiple listing services, which are databases of houses that are bought and sold and only accessible to buyers and sellers represented by real estate agents. Those agents have to follow National Association of Realtors rules, including the agreement that sellers pay commissions of a buyer’s agent.

The Missouri lawsuit is similar to one filed in Illinois that some observers have said could put the business model of residential real estate brokerages at risk.

The NAR, a trade group for real estate brokers, filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit. The NAR claimed in part that the Justice Department had given its blessing to the rules that limit access to multiple listing services when the two parties resolved a dispute in 2008.

The Justice Department this week, in a rare filing of its type in a civil case, said the NAR had inaccurately portrayed the 2008 settlement.

A spokesperson for the NAR did not return a message seeking comment on the matter.

“It cannot be overstated how damaging this is to the NAR’s credibility with the court,” said Brandon Boulware, a Kansas City attorney representing plaintiffs against NAR and other brokerage houses.

A footnote in that filing acknowledged that the Justice Department had issued a civil investigative demand — an official request for records or information in an investigation — relating to an investigation into residential real estate brokerages.

The footnote did not specify the precise nature of the demand, but the Justice Department does not usually disclose the existence of its investigations.

The Justice Department’s interest in the case, as well as its initial steps taken to investigate the matter, suggests that it’s watching the Missouri case closely.

———

©2019 The Kansas City Star (Kansas City, Mo.)

Visit The Kansas City Star (Kansas City, Mo.) at www.kansascity.com

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

Litigation

Telecommute Taxation: States Take Sides Over Out-of-State Income Tax Dispute
State News
Telecommute Taxation: States Take Sides Over Out-of-State Income Tax Dispute
January 13, 2021
by Reece Nations

CONCORD, N.H. — A collection of 14 states have now signed amicus briefs backing New Hampshire in the state’s appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court to determine whether jurisdictions may tax the income of remote workers who cannot commute to their workplaces.  In October, New Hampshire... Read More

Former Trump Campaign Lawyer Sued by Voting Machine Company
Litigation
Former Trump Campaign Lawyer Sued by Voting Machine Company
January 8, 2021
by Tom Ramstack

WASHINGTON -- Voting machine manufacturer Dominion Voting Systems Corp. sued former Trump campaign lawyer Sidney Powell Friday in a lawsuit seeking $1.3 billion in damages for defamation. The lawsuit called Powell’s accusations that Dominion fraudulently deleted or changed votes to defeat President Donald Trump in the... Read More

Brindisi, Tenney Race May Not Be Decided Before Start of 117th Congress
State News
Brindisi, Tenney Race May Not Be Decided Before Start of 117th Congress
December 22, 2020
by Dan McCue

Continued delays in the review of ballots cast two months ago in one New York county could mean the state's 22nd Congressional District will go without representation at the start of 117th Congress in January. During a State Supreme Court hearing on Monday, officials from Oneida... Read More

Court Case in Texas Shows DACA Program Remains Under Peril
Immigration
Court Case in Texas Shows DACA Program Remains Under Peril

HOUSTON (AP) — A Tuesday court hearing over a U.S. program shielding immigrants brought to the country illegally as children highlights the peril the program still faces even under an incoming Democratic president who has pledged to protect it. A federal judge in Houston will hear arguments... Read More

Groups Sue 4 Georgia Counties Over Early Voting for Senate Runoff Election
State News
Groups Sue 4 Georgia Counties Over Early Voting for Senate Runoff Election

ATLANTA — Voting rights groups have filed lawsuits against four Georgia counties for failing to offer sufficient early voting for the Jan. 5 runoff election. The New Georgia Project and Democracy Docket say Bibb, Clarke, Houston and Paulding counties are not offering early voting on a... Read More

Trump Allies File Emergency Petition at Supreme Court Over 2020 Election
Political News
Trump Allies File Emergency Petition at Supreme Court Over 2020 Election

WASHINGTON — Weeks after President Donald Trump said the Supreme Court should decide whether to throw out millions of ballots in what he dubbed a fraudulent election, and with state and federal courts rejecting nearly all his legal team's lawsuits in multiple states, a case from Pennsylvania has limped meekly to... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top