Iowa Supreme Court Ruling Shows Businesses Bear Pandemic Losses

April 25, 2022 by Tom Ramstack
Iowa Supreme Court Ruling Shows Businesses Bear Pandemic Losses
Wakonda Club (Photo via Facebook)

WASHINGTON — An Iowa Supreme Court ruling on Friday that denied insurance coverage for COVID-19 losses to a golf club and a restaurant appears to be a sign of the times in lawsuits coming out of the pandemic.

A day earlier, a Massachusetts court ruled a business could not recover its pandemic losses from its insurer.

In both cases, the businesses were invoking clauses in their all-risk commercial property insurance contracts that said they could be compensated for the loss of use of their businesses after a disaster.

The Iowa court disagreed, saying there was no physical damage that would extend coverage to them.

“Iowa law requires there to be a physical aspect to the loss of the property to satisfy the requirement for a ‘direct physical loss of or damage to property’ included in Wakonda Club’s policy,” the Iowa Supreme Court ruling said.

Wakonda Club sued Selective Insurance Co. of America after shutting down completely in March 2020 and reopening with restrictions in May. Jesse’s Embers’ restaurant sued Western Agricultural Insurance Co. after closing down during the worst of the pandemic.

They were restricted by the governors’ orders on business shutdowns to carry-out, drive-through and delivery service.

The Iowa and Massachusetts rulings last week were not the first to reach final rulings but they demonstrate a trend that leaves little doubt insurance companies are winning nationwide.

Typically, the businesses that sue describe the pandemic as similar to a natural disaster, like a hurricane or flood.

The insurance companies, along with the courts, say there is a fundamental difference. The loss of use after a hurricane or flood normally means the buildings or equipment used by a business are damaged.

The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court became the first state high court to reach the same conclusion last week in agreeing with an insurer in a lawsuit by three restaurants. Additional pandemic-related lawsuits by business owners are pending in state high courts in Vermont, Wisconsin, Washington and Ohio.

One of the first cases to require direct physical damage before insurance coverage could begin was Rose’s 1, LLC, et al. v. Erie Insurance Exchange in Washington, D.C.

The restaurant argued that by complying with a city health department order to shut down, it fulfilled the requirement for physical damage to trigger its insurance coverage.

In an Aug. 6, 2020 ruling, a judge said that government orders to quarantine compelled businesses to take certain actions but “did not affect any direct change to the properties.”

The cases are Wakonda Club v. Selective Insurance Co. of America and Jesse’s Embers LLC v. Western Agricultural Insurance Co. in the Supreme Court of Iowa.

Tom can be reached at [email protected].

A+
a-
  • COVID-19
  • Iowa Supreme Court
  • pandemic losses
  • Wakonda Club
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Litigation

    March 28, 2024
    by Tom Ramstack
    Disney World Settles with Florida After Its Opposition to 'Don’t Say Gay' Law

    ORLANDO — The company that runs Walt Disney World reached a settlement Wednesday with appointees of Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis... Read More

    ORLANDO — The company that runs Walt Disney World reached a settlement Wednesday with appointees of Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis who were exerting controversial regulatory control over the huge tourism complex. The settlement resolves some of the disputes that arose after Disney officials publicly denounced the... Read More

    March 14, 2024
    by Tom Ramstack
    Jewish Group Sues UN Relief Agency Saying It Supports Hamas Terrorism

    WILMINGTON, Del. — A Jewish advocacy group sued a United Nations relief agency Wednesday in Delaware for allegedly helping Hamas... Read More

    WILMINGTON, Del. — A Jewish advocacy group sued a United Nations relief agency Wednesday in Delaware for allegedly helping Hamas in its war with Israel and the murders of Israelis and Americans. The National Jewish Advocacy Center says U.N. relief workers who were supposed to be... Read More

    New York AG Says She’ll Seize Trump’s Property if He Can’t Pay $454M Civil Fraud Debt

    NEW YORK (AP) — Donald Trump could be at risk of losing some of his prized properties if he can’t... Read More

    NEW YORK (AP) — Donald Trump could be at risk of losing some of his prized properties if he can’t pay his staggering New York civil fraud penalty. With interest, he owes the state nearly $454 million — and the amount is going up $87,502 each day until... Read More

    February 16, 2024
    by Tom Ramstack
    Environmentalists Sue EPA for Data on Health Risks of Forever Chemicals

    WASHINGTON — Environmentalists sued the Environmental Protection Agency this week in federal court in Washington, D.C., seeking information about health... Read More

    WASHINGTON — Environmentalists sued the Environmental Protection Agency this week in federal court in Washington, D.C., seeking information about health risks from forever chemicals in fluorinated plastic containers. The two groups that sued accuse the EPA of withholding information about PFAS. They are called forever chemicals... Read More

    February 6, 2024
    by Dan McCue
    DC Appellate Court Rejects Trump's Immunity Claim

    WASHINGTON — A court of appeals in the District of Columbia has rejected former President Donald Trump’s claim that he... Read More

    WASHINGTON — A court of appeals in the District of Columbia has rejected former President Donald Trump’s claim that he is immune from prosecution for allegedly interfering in the 2020 presidential election. In a unanimous, 57-page ruling, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Circuit Court of... Read More

    February 1, 2024
    by Tom Ramstack
    Trump Lawsuit Over Steele Dossier Dismissed by Judge in London

    LONDON, U.K. — A judge in London dismissed a lawsuit Thursday that former President Donald Trump filed against the British... Read More

    LONDON, U.K. — A judge in London dismissed a lawsuit Thursday that former President Donald Trump filed against the British intelligence agent who wrote the "Steele Dossier" describing his questionable links to the Russian government. Trump’s lawsuit called the accusations lies that hurt his reputation. Judge... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top